WPC  (J}#37pcE QVz" ^#UaqsczJT"u2Fu.eU^\kGSkвsW0ޝwd~v HD?U$12E{!h@"K#0)DhG>ӧKX^x7U*4 tNx7%jvpL+Jn8z?d}ɣD0(GOѦ=8qZб%-d*UY`˭|OܯiD.~4K|siROm#AMw-4:9 ͏XH?7On n\295B9(l҅ s8 +T X67DU>B 0nL 0 i 0Y# 0_| 0&U6  7 0G #! UN. %| M ( N ^ w. 4  m \  `&Times New Roman' United Nations Human Rights Website - Treaty Bodies Database - Document - Jurisprudence - 4nt - Jurisprudence - "Angie Dituri"0Angie Dituri .   <:Default ParaXXX< :Normal (Web) S =jS =jS64Hyperlink    <:FollowedHype    <qy:HTML TypewriK<6X9`(Courier NewK  XXXS\  `&Times New RomanS  <6X9`(Courier New#|x(Es$..       XjXX XXjXX XjHP LaserJet 4000 Series PS0(hH  Z6Times New Roman Regular Xn4)/-EUDas()U  Es!..       XXNXX XXXNXX XXN  _ COMMITTEEAGAINSTTORTURE  N.D.v.France  CommunicationNo32/199520November1995CAT/C/15/D/32/1995ADMISSIBILITY  $  S;   S    Submittedby:N.D.(namedeleted)[representedbycounsel]   Sp S    Allegedvictim:Theauthor p SH S  R  Stateparty:France H Ss p S    Dateofcommunication:24April1995  p     TheCommitteeagainstTorture,establishedunderarticle17oftheConventionagainst 4 TortureandOtherCruel,InhumanorDegradingTreatmentorPunishment,SK S    Meetingon20November1995,  S# S    Adoptsthefollowing:      Decisiononadmissibility  D!   So##l S    1.Theauthorofthecommunicationisa_Zairian_Ԁcitizen,currentlyresidinginFrance.SheclaimsthatherreturntoZairefollowingthedismissalofherapplicationforrefugeestatuswouldviolatearticle3oftheConventionagainstTortureandOtherCruel,InhumanorDegradingTreatmentorPunishment.Sheisrepresentedby_AFIDRA_.S ([#'# S     2.On12September1993,theauthorfiledarequesttoberecognizedasarefugeeinFrance,whichwasrejectedbytheOffice_fran ais_Ԁdeprotectiondes_rfugis_Ԁet_apatrides_Ԁ(FrenchOfficefortheProtectionofRefugeesandStatelessPeople)on16February1994.HerappealwasrejectedbytheCommissiondes_recours_Ԁdes_rfugis_Ԁ(CommissionofAppealinRefugeeMatters)on20June1994.Anewapplicationwasrejectedon22September1994bytheOffice_fran ais_Ԁdeprotectiondes_rfugis_Ԁet_apatrides_Ԁandon8March1995bythe @-(, Commissiondes_recours_Ԁdes_rfugis_.ItappearsthatthedismissaloftheapplicationbytheCommissiondes_recours_Ԁdes_rfugis_Ԁisatpresentsubjectofanappealincassationbeforethe_Conseil_Ԁ_d'Etat_,whichhasnotyetrendereditsjudgement.St S  T  3.Anexpulsionorder(_arrt_Ԁde_reconduite_Ԁen_frontire_)issuedagainsttheauthorisatpresentonappealbeforethe_Conseil_Ԁ_d'Etat_,whichhasnotyetdecidedonthecase.AsecondexpulsionorderagainsttheauthorwasquashedbytheTribunal_administratif_ԀofParis.Sc  ` S    4.Beforeconsideringanyclaiminacommunication,theCommitteeagainstTorturemustdecidewhetherornotitisadmissibleunderarticle22oftheConvention.S'w $  S    5.Article22,paragraph5(b),oftheConventionprecludestheCommitteefromconsideringanycommunication,unlessithasascertainedthatallavailabledomesticremedieshavebeenexhausted;thisruledoesnotapplyifitisestablishedthattheapplicationofdomesticremedieshasbeenorwouldbeunreasonablyprolongedorwouldbeunlikelytobringeffectiverelief.Intheinstantcase,theexpulsionorderagainsttheauthorissubjectofanappealbeforethe_Conseil_Ԁ_d'Etat_.Theauthorhasnotinvokedanycircumstancestoshowthatthisremedywouldbeunlikelytobringeffectiverelief.Moreover,itappearsfromtheinformationsubmittedbytheauthorthatasubsequentexpulsionorderagainstherwasquashedbytheTribunal_administratif_.Inthecircumstances,theCommitteeisatpresentprecludedfromconsideringtheauthor'scommunication.S74 S  SS  6.TheCommitteethereforedecides:S_  S  SS  (a)Thatthecommunication,assubmitted,isinadmissible;S7 S    (b)Thatthisdecisionmaybereviewedunderrule109oftheCommittee'srulesofprocedureuponreceiptofarequestbyoronbehalfoftheauthorcontaininginformationtotheeffectthatthereasonsforinadmissibilitynolongerapply;S!D! S    (c)Thatthisdecisionshallbecommunicatedtotheauthorand,forinformation,totheStateparty.S[$$X S    [DoneinEnglish,French,RussianandSpanish,theEnglishtextbeingtheoriginalversion.]  (XXXXNH(X   XXHXXNXXX  (XXXXN XXNX(X   Y