WPC  .vH} hHֱf*ÏW,D 7QS-ɿRLwөmHLxK:!hpS*P!Y_hyOIO* stJY (NͷGwan2y?ں_|ƣ0٩2c^Mf!4{SKeD}Npq" ~>U7 "[߁-Fظ5*n ^P!`PrJLiy2 Fg|zC2+=^9]ϔ mtT͕fa5uQ9a:џ뙫zO<r'aYP|, Q%:Á:Ǭ%yuצ㮚B{WrkKg`Zf7|~#Ҩl;7_ @>Pa!(ulZNOx{[c9oE#UN % 0r^ U wa 4e y  m 0J 0 U> U -+ NX UBZ DE U> f a! ! f5 a7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 fK aM M fa ac B-w w w w w w w w w w w w B 0(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX(J$  XXXXXXXXԨp8 p83|xU42ParaNo. 8.9 AIQ!$8S \  `&Times New RomanS8.9 AIQ!$8S \  `&Times New RomanS<SS:Footnote TexS \  `&Times New RomanSS \  `&Times New RomanS\  `&Times New Roman  ##Xd#\  `*Times New RomanTT88889Hairline!dxdx\  `&Times New RomanhTABLE ATABLE BTable_ATABLE A)Hairline d d !  XkqXXXXkqXXXkq  _  XXkq ECUADOR#XkqXȁ#  uFollowupJurisprudence    ActionbyTreatyBodies  _CCPR_ԀA/51/40,vol.I(1996)    VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   ...    429.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasat   26July1996providesthefollowingpicture:   ...   Ecuador:Threeviewsfindingviolations;onefollow-upreplyreceived;norepliesreceivedintwocases. v Follow-upconsultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadortobeconductedduringthefifty-eighth p session. j   ^  _CCPR_ԀA/52/40,vol.I(1997)   VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  524.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof   30June1997providesthefollowingpicture(Viewsinwhichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-up   informationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded):   ... t  Ecuador:FourViewsfindingviolations:238/1987-_Bolanos_(1989Report);17/forStateparty'sfollow-up h  reply,see1990Report,14/vol.II,annexXIIB;277/1988-_Teran_Ԁ_Jijon_(1992Report);4/follow-up b  reply,dated11June1992,unpublished;319/1988-CanonGarcia(1992Report);480/1991-_Fuenzalida_ \  (1996Report);10/Stateparty'sfollow-upreplyinthelattertwocasesremainsoutstanding.Follow-up V consultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadorweretobeconductedduringthesixty-firstsession. P ... D Concernoverinstancesofnon-cooperationunderthefollow-upmandate 8 554.Inspiteofsomeprogressincollectingfollow-upinformationsincetheadoptionofits1996Report, ,| theCommitteeandtheSpecialRapporteurnotewithconcernthatanumberofcountriesdidnotprovide &v anyfollow-upinformationwithinthedeadlinesestablishedbytheCommitteeorhavenotrepliedto  p remindersorrequestsforinformationfromtheSpecialRapporteur.ThoseStateswhichhavenotreplied j torequestsforfollow-upinformationarethefollowing(inalphabeticalorder): d ...  X Ecuador:onecase; !L ... #@  555.TheCommitteeurgesthoseStatespartiestoreplytotheSpecialRapporteur'srequestsforfollow-up %4!" informationwithinthedeadlinesthathavebeenset. &."# ____________ '(#$   4/OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,FortyseventhSession,SupplementNo.40 ("$% (A/47/40). )%&   10/Ibid.,FortyfirstSession,SupplementNo.40(A/51/40). *&'   14/OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,FortyfifthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/45/40). +'(   17/Ibid.,FortyfourthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/44/40). , ()  -)*  _CCPR_ԀA/53/40,vol.I(1998)   VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...   486.TheCommittee'spreviousreport(A/52/40)containedadetailedcountry-by-countrybreakdownof   follow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1997.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollow-upinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates(Viewsin z   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded).Italso t  indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange n  sincethepreviousreport.ThisisbecausetheresourcesavailablefortheCommittee'sworkwere h  considerablyreducedinthecurrentyear,preventingitfromundertakingacomprehensivesystematic b  follow-up_programme_. \  ... P Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987-_Bolanos_(1989Report(A/44/40));forStateparty's D follow-upreply,see1990Report(A/45/40),vol.II,annexXII,B;277/1988-_Teran_Ԁ_Jijon_(1992Report, > A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992,unpublished;319/1988CanonGarcia(1992Report); 8 nofollowupreplyreceived);480/1991_Fuenzalida_(1996Report(A/51/40));481/1991Ortega(1996 2 Report);Statepartysfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,dated9January1998(seepara.497below). ,| FollowupconsultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadorwereconductedduringthesixtyfirst &v session(seepara.493below).  p ... d Ѐ ^ Overviewoffollow-uprepliesreceivedandoftheSpecialRapporteur'sfollow-upconsultationsduringthe  X reportingperiod !R ... "F 493.Ecuador.On30October1997,theSpecialRapporteurmetwiththePermanentRepresentativeof $: ! EcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevatodiscusstheStateparty'sfailuretoimplementthe %4!" Committee'srecommendationsformulatedinitsViewsoncaseNo.480/1991(_Fuenzalida_),andtorequest &."# areplyinrespectoftheCommittee'sViewsincaseNo.481/1991(Ortega).Withregardtothe '(#$ compensationwh_ich_ԀwasrecommendedbytheCommittee,theSpecialRapporteurexplainedthatthe ("$% principleofcompensationcouldnotbechallengedbytheStateparty,butthatitwasfreetodeterminethe )%& levelofcompensation.Ifnolegalbasisexistedforcompensation,theStatepartyshouldmakeexgratia *&' payments.TherepresentativepromisedtoconveytheRapporteur'sconcernstohisGovernment. +'( 494.Inasubmissionof9January1998,theStatepartyprovidesinformationinrespectofthetwocases, -)* whichreadsasabelatedsubmissiononthemerits.Noinformationisprovidedaboutthemeasurestaken,  ifany,bytheStatepartytoimplementtheCommittee'srecommendations.    _CCPR_ԀA/54/40,vol.I(1999)   VII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  461.TheCommittee'spreviousreport(A/53/40)containedadetailedcountry-by-countrybreakdownof   follow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1998.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollow-upinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates(Viewsin   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded).Italso   indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange z   sincethelastreport.ThisisbecausetheresourcesavailablefortheCommittee'sworkhavebeen t  considerablyreducedpreventingitfromundertakingacomprehensivesystematicfollow-up_programme_. n  ... b  Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987-_Bolanos_(A/44/40);forStateparty'sfollow-upreply, V seeA/45/40,vol.II,annexXII,sect.B;277/1988-_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_(A/47/40);follow-upreply,dated11June P 1992,unpublished;319/1988-_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_(A/47/40);nofollow-upreplyreceived;480/1991 J -_Fuenzalida_(A/51/40);481/1991-Ortega(A/52/40);forStateparty'sfollow-upreplyinthelattertwo D casesdated9January1998,seeA/53/40,para.494.Follow-upconsultationswiththePermanentMission > ofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession(see 8 A/53/40,para.493).Forfurtherfollow-upreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,seebelow. 2 ... &v Overviewoffollow-uprepliesreceivedandoftheSpecialRapporteur'sfollow-upconsultationsduringthe j reportingperiod d ...  X 466.Ecuador.Bysubmissionof29January1999,theGovernmentofEcuadorinformedtheCommittee "F thatithadmetwithMr._Villacres_ԀOrtega'srepresentativeon18Januaryinordertocometoafriendly #@  settlementonthebasisoftheCommittee'sViews.Byfurthersubmissionof14April1999,theGovernment $: ! ofEcuadorforwardedtotheCommitteeacopyoftheagreementofcompensationc_oncluded_Ԁwiththe %4!" representativeofMr._Villacres_ԀOrtegaon26February1999.Intheagreement,theStatepartyrecognized &."# itsinternationalresponsibilityforhavingviolatedarticles7and10,paragraph1,intheauthor'scaseand '(#$ agreedtopayhim,within90days,US$25,000fordamages.TheStateparty,moreover,agreedtotake ("$% civil,penalandadministrativeactionagainsttheperpetratorsoftheviolationsandtotakethenecessary )%& stepstobringthemtojusticeandreserveditsrighttoclaimbackfromtheperpetratorstheamountof *&' damagespaid.Forthefulltextoftheagreement,seeannexIX.Asimilaragreementwasconcludedwith +'( Mr.Garcia_Fuenzalida_Ԁon16June1999.  , ()  _CCPR_ԀA/55/40,vol.I(2000)   UKUS.,  XkqXXXkq  XkqXX Xkq j-  VI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL j--݌  ЌXkqXXXkq  # XkqXXXkq-#XkqXX Xkq...   # XkqXXXkq.#XkqXX Xkq596.TheCommitteespreviousreport(A/54/40)containedadetailedcountrybycountrybreakdownof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1999.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollowupinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates.(Viewsin z   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollowupinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded.)Italso t  indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange n  sincethelastreport.ThisisbecausethelimitedresourcesavailablefortheCommitteesworkpreventit h  fromundertakingacomprehensiveorsystematicfollowupprogramme. b  ... V US.,UK.,A-UKUS.,Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987_Bolanos_(A/44/40);forStatepartysfollowupreply, J seeA/45/40,vol.II,annexXII,sect.B;277/1988_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_(A/47/40);followupreply,dated D 11June1992,unpublished;319/1988_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived;480/1991 > _Fuenzalida_(A/51/40);481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);&  FortheStatepartysfollowupreply,dated9 8 January1998,inthelattertwocases,seeA/53/40,para.494.FollowupconsultationswiththePermanent 2 MissionofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthesixtyfirstsession ,| (seeA/53/40,para.493).Forfurtherfollowupreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,see &v A/54/40,para.466.  p '8+5  j  8kqXXdd8   _CCPR_ԀA/56/40,vol.I(2001)   # XkqXXXkq.#XkqXX XkqChapterIV.FollowupActivitiesundertheOptionalProtocolUS.,UK.,2UKUS.,# XkqXXXkq*8#XkqXX Xkq    ...  180.  TheCommitteespreviousannualreport(A/55/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailedcountry   bycountrysurveyonfollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2000.The   listthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnot   takeintoaccounttheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventysecondsession,forwhichfollowup z   repliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesincethepreviousreport. t  ... h  Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987_Bolaos_(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/45/40, \  vol.II,annexXII,sect.B;277/1988_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992, V unpublished;319/1988_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived;480/1991_Fuenzalida_ P (A/51/40);481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,dated9January J 1998,seeA/53/40,paragraph494.FollowupconsultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadorto D theUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession(seeA/53/40,para. > 493).Forfurtherfollowupreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,seeA/54/40,paragraph466.# XkqXXXkq8#US.,UK.,8  8  XkqXX XkqUKUS.,_CCPR_ԀA/57/40,vol.I(2002)   ChapterVI.Followupactivitiesundertheoptionalprotocol  ...  228.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee(A/56/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailed   countrybycountrysurveyoffollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2001.   Thelistthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoes   notincluderesponsesconcerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventyfourthandseventy z   fifthsessions,forwhichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesince t  thepreviousreport. n  ... b    Ecuador:Viewsinfivecaseswithfindingsofviolations: V 238/1987_Bolaos_(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/45/40,vol.US.,UK.,O@II,annexXII,sect.B; J 277/1988_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992,unpublished; > 319/1988_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived; 2 480/1991_Fuenzalida_(A/51/40); &v 481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,dated9January1998,see j A/53/40,paragraph494.FollowupconsultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadortothe d UnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession(seeA/53/40,paragraph ^ 493).Forfurtherfollow-upreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,seeA/54/40,paragraph466.  X ... !L 229.ForfurtherinformationonthestatusofalltheViewsinwhichfollowupinformationremains #@  outstandingorinrespectofwhichfollowupconsultationshavebeenorwillbescheduled,referenceis $: ! madetothefollowupprogressreportpreparedfortheseventy-fourthsessionoftheCommittee %4!" (_CCPR_/C/74/R.7/Rev.1,dated28March2002),discussedinpublicsessionattheCommittees2009th &."# meetingon4April2002(_CCPR_/C/SR.2009).ReferenceisalsomadetotheCommitteesprevious '(#$ reports,inparticularA/56/40,paragraphs182to200. ("$% # XkqXXXkq0@#  )%&  XkqXX XkqCEUS.,_CCPR_ԀA/58/40,vol.I(2003)   CHAPTERVI.FollowupactivitiesundertheOptionalProtocol  ...  223.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountrybycountrysurveyof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2002.Thelistthatfollowsupdates   thatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotincluderesponses   concerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventyseventhandseventyeighthsessions,for z   whichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethepreviousreport.* n  ... b  Ecuador:0 `  Viewsinfivecaseswithfindingsofviolations:V` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#238/1987_Bolaos_(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/45/40,volumeII, J annexXII,sectionB;D (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#277/1988_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992, 8 unpublished;2 (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#319/1988_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived;&v (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#480/1991_Fuenzalida_(A/51/40);j (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,dated ^ 9January1998,seeA/53/40,paragraph494.Followupconsultationswiththe  X PermanentMissionofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawere !R conductedduringthesixty-firstsession(seeA/53/40,para.493).Forfurther !L follow-upreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,seeA/54/40,paragraph "F 466.#@  (# (# Notes %4!" 1.[OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly],FiftyseventhSession,SupplementNo.40(A/57/40), '(#$ vol.I,chap.VI. ("$% *ThedocumentsymbolA/[SessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordoftheGeneralAssembly *&' inwhichthecaseappears;annexVIreferstothepresentreport,vol.II. +'( # XkqXXXkqK#US.,CE.,K  -)* _XkqXX XkqCEUS., _CCPR_ԀA/59/40vol.I(2004)   CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  230.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountry-by-countrysurveyof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2003.Thelistthatfollowsupdates   thatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotincluderesponses   concerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheeightiethandeightyfirstsessions,forwhichfollow z   uprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesincethe t  previousreport.* n  ... b  US.,CE.,W*34 ddd Xdd Xdd X(#(#,UU,UU+  1'VV 1UKUS.,Ecuador:US.,UK.,W\ 'V 'Viewsinfivecaseswithfindingsofviolations: 6,V  6 'h '238/1987_Bolaos_(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/45/40,volumeII, h annexXII,sectionB; 6,b  6 '$ '277/1988_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992, $ unpublished; 6,  6 ' '319/1988_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived; 6,  6 'R '480/1991_Fuenzalida_(A/51/40); 6,R  6 'd '481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases, d dated9January1998,seeA/53/40,paragraph494.Follow-upconsultations ^ withthePermanentMissionofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGeneva  X wereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession(seeA/53/40,para.493).For !R  furtherfollow-upreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,seeA/54/40, !L! paragraph466.$"F"   $CEUS.,_______________ %!# Notes &!$ 1/Ibid.,FiftyeighthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/58/40),vol.I,chap.VI. (#& *ThedocumentsymbolA/[sessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssemblyin *%( whichthecaseappears;annexIXreferstothepresentreport,volumeII. +&) # XkqXXXkqW#US.,CE.,b -(+    XkqXX XkqCEUS., _CCPR_,A/60/40vol.I(2005)   ...  CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   224.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollowuptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forthefollowuponViewstothiseffect.Mr.AndohasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventyfirstsession). t  225.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollowupinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights.Atotalof391Viewsoutofthe503Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehad \  beenaviolationoftheCovenant. V 228.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffectthatthe J CommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitionerhasinformed D theCommitteethattheStatepartyhasinfactgiveneffecttotheCommitteesrecommendations,even > thoughtheStatepartydidnotitselfprovidethatinformation. 8 229.Thepresentannualreportadoptsadifferentformatforthepresentationoffollowupinformation ,| comparedtopreviousannualreports.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollowupreplies &v fromStatespartiesreceivedasof28July2005,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefound  p violationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollowuprepliesareorhavebeen j consideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsofcomplyingwiththeCommitteesViews,orwhether d thedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollowuponViewscontinues.The ^ notesfollowinganumberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollowupreplies.  X 230.FollowupinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentativessince !L thelastannualreportissetoutinanewannexVII,containedinVolumeIIofthepresentannualreport. "F This,moredetailed,followupinformationalsoindicatesactionstilloutstandinginthosecasesthatremain #@  underreview. $: !   '(#$ TRO'3#Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeLaser Ta Landscape3'LetterT   FOLLOWUPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   }q*6D7ed dUUUU34..,'bZ,4bZ, bZ,'bZ,bZ,bZ,bb+  6DD' @6γXXkq# γγd#γ γUS.,CE.,eUKUS.,Statepartyand  numberofcases o withviolation# γγs#γ γUS.,UK.,sCEUS., ;DD,!8 @DD @;# γγ{t#γ γUS.,CE.,tUKUS.,Communicationnumber,  authorand_locationa_# γγ$u#γ γUS.,UK.,]uCEUS., ;DD,!o@DD @;  # γγu#γ γUS.,CE.,/vUKUS.,Followupresponsereceivedfrom   Statepartyandlocation# γγv#γ γUS.,UK.,vCEUS., ;DD,!o @DD @;Satisfactory   response ;DD,!o @DD @;Unsatisfactory   response ;DD,!o@DD @;Nofollowup  response ?DDD,!o@DD @?Followup  dialogue o ongoing IDD:'8 @  DDD @I... ;DD,! a@DD @; ;DD,! a@DD @; ;DD,! a@DD @; ;DD,! a@DD @; ;DD,! a@DD @; ?DDD,! a@DD @? NDD?' a@  DDD @NEcuador(5) ;DD,! :@DD @;238/1987,_Bolaos_  : A/44/40 ;DD,! @DD @;X  : A/45/40 ;DD,! @DD @;X  :  A/45/40 ;DD,! !@DD @; ;DD,! :"@DD @; ?DDD,! :#@DD @? NDD?' :$@  DDD @N ;DD,! %@DD @;277/1988,_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_  & A/47/40 ;DD,!U '@DD @;X  ( A/59/40* ;DD,!U )@DD @; ;DD,! *@DD @;X ;DD,! +@DD @; ?DDD,! ,@DD @?X NDD?' -@  DDD @N CDDD0!.~ .@DD @C*Note:Accordingtothisreport,informationwasprovidedon11June1992,butwasunpublished.ItappearsfromtheFollowupfilethatin .~ / thisresponse,theStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesoftworeportsoftheNationalPoliceontheinvestigationofthecrimesinwhichMr. G 0 _Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_Ԁwasinvolved,includingthestatementshemadeon12March1986concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes. QDDB* 1@  DDD @Q ;DD,! 2@DD @;319/1988,_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_  3 A/47/40 ;DD,!b 4@DD @; ;DD,! 5@DD @; ;DD,! 6@DD @; ;DD,! 7@DD @;X ?DDD,! 8@DD @?X NDD?' 9@  DDD @N ;DD,!; :@DD @;480/1991,_Fuenzalida_ ; ; A/51/40 ;DD,!T<@DD @;X ; = A/53/40,A/54/40 ;DD,!T>@DD @;X ;DD,!; ?@DD @; ;DD,!; @@DD @; ?DDD,!; A@DD @? PDDD?'; B@  DDD @P =DDD,!-C@DDD @=481/1991,_Villacrs_ԀOrtega -D A/52/40 =DDD,!E@DDD @=X -F A/53/40,A/54/40 =DDD,!G@DDD @=X =DDD,!-H@DDD @= =DDD,!-I@DDD @= ?DDDD,!-J@DDD @?7-+-K@   DDDD 7#XkqXγus#aThelocationreferstothedocumentsymboloftheOfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,SupplementNo.40,whichistheannualreport qL oftheCommitteetotherespectivesessionsoftheAssembly. kM # XkqXXXkqfw#US.,CE.,w  YP TRX3'LetterO'3#Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta Landscape3'LetterscapeX3''3Letter LandscapeLaser Ta LandscapeT _CCPR_,A/61/40vol.I(2006)   ...  L  M  L  M  CHAPTERVIFOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   227.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._Ando_ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventy-firstsession). t  228.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights;429Viewsoutofthe547Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehadbeena \  violationoftheCovenant. V 229.Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseandsubjective: J itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies.Manyfollow-up D repliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingnessoftheStatepartyto > implementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantanappropriateremedy.Other 8 repliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddresstheCommitteesViewsatall 2 oronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethatthevictimhasfiledaclaimfor ,| compensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensationcanthereforebepaid.Stillother &v repliesindicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartytoprovidearemedy,butthataremedy  p willbeaffordedtothecomplainantonanL  M  exgratiaL  M  Ԁbasis. j 230.Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualorlegal ^ grounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promiseaninvestigationof  X thematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,foronereasonoranother, !R giveeffecttotheCommitteesViews. !L 231.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffectthatthe #@  CommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitionerhasinformed $: ! theCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommitteesrecommendations,even %4!" thoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. &."# 232.Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-upinformationas ("$% thelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-uprepliesfromStatesparties )%& receivedupto7July2006,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant. *&' Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryor +'( unsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommitteesViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetween , () theStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViewscontinues.TheNotesfollowinga -)* numberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollow-upreplies.  233.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/60/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIofthe  presentannualreport.   TRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeX3'3'LetterscapeX3'TL  M  L  M  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   e*Dded'bZ'4bZ4 bZ 'bZ'bZbZbb6D7e.e.,dd ,dd , dd ,dd ,dd ,edd ,dd +  $ $Stateparty R andnumber L ofcaseswith  F violation ' @ 'L  M  L  M  Communication R number,authorand L  location ' F  'L  M  L  M  Follow-upresponse R  receivedfromStateparty L  andlocation ' F  'L  M  L  M  Satisfactory R response 'L 'L  M  L  M  Unsatisfactory R response 'L 'L  M  L  M  No R follow-up L response  F received ' @ 'L  M  L  M  Follow-up R dialogue L ongoing  F ...  ~    ~    ~    ~    ~    ~    ~  Ecuador(5) & \ CC &L  M  L  M  238/1987,L  M  _Bolaos_L  M    \ ! A/44/40L  M  L  M  L  M   V " L  M  L  M  X  \ # A/45/40L  M  L  M  L  M   V $ L  M  L  M  X  \ % A/45/40  V &    \ '    \ (    \ )   0 ) 277/1988,L  M  _Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_L  M    * A/47/40   + X  , A/59/40*   -    . X   /    0 X   1   1 *L  M  NoteL  M  :Accordingtothisreport,informationwasprovidedon11June1992,butwasnotpublished.Itappearsfromthe l2 Followupfilethatinthisresponse,theStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesL  M  oftworeportsoftheNationalPoliceonthe f3 investigationofthecrimesinwhichMr._Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_Ԁwasinvolved,includingthestatementshemadeon12March1986 `4 concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes.   Z5   45 L  M  L  M  319/1988,L  M  _Ca;n_ 6 _Garca_L  M   7 A/47/40L  M  L  M  L  M   8   9   :   ; X  < X  =   = 480/1991,L  M  _Fuenzalida_L  M   j> A/51/40  d? L  M  L  M  X j@ A/53/40,A/54/40L  M  L  M  L  M   dA X  jB   jC   jD   jE   >E 481/1991,L  M  _Villacrs_ F OrtegaL  M   G A/52/40  H X I A/53/40,A/54/40  J X  K   L   M   N ...  $!tO   $!tP   $!tQ   $!tR   $!tS   $!tT  $!tU     TRX3'LetterO'3Letter Landscape3'Letter 2 480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40)'3Letter LandscapeX3'T _CCPR_,A/62/40vol.I(2007)   ...  CHAPTERVI.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   213.  InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._Ando_ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventy-firstsession). t  214.  In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationofCovenant b  rights;452Viewsoutofthe570Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehadbeenaviolationof \  theCovenant. V 215.  Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseandsubjective: J itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies.Manyfollow-up D repliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingnessoftheStatepartyto > implementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantanappropriateremedy.Other 8 repliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddresstheCommitteesViewsatall 2 oronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethatthevictimhasfiledaclaimfor ,| compensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensationcanthereforebepaid.Stillotherreplies &v indicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartytoprovidearemedy,butthataremedywillbe  p affordedtothecomplainantonanexgratiabasis. j 216.  Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualorlegal ^ grounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promiseaninvestigationofthe  X matterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,foronereasonoranother,give !R effecttotheCommitteesViews. !L 217.  Inmanycases,theCommitteesecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstothe #@  effectthattheCommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitioner $: ! hasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommittees %4!" recommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. &."# 218.  Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-upinformationas ("$% thelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-uprepliesfromStatesparties )%& receivedupto7July2007,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant. *&' Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryor +'( unsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommitteesViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetween , () theStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViewscontinues.TheNotesfollowinganumber -)* ofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollow-upreplies.  219.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/61/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIofthe  presentannualreport.      XRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeX3'3'Letter 2 480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40)ðX  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   M*d ddd dd  dd dd dd edd edd De.e.,/\R,\R,\R,\R,\R,f\R,\\+  8DDD'  8Statepartyand  numberofcases  withviolation =DDD,!DDD =Communication  number,  authorandlocation =DDD,!DDD =Follow-upresponse   receivedfromState   partyandlocation =DDD,! DDD =Satisfactory   response =DDD,! DDD =Unsatisfactory  response =DDD,!DDD =Nofollow-up  response  received ?DDDD,!DDD ?Follow-up  dialogue  ongoing SDDB,  DDDD S... @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ BDDD/! DD B ND?'  DDD NEcuador(5) 4DD# D 4238/1987,_Bolaos_   A/44/40 .DD DD .X    A/45/40 .DD !DD .X  " A/45/40 .DD #DD . .DD $DD . 0DDD %DD 0 ED6 & DDD E 4DD# 'D 4277/1988,_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_  ( A/47/40 4DD#  )DD 4X  * A/59/40* 4DD#  +DD 4 4DD# ,DD 4X 4DD# -DD 4 6DDD# .DD 6X ED6 / DDD E :DDD' 0D :*Note:Accordingtothisreport,informationwasprovidedon11June1992,butwasnotpublished.Itappearsfromthe  1 Followupfilethatinthisresponse,theStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesoftworeportsoftheNationalPoliceonthe  2 investigationofthecrimesinwhichMr._Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_Ԁwasinvolved,includingthestatementshemadeon12March1986  3 concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes. HD9! 4 DDD H 4DD# 5D 4319/1988,_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_  6 A/47/40 4DD#7DD 4 4DD# 8DD 4 4DD# 9DD 4X 4DD# :DD 4 6DDD# ;DD 6X ED6 < DDD E 4DD#=D 4480/1991,_Fuenzalida_ > A/51/40 4DD#?DD 4X @ A/53/40,A/54/40 4DD#ADD 4X B Ѐ 4DD#CDD 4 4DD#DDD 4 6DDD#EDD 6 GDD6F DDD G 4DD#GDD 4481/1991,_Villacrs_ H Ortega I A/52/40 4DD#JDD 4X K A/53/40,A/54/40 4DD#LDD 4X M Ѐ 4DD#NDD 4 4DD#ODD 4 6DDD#PDD 6 9DD(Q DDD 9... +DDRDD + +DDSDD + +DDTDD + +DDUDD + +DDVDD + -DDDWDD -.$"X  DDD .