WPC  u4M`sn|XͬˇSgHTi*8eu3C\s8TrjGbjYitlnOA+ё bh%aYOw?A|lՠln"g[~PQ;^JSF4{Ft6YVWwn\qta b㿝Lt%5= g,` h^bW}zOWq3hy|XeߓHqUF́`tIew[K*=6qZ|W JK؄SCZ?mTg[s:k oբߙZhQ״^|A>8((Y~3 D\[U LMO kS3W.NNnU1`ZÌgp5F?FIMn0bB~5R E#UN % 0r^ U wa 4e y  m 0J 0 U> U -+ NX UBZ DE U> f a! f5 f7 a9 aM fa ac c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c fw ay y f a B- B Brother MFC-490CW Printer0(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX(J$  XXXXXXXX4o;5 1h;3|xU42ParaNo. 8.9 AIQ!$8S \  `&Times New RomanS8.9 AIQ!$8S \  `&Times New RomanS<SS:Footnote TexS \  `&Times New RomanSS \  `&Times New RomanS\  `&Times New Roman  ##Xd#\  `*Times New RomanTT88889Hairline!dxdx\  `&Times New RomanhTABLE ATABLE BTABLE A:TABLE CTable_ATABLE A)Hairline d d !  XHXXXXHXXXH  _  TXXH ECUADOR#XHXT#  uFollowupJurisprudence    ActionbyTreatyBodies  _CCPR_ԀA/51/40,vol.I(1996)  t  VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL L  ... $ t  429.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstanding L  asat26July1996providesthefollowingpicture: 8  ...   Ecuador:Threeviewsfindingviolations;onefollow-upreplyreceived;norepliesreceivedintwo  cases.Follow-upconsultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadortobeconductedduringthe  fifty-eighthsession. p   H _ CCPRA/52/40,vol.I(1997)   VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ... ` 524.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstanding 8  asof30June1997providesthefollowingpicture(Viewsinwhichthedeadlineforreceiptof $ t follow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded):  ` ...  8  Ecuador:FourViewsfindingviolations:238/1987-Bolanos(1989Report);17/forStateparty's   follow-upreply,see1990Report,14/vol.II,annexXIIB;277/1988-TeranJijon(1992Report);4/   follow-upreply,dated11June1992,unpublished;319/1988-CanonGarcia(1992Report);   480/1991-Fuenzalida(1996Report);10/Stateparty'sfollow-upreplyinthelattertwocases   remainsoutstanding.Follow-upconsultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadorweretobe p conductedduringthesixty-firstsession. \ ... 4 Concernoverinstancesofnon-cooperationunderthefollow-upmandate  \ 554.Inspiteofsomeprogressincollectingfollow-upinformationsincetheadoptionofits1996 4 Report,theCommitteeandtheSpecialRapporteurnotewithconcernthatanumberofcountriesdid   notprovideanyfollow-upinformationwithinthedeadlinesestablishedbytheCommitteeorhave   notrepliedtoremindersorrequestsforinformationfromtheSpecialRapporteur.ThoseStateswhich  havenotrepliedtorequestsforfollow-upinformationarethefollowing(inalphabeticalorder):  ... l Ecuador:onecase; D! ... #l! 555.TheCommitteeurgesthoseStatespartiestoreplytotheSpecialRapporteur'srequestsfor $D # follow-upinformationwithinthedeadlinesthathavebeenset. %0!$ ____________ &"%   4/OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,FortyseventhSession,SupplementNo.40 '#& (A/47/40). (#'   10/Ibid.,FortyfirstSession,SupplementNo.40(A/51/40). )$(   14/OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,FortyfifthSession,SupplementNo.40 |*%) (A/45/40). h+&*   17/Ibid.,FortyfourthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/44/40). T,'+ _ @-(,  _CCPR_ԀA/53/40,vol.I(1998)   VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL t ... L  486.TheCommittee'spreviousreport(A/52/40)containedadetailedcountry-by-countrybreakdown $ t offollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1997.Thelistthatfollows  ` showstheadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollow-upinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates  L  (Viewsinwhichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeen  8  included).Italsoindicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasesthere $  hasbeennochangesincethepreviousreport.Thisisbecausetheresourcesavailableforthe   Committee'sworkwereconsiderablyreducedinthecurrentyear,preventingitfromundertakinga   comprehensivesystematicfollow-up_programme_.   ... p Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987-_Bolanos_(1989Report(A/44/40));forState H party'sfollow-upreply,see1990Report(A/45/40),vol.II,annexXII,B;277/1988-_Teran_Ԁ_Jijon_ 4 (1992Report,A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992,unpublished;319/1988CanonGarcia  p (1992Report);nofollowupreplyreceived);480/1991_Fuenzalida_(1996Report(A/51/40));  \ 481/1991Ortega(1996Report);Statepartysfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,dated9 H January1998(seepara.497below).FollowupconsultationswiththePermanentMissionof 4 Ecuadorwereconductedduringthesixtyfirstsession(seepara.493below).   ...  Ѐ  Overviewoffollow-uprepliesreceivedandoftheSpecialRapporteur'sfollow-upconsultations  duringthereportingperiod l ... D! 493.Ecuador.On30October1997,theSpecialRapporteurmetwiththePermanentRepresentative #l! ofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevatodiscusstheStateparty'sfailuretoimplement $X" theCommittee'srecommendationsformulatedinitsViewsoncaseNo.480/1991(_Fuenzalida_),and $D # torequestareplyinrespectoftheCommittee'sViewsincaseNo.481/1991(Ortega).Withregard %0!$ tothecompensationwh_ich_ԀwasrecommendedbytheCommittee,theSpecialRapporteurexplained &"% thattheprincipleofcompensationcouldnotbechallengedbytheStateparty,butthatitwasfreeto '#& determinethelevelofcompensation.Ifnolegalbasisexistedforcompensation,theStateparty (#' shouldmakeexgratiapayments.TherepresentativepromisedtoconveytheRapporteur'sconcerns )$( tohisGovernment. |*%) 494.Inasubmissionof9January1998,theStatepartyprovidesinformationinrespectofthetwo T,'+ cases,whichreadsasabelatedsubmissiononthemerits.Noinformationisprovidedaboutthe @-(, measurestaken,ifany,bytheStatepartytoimplementtheCommittee'srecommendations.   _ CCPRA/54/40,vol.I(1999)   VII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL t 461.TheCommittee'spreviousreport(A/53/40)containedadetailedcountry-by-countrybreakdown L  offollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1998.Thelistthatfollows 8  showstheadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollow-upinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates $ t (Viewsinwhichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeen  ` included).Italsoindicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasesthere  L  hasbeennochangesincethelastreport.ThisisbecausetheresourcesavailablefortheCommittee's  8  workhavebeenconsiderablyreducedpreventingitfromundertakingacomprehensivesystematic $  follow-upprogramme.   ...   Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987-Bolanos(A/44/40);forStateparty'sfollow-up p reply,seeA/45/40,vol.II,annexXII,sect.B;277/1988-TernJij;n(A/47/40);follow-upreply, \ dated11June1992,unpublished;319/1988-Ca;nGarca(A/47/40);nofollow-upreplyreceived; H 480/1991-Fuenzalida(A/51/40);481/1991-Ortega(A/52/40);forStateparty'sfollow-upreplyin 4 thelattertwocasesdated9January1998,seeA/53/40,para.494.Follow-upconsultationswiththe  p PermanentMissionofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthe  \ sixty-firstsession(seeA/53/40,para.493).Forfurtherfollow-upreplies,dated29Januaryand14 H April1999,seebelow. 4 ...   Overviewoffollow-uprepliesreceivedandoftheSpecialRapporteur'sfollow-upconsultations  duringthereportingperiod  ... X  466.Ecuador.Bysubmissionof29January1999,theGovernmentofEcuadorinformedthe #l! CommitteethatithadmetwithMr.VillacresOrtega'srepresentativeon18Januaryinordertocome $X" toafriendlysettlementonthebasisoftheCommittee'sViews.Byfurthersubmissionof14April $D # 1999,theGovernmentofEcuadorforwardedtotheCommitteeacopyoftheagreementof %0!$ compensationconcludedwiththerepresentativeofMr.VillacresOrtegaon26February1999.In &"% theagreement,theStatepartyrecognizeditsinternationalresponsibilityforhavingviolatedarticles '#& 7and10,paragraph1,intheauthor'scaseandagreedtopayhim,within90days,US$25,000for (#' damages.TheStateparty,moreover,agreedtotakecivil,penalandadministrativeactionagainstthe )$( perpetratorsoftheviolationsandtotakethenecessarystepstobringthemtojusticeandreserved |*%) itsrighttoclaimbackfromtheperpetratorstheamountofdamagespaid.Forthefulltextofthe h+&* agreement,seeannexIX.AsimilaragreementwasconcludedwithMr.GarciaFuenzalidaon16June T,'+ 1999.  @-(,  CCPRA/55/40,vol.I(2000)   UKUS.,  XHXXXH  XHXX XH +  VI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL ++,݌ t ЌXHXXXH  # XHXXXH ,#XHXX XH... L  # XHXXXH,#XHXX XH596.TheCommitteespreviousreport(A/54/40)containedadetailedcountrybycountrybreakdown $ t offollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1999.Thelistthatfollows  ` showstheadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollowupinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates.  L  (Viewsinwhichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollowupinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeen  8  included.)Italsoindicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasesthere $  hasbeennochangesincethelastreport.Thisisbecausethelimitedresourcesavailableforthe   Committeesworkpreventitfromundertakingacomprehensiveorsystematicfollowupprogramme.   ...   US.,UK.,+UKUS.,Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987Bolanos(A/44/40);forStatepartysfollowup \ reply,seeA/45/40,vol.II,annexXII,sect.B;277/1988TernJij;n(A/47/40);followupreply, H dated11June1992,unpublished;319/1988Ca;nGarca(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived; 4 480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40);481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);&  FortheStatepartysfollowup  p reply,dated9January1998,inthelattertwocases,seeA/53/40,para.494.Followupconsultations  \ withthePermanentMissionofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconducted H duringthesixtyfirstsession(seeA/53/40,para.493).Forfurtherfollowupreplies,dated29 4 Januaryand14April1999,seeA/54/40,para.466.   ' 2     8HXXdd8   CCPRA/56/40,vol.I(2001)   # XHXXXHU-#XHXX XHChapterIV.FollowupActivitiesundertheOptionalProtocolUS.,UK.,0UKUS.,# XHXXXH5#XHXX XH    ... ` 180.  TheCommitteespreviousannualreport(A/55/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailed 8  countrybycountrysurveyonfollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June $ t 2000.Thelistthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesare  ` outstanding,butdoesnottakeintoaccounttheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventy  L  secondsession,forwhichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochange  8  sincethepreviousreport. $  ...   Ecuador:FiveViewsfindingviolations:238/1987Bolaos(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,see   A/45/40,vol.II,annexXII,sect.B;277/1988TernJij;n(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June p 1992,unpublished;319/1988Ca;nGarca(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived;480/1991 \ Fuenzalida(A/51/40);481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,dated H 9January1998,seeA/53/40,paragraph494.FollowupconsultationswiththePermanentMission 4 ofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession(see  p A/53/40,para.493).Forfurtherfollowupreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,seeA/54/40,  \ paragraph466.# XHXXXH_6#US.,UK.,*6  H  XHXX XHUKUS.,CCPRA/57/40,vol.I(2002)   ChapterVI.Followupactivitiesundertheoptionalprotocol  ... ` 228.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee(A/56/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailed 8  countrybycountrysurveyoffollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June $ t 2001.Thelistthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesare  ` outstanding,butdoesnotincluderesponsesconcerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringthe  L  seventyfourthandseventyfifthsessions,forwhichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycases  8  therehasbeennochangesincethepreviousreport. $  ...     Ecuador:Viewsinfivecaseswithfindingsofviolations:   238/1987Bolaos(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/45/40,vol.US.,UK.,?=II,annexXII,sect.B; \ 277/1988TernJij;n(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992,unpublished; 4 319/1988Ca;nGarca(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived;  \ 480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40); 4 481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,dated9January1998,see   A/53/40,paragraph494.FollowupconsultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadortothe  UnitedNationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession(seeA/53/40,  paragraph493).Forfurtherfollow-upreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,seeA/54/40,  paragraph466. l ... D! 229.ForfurtherinformationonthestatusofalltheViewsinwhichfollowupinformationremains #l! outstandingorinrespectofwhichfollowupconsultationshavebeenorwillbescheduled,reference $X" ismadetothefollowupprogressreportpreparedfortheseventy-fourthsessionoftheCommittee $D # (CCPR/C/74/R.7/Rev.1,dated28March2002),discussedinpublicsessionattheCommittees %0!$ 2009thmeetingon4April2002(CCPR/C/SR.2009).ReferenceisalsomadetotheCommittees &"% previousreports,inparticularA/56/40,paragraphs182to200. '#& # XHXXXH =#  (#'  XHXX XHCEUS.,CCPRA/58/40,vol.I(2003)   CHAPTERVI.FollowupactivitiesundertheOptionalProtocol  ... ` 223.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountrybycountrysurvey 8  offollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2002.Thelistthatfollows $ t updatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotinclude  ` responsesconcerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventyseventhandseventyeighth  L  sessions,forwhichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasesthere  8  hasbeennochangesincethepreviousreport.* $  ...   Ecuador:0 `  Viewsinfivecaseswithfindingsofviolations: ` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#238/1987Bolaos(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/45/40,volumeII, \ annexXII,sectionB;H (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#277/1988TernJij;n(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992,  p unpublished; \ (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#319/1988Ca;nGarca(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived;4 (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40);  (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases,  dated9January1998,seeA/53/40,paragraph494.Followupconsultations  withthePermanentMissionofEcuadortotheUnitedNationsOfficeat l Genevawereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession(seeA/53/40,para. X  493).Forfurtherfollow-upreplies,dated29Januaryand14April1999,see D! A/54/40,paragraph466.0"  (# (# Notes $X" 1.[OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly],FiftyseventhSession,SupplementNo.40(A/57/40), %0!$ vol.I,chap.VI. &"% *ThedocumentsymbolA/[SessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordoftheGeneralAssembly (#' inwhichthecaseappears;annexVIreferstothepresentreport,vol.II. )$( # XHXXXHG#US.,CE.,G  h+&* XHXX XHCEUS., CCPRA/59/40vol.I(2004)   CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ... ` 230.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountry-by-countrysurvey 8  offollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2003.Thelistthatfollows $ t updatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotinclude  ` responsesconcerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheeightiethandeightyfirstsessions,  L  forwhichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeen  8  nochangesincethepreviousreport.* $  ...   US.,CE.,R*34 ddd Xdd Xdd X(#(#,UU,UU+  1'   1UKUS.,Ecuador:US.,UK.,)W '  'Viewsinfivecaseswithfindingsofviolations: 6,   6 '8 '238/1987Bolaos(A/44/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/45/40,volume 8 II,annexXII,sectionB; 6,$t  6 '( '277/1988TernJij;n(A/47/40);followupreply,dated11June1992, ( unpublished; 6,  6 'x '319/1988Ca;nGarca(A/47/40);nofollowupreplyreceived; 6,x  6 ',| '480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40); 6,,|  6 '0 '481/1991Ortega(A/52/40);forfollowupreplyinthelattertwocases, 0 dated9January1998,seeA/53/40,paragraph494.Follow-up  consultationswiththePermanentMissionofEcuadortotheUnited  NationsOfficeatGenevawereconductedduringthesixty-firstsession   (seeA/53/40,para.493).Forfurtherfollow-upreplies,dated29January  ! and14April1999,seeA/54/40,paragraph466.$|!"   $CEUS.,_______________ $l# Notes %X $ 1/Ibid.,FiftyeighthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/58/40),vol.I,chap.VI. &0"& *ThedocumentsymbolA/[sessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly ($( inwhichthecaseappears;annexIXreferstothepresentreport,volumeII. )$) # XHXXXHR#US.,CE.,\  h,', XHXX XHCEUS., CCPR,A/60/40vol.I(2005)   ... t CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL L  224.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollowuptoits $ t Viewsunderarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecial  ` RapporteurforthefollowuponViewstothiseffect.Mr.AndohasbeentheSpecialRapporteur  L  sinceMarch2001(seventyfirstsession).  8  225.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollowupinformationfromStatesparties.   SuchinformationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofa   violationofCovenantrights.Atotalof391Viewsoutofthe503Viewsadoptedsince1979   concludedthattherehadbeenaviolationoftheCovenant.   228.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffect \ thattheCommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitioner H hasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhasinfactgiveneffecttotheCommittees 4 recommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartydidnotitselfprovidethatinformation.  p 229.Thepresentannualreportadoptsadifferentformatforthepresentationoffollowup H informationcomparedtopreviousannualreports.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureof 4 followuprepliesfromStatespartiesreceivedasof28July2005,inrelationtoViewsinwhichthe   CommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollowup   repliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsofcomplyingwiththe  CommitteesViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurfor  followuponViewscontinues.Thenotesfollowinganumberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthe  difficultiesincategorizingfollowupreplies. l 230.FollowupinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives D! sincethelastannualreportissetoutinanewannexVII,containedinVolumeIIofthepresent 0"  annualreport.This,moredetailed,followupinformationalsoindicatesactionstilloutstandingin #l! thosecasesthatremainunderreview. $X"   &"% TRO'3#Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeLaser Ta Landscape3'LetterT   FOLLOWUPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   ok*6D7ed dUUUU34..,'bZ,4bZ, bZ,'bZ,bZ,bZ,bb+  6DD'zz @6lXXH# ll^#l lUS.,CE.,_UKUS.,Statepartyand  numberofcases J withviolation# llm#l lUS.,UK.,mCEUS., ;DD,! b@DD @;# llmn#l lUS.,CE.,nUKUS.,Communicationnumber,  authorandlocationa# llo#l lUS.,UK.,OoCEUS., ;DD,!J@DD @;  # llo#l lUS.,CE.,pUKUS.,Followupresponsereceivedfrom   Statepartyandlocation# ll}p#l lUS.,UK.,pCEUS., ;DD,!J @DD @;Satisfactory   response ;DD,!J @DD @;Unsatisfactory   response ;DD,!J@DD @;Nofollowup  response ?DDD,!J@DD @?Followup  dialogue J ongoing IDD:' b@  DDD @I... ;DD,! :@DD @; ;DD,! :@DD @; ;DD,! :@DD @; ;DD,! :@DD @; ;DD,! :@DD @; ?DDD,! :@DD @? NDD?' :@  DDD @NEcuador(5) ;DD,! @DD @;238/1987,Bolaos   A/44/40 ;DD,! @DD @;X   A/45/40 ;DD,! @DD @;X    A/45/40 ;DD,! !@DD @; ;DD,! "@DD @; ?DDD,! #@DD @? NDD?' $@  DDD @N ;DD,!b %@DD @;277/1988,TernJij;n b & A/47/40 ;DD,!* z'@DD @;X b ( A/59/40* ;DD,!* z)@DD @; ;DD,!b *@DD @;X ;DD,!b +@DD @; ?DDD,!b ,@DD @?X NDD?'b -@  DDD @N CDDD0!R .@DD @C*Note:Accordingtothisreport,informationwasprovidedon11June1992,butwasunpublished.ItappearsfromtheFollowupfilethatin R / thisresponse,theStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesoftworeportsoftheNationalPoliceontheinvestigationofthecrimesinwhichMr.  0 TernJij;nwasinvolved,includingthestatementshemadeon12March1986concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes. QDDB* 1@  DDD @Q ;DD,!j 2@DD @;319/1988,Ca;nGarca j 3 A/47/40 ;DD,!2 4@DD @; ;DD,!j 5@DD @; ;DD,!j 6@DD @; ;DD,!j 7@DD @;X ?DDD,!j 8@DD @?X NDD?'j 9@  DDD @N ;DD,! Z :@DD @;480/1991,Fuenzalida  Z ; A/51/40 ;DD,!"<@DD @;X  Z = A/53/40,A/54/40 ;DD,!">@DD @;X ;DD,! Z ?@DD @; ;DD,! Z @@DD @; ?DDD,! Z A@DD @? PDDD?' Z B@  DDD @P =DDD,!C@DDD @=481/1991,VillacrsOrtega D A/52/40 =DDD,!rE@DDD @=X F A/53/40,A/54/40 =DDD,!rG@DDD @=X =DDD,!H@DDD @= =DDD,!I@DDD @= ?DDDD,!J@DDD @?7-+K@   DDDD 7#XHXlgm#aThelocationreferstothedocumentsymboloftheOfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,SupplementNo.40,whichistheannual 0L reportoftheCommitteetotherespectivesessionsoftheAssembly. nM # XHXXXH8q#US.,CE.,qq  8P TRX3'LetterO'3#Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta Landscape3'LetterscapeX3''3Letter LandscapeLaser Ta LandscapeT CCPR,A/61/40vol.I(2006)   ... t L  M  L  M  CHAPTERVIFOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL L  227.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoits $ t Viewsunderarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecial  ` Rapporteurforfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr.AndohasbeentheSpecialRapporteursince  L  March2001(seventy-firstsession).  8  228.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.   SuchinformationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofa   violationofCovenantrights;429Viewsoutofthe547Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthat   therehadbeenaviolationoftheCovenant.   229.Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseand \ subjective:itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies. H Manyfollow-uprepliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingness 4 oftheStatepartytoimplementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantan  p appropriateremedy.Otherrepliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonot  \ addresstheCommitteesViewsatalloronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimply H notethatthevictimhasfiledaclaimforcompensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatno 4 compensationcanthereforebepaid.Stillotherrepliesindicatethatthereisnolegalobligationon   theStatepartytoprovidearemedy,butthataremedywillbeaffordedtothecomplainantonanL  M  ex   gratiaL  M  Ԁbasis.  230.Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualor  legalgrounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promisean l investigationofthematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,for X  onereasonoranother,giveeffecttotheCommitteesViews. D! 231.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffect #l! thattheCommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitioner $X" hasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommittees $D # recommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. %0!$ 232.Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-upinformation '#& asthelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-uprepliesfrom (#' Statespartiesreceivedupto7July2006,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefound )$( violationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhave |*%) beenconsideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommittees h+&* Views,orwhetherthedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-upto T,'+ Viewscontinues.TheNotesfollowinganumberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficulties @-(, incategorizingfollow-upreplies.  233.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/60/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeII t ofthepresentannualreport.  ` TRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeX3'3'LetterscapeX3'TL  M  L  M  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   e*Dded'bZ'4bZ4 bZ 'bZ'bZbZbb6D7e.e.,dd ,dd , dd ,dd ,dd ,edd ,dd +  $zz $Stateparty . andnumber  ofcases   with   violation '  'L  M  L  M  Communication .  number,authorand   location '   'L  M  L  M  Follow-upresponse .  receivedfromStateparty   andlocation '  'L  M  L  M  Satisfactory . response ' 'L  M  L  M  Unsatisfactory . response ' 'L  M  L  M  No . follow-up  response   received '  'L  M  L  M  Follow-up . dialogue  ongoing   ...   h    h    h    h    h    h    h  Ecuador(5) & !AA &L  M  L  M  238/1987,L  M  BolaosL  M    " A/44/40L  M  L  M  L  M    # L  M  L  M  X  $ A/45/40L  M  L  M  L  M    % L  M  L  M  X  & A/45/40   '    (    )    *    * 277/1988,L  M  TernJij;nL  M    Z + A/47/40  H , X  Z - A/59/40*  H .    Z / X   Z 0    Z 1 X   Z 2   f2 *L  M  NoteL  M  :Accordingtothisreport,informationwasprovidedon11June1992,butwasnotpublished.Itappearsfrom z3 theFollowupfilethatinthisresponse,theStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesL  M  oftworeportsoftheNationalPolice h4 ontheinvestigationofthecrimesinwhichMr.TernJij;nwasinvolved,includingthestatementshemadeon12 V5 March1986concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes.  D6   b6 L  M  L  M  319/1988,L  M  Ca;n 7 GarcaL  M   8 A/47/40L  M  L  M  L  M   9   :   ;   < X  = X  >   > 480/1991,L  M  FuenzalidaL  M   $t? A/51/40  b@ L  M  L  M  X $tA A/53/40,A/54/40L  M  L  M  L  M   bB X  $tC   $tD   $tE   $tF   0F 481/1991,L  M  Villacrs G OrtegaL  M   H A/52/40  pI X J A/53/40,A/54/40  K X  L   M   N   O ...   BP    BQ    BR    BS    BT    BU   BV  _  "`V TRX3'LetterO'3Letter Landscape3'Letter 2 480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40)'3Letter LandscapeX3'T _CCPR_,A/62/40vol.I(2007)   ... t CHAPTERVI.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL L  213.  InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoits $ t Viewsunderarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecial  ` Rapporteurforfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._Ando_ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursince  L  March2001(seventy-firstsession).  8  214.  In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.   SuchinformationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofa   violationofCovenantrights;452Viewsoutofthe570Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthat   therehadbeenaviolationoftheCovenant.   215.  Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseand \ subjective:itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies. H Manyfollow-uprepliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingness 4 oftheStatepartytoimplementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantan  p appropriateremedy.Otherrepliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddress  \ theCommitteesViewsatalloronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethat H thevictimhasfiledaclaimforcompensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensation 4 canthereforebepaid.StillotherrepliesindicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartyto   providearemedy,butthataremedywillbeaffordedtothecomplainantonanexgratiabasis.   216.  Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualor  legalgrounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promisean  investigationofthematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,for l onereasonoranother,giveeffecttotheCommitteesViews. X  217.  Inmanycases,theCommitteesecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainants 0"  totheeffectthattheCommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances, #l! thepetitionerhasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttothe $X" Committeesrecommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. $D # 218.  Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-up &"% informationasthelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-upreplies '#& fromStatespartiesreceivedupto7July2007,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefound (#' violationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeen )$( consideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommitteesViews, |*%) orwhetherthedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViews h+&* continues.TheNotesfollowinganumberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesin T,'+ categorizingfollow-upreplies. @-(, Ї219.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/61/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIof  thepresentannualreport.    ` XRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeX3'3'Letter 2 480/1991Fuenzalida(A/51/40)aX  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   *d ddd dd  dd dd dd edd edd De.e.,/\R,\R,\R,\R,\R,f\R,\\+  8DDD'  8Statepartyand  numberofcases  withviolation =DDD,!rDDD =Communication  number,  authorandlocation =DDD,!rDDD =Follow-upresponse   receivedfromState   partyandlocation =DDD,!r DDD =Satisfactory   response =DDD,! DDD =Unsatisfactory  response =DDD,!DDD =Nofollow-up  response  received ?DDDD,!rDDD ?Follow-up  dialogue  ongoing SDDB,r  DDDD S... @DD/!t DD @ @DD/!t DD @ @DD/!t DD @ @DD/!t DD @ @DD/!t DD @ BDDD/!t DD B ND?'t  DDD NEcuador(5) 4DD#v D 4238/1987,_Bolaos_ v  A/44/40 .DDd DD .X v   A/45/40 .DDd !DD .X v " A/45/40 .DDd #DD . .DDv $DD . 0DDDv %DD 0 ED6v & DDD E 4DD#\ 'D 4277/1988,_Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_ \ ( A/47/40 4DD#J )DD 4X \ * A/59/40* 4DD#J +DD 4 4DD#\ ,DD 4X 4DD#\ -DD 4 6DDD#\ .DD 6X ED6\ / DDD E :DDD'B 0D :*Note:Accordingtothisreport,informationwasprovidedon11June1992,butwasnotpublished.Itappearsfrom B 1 theFollowupfilethatinthisresponse,theStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesoftworeportsoftheNationalPolice 0 2 ontheinvestigationofthecrimesinwhichMr._Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_Ԁwasinvolved,includingthestatementshemadeon12 n 3 March1986concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes. HD9! \ 4 DDD H 4DD#T 5D 4319/1988,_Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_ T 6 A/47/40 4DD#B7DD 4 4DD#T 8DD 4 4DD#T 9DD 4X 4DD#T :DD 4 6DDD#T ;DD 6X ED6T < DDD E 4DD#:=D 4480/1991,_Fuenzalida_ :> A/51/40 4DD#(?DD 4X :@ A/53/40,A/54/40 4DD#(ADD 4X :B Ѐ 4DD#(CDD 4 4DD#:DDD 4 6DDD#:EDD 6 GDD6:F DDD G 4DD# GDD 4481/1991,_Villacrs_  H Ortega I A/52/40 4DD#JDD 4X  K A/53/40,A/54/40 4DD#LDD 4X  M Ѐ 4DD#NDD 4 4DD# ODD 4 6DDD# PDD 6 9DD( Q DDD 9... +DDRDD + +DDSDD + +DDTDD + +DDUDD + +DDVDD + -DDDWDD -.$"X  DDD .  X TRX3'LetterO'3Letter Landscape3'LetteronalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecial'3Letter LandscapeX3'T _CCPR_,A/63/40vol.I(2008)    VI.  FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  t 187.  InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoits L  Viewsunderarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecial 8  Rapporteurforfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._Ando_ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursince $ t March2001(seventy-firstsession).  ` 188.  In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.  8  SuchinformationhadbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofa $  violationofCovenantrights;429Viewsoutofthe547Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthat   therehadbeenaviolationoftheCovenant.   189.  Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseand   subjective:itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies. p Manyfollow-uprepliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingness \ oftheStatepartytoimplementtheCommittee'srecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantan H appropriateremedy.Otherrepliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddress 4 theCommittee'sViewsatallorrelateonlytocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethat  p thevictimhasfiledaclaimforcompensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensation  \ canthereforebepaid.StillotherrepliesindicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartyto H providearemedy,butthataremedywillbeaffordedtothecomplainantonanexgratiabasis. 4 190.  Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommittee'sViewsandfindingsonfactualor   legalgrounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promisean  investigationofthematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,for  onereasonoranother,giveeffecttotheCommittee'srecommendations.  191.  Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffect X  thattheCommittee'sViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitioner D! hasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommittee's 0"  recommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. #l! 192.  Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-up $D # informationasthelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-upreplies %0!$ fromStatespartiesreceivedupto7July2008,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefound &"% violationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeen '#& consideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommittee'sViews, (#' orwhetherthedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViews )$( continues.Thenotesfollowinganumberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesin |*%) categorizingfollow-upreplies. h+&* 193.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives @-(, subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/62/40)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIofthepresent  annualreport.     TRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeL  M  Issuesandviol3'LetteronalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialT*Vd d/\R/\R\R\R\Rf\Rf\\e.e.,vv, vv,Svv,vv,vv,vv,:vv+  /DDD GG/L  M  L  M  Statepartyandnumber G ofcaseswithviolation +DDD5DDD +Communicationnumber, G authorandrelevant 5 Committeereport +DDD#DDD +Followupresponse G receivedfromState 5 party +DDD#DDD +Satisfactory G  response +DDD5 DDD +Unsatisfactory G  response +DDD5 DDD +No G  response -DDDD5DDD -Followup G dialogue 5 ongoingL  M  CDD2## GG  DDDD GGC... +DDODD + +DDODD + +DDODD + +DDODD + +DDODD + -DDDODD - AD2#O GG  DDD GGAL  M  Ecuador(5) +DD D +238/1987,L  M  _Bolaos_L  M     A/44/40 +DD DD +X   A/45/40 +DD DD +X   A/45/40 +DD DD + +DD  DD + -DDD !DD -L  M  AD2# " GG  DDD GGAL  M  +DD5 #D +277/1988,L  M  _Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_L  M   5 $ A/47/40 +DD# s%DD +X 5 & A/59/40L  M  *L  M  +DD# s'DD + +DD5 (DD +X +DD5 )DD + -DDD5 *DD -XL  M  AD2#5 + GG  DDD GGAL  M  1DDD ,D 1L  M  *L  M  NoteL  M  :Accordingtothisreport,informationwasprovidedon11June1992,butwasnotpublished.Itappears  - fromthefollowupfilethatinthisresponse,theStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesL  M  oftworeportsofthe  . nationalpoliceontheinvestigationofthecrimesinwhichMr._Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_Ԁwasinvolved,includingthe { / statementshemadeon12March1986concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes.L  M  L  M  DD5&i 0 GG  DDD GGDL  M  +DD51D +319/1988,L  M  _Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_L  M   52 A/47/40 .DD#3DD . .DD54DD . .DD55DD .X .DD56DD . 0DDD57DD 0XL  M  AD2#58 GG  DDD GGAL  M  +DDO9D +480/1991,L  M  _Fuenzalida_L  M   O: A/51/40 +DD=;DD +X O< A/53/40,A/54/40 +DD==DD +X +DDO>DD + +DDO?DD + -DDDO@DD -L  M  CDD2#OA GG  DDD GGCL  M  +DD BDD +481/1991,L  M  _Villacrs_  C OrtegaL  M   D A/52/40 +DDEDD +X  F A/53/40,A/54/40 +DDGDD +X +DD HDD + +DD IDD + -DDD JDD -L  M  CDD2# K GG  DDD GGC... +DDaLDD + +DDaMDD + +DDaNDD + +DDaODD + +DDaPDD + -DDDaQDD -3)'aR GG   DDD 3  FR TRX3'LetterO'3Letter Landscape3'Letter63/40vol.I(2008)    '3Letter LandscapeL  M  IssuesandviolT _CCPR_,A/64/40,vol.I(2009)    VI.  FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  t 230.  InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoits L  Viewsunderarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecial 8  Rapporteurforfollow-uponViewstothiseffect.Ms.RuthWedgwoodhasbeentheSpecial $ t RapporteursinceJuly2009(ninety-sixthsession).  ` 231.  In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.  8  SuchinformationhadbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofa $  violationofCovenantrights;543Viewsoutofthe681Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthat   therehadbeenaviolationoftheCovenant.   232.  Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseand   subjective:itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies. p Manyfollow-uprepliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingness \ oftheStatepartytoimplementtheCommittee'srecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantan H appropriateremedy.Otherrepliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddress 4 theCommittee'sViewsatallorrelateonlytocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethat  p thevictimhasfiledaclaimforcompensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensation  \ canthereforebepaid.StillotherrepliesindicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartyto H providearemedy,butthataremedywillbeaffordedtothecomplainantonanexgratiabasis. 4 233.  Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommittee'sViewsandfindingsonfactualor   legalgrounds,constitutemuchbelatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promisean  investigationofthematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,for  onereasonoranother,giveeffecttotheCommittee'srecommendations.  234.  Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffect X  thattheCommittee'sViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitioner D! hasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommittee's 0"  recommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. #l! 235.  Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-up $D # informationasthelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-upreplies %0!$ fromStatespartiesreceiveduptotheninety-sixthsession(13-31July2009),inrelationtoViewsin &"% whichtheCommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhether '#& follow-uprepliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsoftheir (#' compliancewiththeCommittee'sViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandthe )$( SpecialRapporteurforfollow-uponViewscontinues.Thenotesfollowinganumberofcaseentries |*%) conveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollow-upreplies. h+&* 236.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives @-(, subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/63/40)issetoutinannexIXtovolumeIIofthepresentannual  report.  ̀ L  TRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter Landscape      3'Letter63/40vol.I(2008)    T*[d Vdvv vv SvvSvvvvvv:vv:e.e.,vv,) vv,vv,vv,vv,#vv,vv+  /DDD vv/L  M  L  M  Statepartyandnumber d ofcaseswithviolation +DDDRDDD +CommunicationnumberL  M  ,L  M   d authorandrelevant R Committeereport +DDD@DDD +Followup d responsereceived R fromStateparty +DDD@ DDD +Satisfactory d  response +DDDR DDD +Unsatisfactory d  response +DDDR DDD +No d response -DDDDRDDD -Follow d up R dialogue @ ongoingL  M  CDD2#. vv  DDDD vvCL  M  ... +DD DD + +DD DD + +DD DD + +DD DD + +DD DD + -DDD DD - AD2#  vv  DDD vvAL  M  Ecuador(5) +DD D +L  M  238/1987L  M  ,L  M  ԀL  M  _Bolaos_L  M     A/44/40 +DD DD +X   A/45/40 +DD DD +X    A/45/40 +DD !DD + +DD "DD + -DDD #DD -L  M  AD2# $ vv  DDD vvAL  M  +DDZ %D +L  M  277/1988L  M  ,L  M  ԀL  M  _Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_L  M   Z & A/47/40 +DDH 'DD +X Z ( A/59/40L  M  *L  M  +DDH )DD + +DDZ *DD +X +DDZ +DD + -DDDZ ,DD -XL  M  CDD2#Z - vv  DDD vvCL  M  1DDD"r .DD 1L  M  *L  M  NoteL  M  :AccordingtothisreportL  M  ,L  M  Ԁinformationwasprovidedon11June1992L  M  ,L  M  Ԁbutwasnotpublished.It "r / appearsfromthefollowupfilethatinthisresponseL  M  ,L  M  ԀtheStatepartymerelyforwardedcopiesoftworeports `0 ofthenationalpoliceontheinvestigationofthecrimesinwhichMr._Tern_Ԁ_Jij;n_ԀwasinvolvedL  M  ,L  M  Ԁincluding N1 thestatementshemadeon12March1986concerninghisparticipationinsuchcrimes.L  M  L  M  DD5&<2 vv  DDD vvDL  M  Ecuador(L  M  _contd_L  M  )L  M  +DD3D +319/1988L  M  ,L  M  ԀL  M  _Ca;n_Ԁ_Garca_L  M   4 A/47/40 +DD5DD + +DD6DD + +DD7DD +X +DD8DD + -DDD9DD -XL  M  AD2#: vv  DDD vvAL  M  +DD;D +480/1991L  M  ,L  M  ԀL  M  _Fuenzalida_L  M   < A/51/40 +DD|=DD +X > A/53/40L  M  ,L  M  ԀA/54/40 +DD|?DD +X +DD@DD + +DDADD + -DDDBDD -L  M  CDD2#C vv  DDD vvCL  M  +DDVDDD +L  M  481/1991L  M  ,L  M  ԀL  M  _Villacrs_ VE OrtegaL  M   DF A/52/40L  M  +DD2GDD +X VH A/53/40L  M  ,L  M  ԀA/54/40 +DDDIDD +X +DDVJDD + +DDVKDD + -DDDVLDD -L  M  CDD2#VM vv  DDD vvC... +DD \NDD + +DD \ODD + +DD \PDD + +DD \QDD + +DD \RDD + -DDD \SDD -3)' \T vv   DDD 3