WPC ='dӸODGpCXZsMEӬflQkt^6fkGXOu[Wʓ| HS:B@Po=%H" ? 1S# HBf0$:p"D:5;ihZ tڇ?-RՈlؘ,UZ&, ^늢gh܆Y.r_ \Fe|ޙ'm羐7ryqDsYq 9, )ʔc!?px_fwuT[4ZIaV'i7+#p[*iiU%+@}YO9 38Q$ En:/LI i_$jbr #>S,u]=)E#UN % 0r^ U wa 4e y  m N 0J 0 U> U -- UBZ DE U> 0U 0t 0Q 0 0 0| 0) 0 0q 0  0 0 0C 0 0 0& 0 0J 0 0 0U 0 0 0A 0 0k 0 0<{fafafafa B-f<a>fRaTTTTTTTT Bh 0(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX(J$  XXXXXXXX&p8 p813|xU 42ParaNo. 8.9 AIQ!$8S\  `&Times New RomanS8.9 AIQ!$8S\  `&Times New RomanS<SS:Footnote TexS\  `&Times New RomanSS\  `&Times New RomanS\  `&Times New Roman  ##Xd#\  `*Times New RomanTT88889Hairline!dxdx\  `&Times New Roman*+ (_2623  ..*D+D (_25   ," <DL,23  ..," <DL,   *5+5 (_24  ) <DL)23  ..) <DL)  *2+2 (_23 ` &<<DL&23  ..&<<DL& ` */+/ (_22  #DL#23  ..#DL#  *,+, (_21   DL 23  .. DL  *)+) (_20 h DDL23  ..DDL h *&+& (_19  L23  ..L  *#+# (_18   L23  .. L  *>> (_17  2( 4 <DL223  Ԁ2( 4 <DL2  *DD (_16   ," <DL,23  Ԁ," <DL,   *55 (_15  ) <DL)23  Ԁ) <DL)  *22 (_14 ` &<<DL&23  Ԁ&<<DL& ` *// (_13  #DL#23  Ԁ#DL#  *,, (_12   DL 23  Ԁ DL  *)) (_11 h DDL23  ԀDDL h *&& (_10  L23  ԀL  (## &_9   L23  Ԁ L  (>> &_8  2( 4 <DL223  2( 4 <DL2  (DD &_7   ," <DL,23  ," <DL,   (55 &_6  ) <DL)23  ) <DL)  (22 &_5 ` &<<DL&23  &<<DL& ` (// &_4  #DL#23  #DL#  (,, &_3   DL 23   DL  ()) &_2 h DDL23  DDL h (&& &_1  L23  L  &## $_   L23   L  <:Default ParaTable_AhTABLE ATable_ATABLE A)Hairline d0TTABLE A TABLE B d !  X{XXXX{XXX{  _    XX{LIBYANARABJAMAHIRIYA#X{X#   x FollowupJurisprudence    ActionbyTreatyBodiesCE.,US.,   US.,CE.,[ CCPRA/51/40,vol.I(1996)    VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL     ...   429.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasat   26July1996providesthefollowingpicture:   ... | LibyanArabJamahiriya:Onedecisionfindingviolations;nofollow-upreplyreceived.Aremindertobe p addressedtotheStateparty. j ... ^ Concernoverinstancesofnon-cooperationunderthefollow-upmandate R 463.Inspiteoftheprogressincollectingfollow-upinformationsincetheadoptionofthelastannualreport, F theCommitteeandtheSpecialRapporteurnotewithconcernthatanumberofcountriesdidnotprovide @ anyfollow-upinformationwithinthedeadlinesestablishedbytheCommitteeorhavenotrepliedto : remindersorrequestsforinformationfromtheSpecialRapporteur.TheStatesthathavenotrepliedto 4 requestsforfollow-upinformationarethefollowing: . ~ ... ""r LibyanArabJamahiriya(noreplyinrespectofonecase); $f  ...  &Z!" 464.TheSpecialRapporteururgestheseStatespartiestoreplytohisrequestsforfollow-upinformation 'N#$ withintheimparteddeadlines. (H$%   ,0()  CCPR A/52/40,vol.I(1997)      `  VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL    ...  524.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof   30June1997providesthefollowingpicture(Viewsinwhichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-up   informationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded):   ... t  LibyanArabJamahiriya:Onedecisionfindingviolations:440/1990-ElMegreisi(1994Report);9/State h  party'sfollow-upreplyremainsoutstanding.AuthorhasinformedtheCommitteethathisbrotherwas b  releasedinMarch1995.Compensationoutstanding. \  ... P Concernoverinstancesofnon-cooperationunderthefollow-upmandate D 554.Inspiteofsomeprogressincollectingfollow-upinformationsincetheadoptionofits1996Report, 8 theCommitteeandtheSpecialRapporteurnotewithconcernthatanumberofcountriesdidnotprovide 2 anyfollow-upinformationwithinthedeadlinesestablishedbytheCommitteeorhavenotrepliedto ,| remindersorrequestsforinformationfromtheSpecialRapporteur.ThoseStateswhichhavenotreplied &v torequestsforfollow-upinformationarethefollowing(inalphabeticalorder):  p ... d LibyanArabJamahiriya:onecase;  X ... !L 555.TheCommitteeurgesthoseStatespartiestoreplytotheSpecialRapporteur'srequestsforfollow-up #@  informationwithinthedeadlinesthathavebeenset. $: ! ___________ , ()   9/OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,FortyninthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/49/40).  -)*  CCPRA/53/40,vol.I(1998)    VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  486.TheCommitteespreviousreport(A/52/40)containedadetailedcountrybycountrybreakdown   offollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1997.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollowupinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates(Viewsin   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollowupinformationhasnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded).Italso z   indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethepreviousreport.ThisisbecausetheresourcesavailablefortheCommitteesworkwere n  considerablyreducedinthecurrentyear,preventingitfromundertakingacomprehensivesystematic h  followupprogramme. b  ... V LibyanArabJamahiriya:Onedecisionfindingviolations:440/1990ElMegreisi(1994Report J (A/49/40)0;Statepartysfollowupreplyremainsoutstanding.AuthorhasinformedtheCommitteethat D hisbrotherwasreleasedinMarch1995.Compensationremainsoutstanding. > ... 2 Concernoverthefollowupmandate &v ... j 510.TheCommitteeagainexpressesitsregretthatitsrecommendations,formulatedinits1995,1996and ^ 1997Reports,totheeffectthatatleastonefollowupmissionperyearbebudgetedbytheOfficeofthe  X UnitedNationsHighCommissionerforHumanRights,havestillnotbeenimplemented.Similarly,the !R Committeeconsidersthatstaffresourcestoservicethefollowupmandateremaininadequate,despitethe !L Committeesrepeatedrequests,andthatthispreventstheproperandtimelyconductoffollowupactivities, "F includingfollowupmissions.Inthiscontext,theCommitteeexpressesseriousconcernthat,becauseof #@  thelackofstaff,nofollowupconsultationscouldbeorganizedduringitssixtysecondsessionoratits $: ! sixtythirdsession.ItisforthisreasonthattheCommitteeisunabletoincludeinthepresentreporta %4!" completelistofStateswhichhavefailedtocooperateunderthefollowupprocedure.Stateslistedinthe &."# previousyearsreportforwhichrepliesarestilloutstandingare:...LibyanArabJamahiriya... '(#$   )%&  CCPRA/54/40,vol.I(1999)     VII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL    461.TheCommittee'spreviousreport(A/53/40)containedadetailedcountry-by-countrybreakdown  offollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1998.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollow-upinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates(Viewsin   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded).Italso   indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange   sincethelastreport.ThisisbecausetheresourcesavailablefortheCommittee'sworkhavebeen z   considerablyreducedpreventingitfromundertakingacomprehensivesystematicfollow-upprogramme. t  ... h  LibyanArabJamahiriya:Onedecisionfindingviolations:440/1990-El-Megreisi(A/49/40);Stateparty's \  follow-upreplyremainsoutstanding.AuthorhasinformedtheCommitteethathisbrotherwasreleasedin V March1995.Compensationremainsoutstanding. P    D  CCPRA/55/40,vol.I(2000)   UKUS., X{XXX{  X{XXX{    VI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  4!݌  ЌX{XXX{  #X{XXX{!#X{XXX{...  #X{XXX{"#X{XXX{596.TheCommitteespreviousreport(A/54/40)containedadetailedcountrybycountrybreakdownof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1999.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollowupinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates.(Viewsin   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollowupinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded.)Italso z   indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethelastreport.ThisisbecausethelimitedresourcesavailablefortheCommitteesworkpreventit n  fromundertakingacomprehensiveorsystematicfollowupprogramme. h  ...US.,UK., UKUS., \  LibyanArabJamahiriya:Onedecisionfindingviolations:440/1990ElMegreisi(A/49/40);theState P partysfollowupreplyremainsoutstanding.TheauthorhasinformedtheCommitteethathisbrotherwas J releasedinMarch1995.Compensationremainsoutstanding.#X{XXX{^"#US.,UK.,% D   8  8{XXdd8   CCPRA/56/40,vol.I(2001)   X{XXX{UKUS.,ChapterIV.FollowupActivitiesundertheOptionalProtocolUS.,UK.,{(UKUS.,#X{XXX{\(#X{XXX{    ...  180.  TheCommitteespreviousannualreport(A/55/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailedcountry   bycountrysurveyonfollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2000.The   listthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnot   takeintoaccounttheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventysecondsession,forwhichfollowup z   repliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesincethepreviousreport. t  ... h  LibyanArabJamahiriya:Viewsinonecasefindingviolations:440/1990ElMegreisi(A/49/40);followup \  replyremainsoutstanding.TheauthorhasinformedtheCommitteethathisbrotherwasreleasedinMarch V 1995.Compensationremainsoutstanding.#X{XXX{)#US.,UK.,(  P   D  X{XXX{UKUS.,CCPRA/57/40,vol.I(2002)   ChapterVI.Followupactivitiesundertheoptionalprotocol  ...  228.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee(A/56/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailed   countrybycountrysurveyoffollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2001.   Thelistthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoes   notincluderesponsesconcerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventyfourthandseventy z   fifthsessions,forwhichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesince t  thepreviousreport. n  ... b  LibyanArabJamahiriya:Viewsinonecasewithfindingsofviolations:US.,UK.,-ԀUKUS., V 440/1990ElMegreisi(A/49/40);followupreplyremainsoutstanding.Theauthorhasinformedthe J CommitteethathisbrotherwasreleasedinMarch1995.Compensationremainsoutstanding. D ... 8 229.ForfurtherinformationonthestatusofalltheViewsinwhichfollowupinformationremains ,| outstandingorinrespectofwhichfollowupconsultationshavebeenorwillbescheduled,referenceis &v madetothefollowupprogressreportpreparedfortheseventy-fourthsessionoftheCommittee  p (CCPR/C/74/R.7/Rev.1,dated28March2002),discussedinpublicsessionattheCommittees2009th j meetingon4April2002(CCPR/C/SR.2009).ReferenceisalsomadetotheCommitteesprevious d reports,inparticularA/56/40,paragraphs182to200. ^ #X{XXX{-#US.,UK.,1  !L  X{XXX{CEUS.,CCPRA/58/40,vol.I(2003)   CHAPTERVI.FollowupactivitiesundertheOptionalProtocol  ...  223.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountrybycountrysurveyof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2002.Thelistthatfollowsupdates   thatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotincluderesponses   concerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventyseventhandseventyeighthsessions,for z   whichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethepreviousreport.* n  ... b  LibyanArab ` 0 Viewsinonecasewithfindingsofviolations:V (# (# Jamahiriya: P 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#440/1990ElMegreisi(A/49/40);followupreplyremainsoutstanding.The J authorhasinformedtheCommitteethathisbrotherwasreleasedinMarch1995. D Compensationremainsoutstanding.> (# (# Notes ,| 1.[OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly],FiftyseventhSession,SupplementNo.40(A/57/40),  p vol.I,chap.VI. j *ThedocumentsymbolA/[SessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordoftheGeneralAssembly ^ inwhichthecaseappears;annexVIreferstothepresentreport,vol.II.  X #X{XXX{5#US.,CE.,5  !L X{XXX{CEUS., CCPRA/59/40vol.I(2004)   CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  230.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountry-by-countrysurveyof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2003.Thelistthatfollowsupdates   thatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotincluderesponses   concerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheeightiethandeightyfirstsessions,forwhichfollow z   uprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesincethe t  previousreport.* n  ... b  US.,CE.,1=*45 ddd Xdd Xdd X(#(#,UU,UU+  1'VV 1FRUS.,LibyanArab V ЀJamahiriya:US.,FR.,ACEUS.,  P Viewsinonecasewithfindingsofviolations: 6,V  6 'J '440/1990ElMegreisi(A/49/40);followupreplyremainsoutstanding;the J authorhasinformedtheCommitteethathisbrotherwasreleasedinMarch D 1995;compensationremainsoutstanding.$>   $_______________ ,| Notes &v 1/Ibid.,FiftyeighthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/58/40),vol.I,chap.VI. j *ThedocumentsymbolA/[sessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssemblyin ^ whichthecaseappears;annexIXreferstothepresentreport,volumeII.  X #X{XXX{=#US.,CE.,B  "F! X{XXX{CEUS., CCPR,A/60/40vol.I(2005)   ...  CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   224.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollowuptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forthefollowuponViewstothiseffect.Mr.AndohasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventyfirstsession). t  225.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollowupinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights.Atotalof391Viewsoutofthe503Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehad \  beenaviolationoftheCovenant. V 228.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffectthatthe J CommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitionerhasinformed D theCommitteethattheStatepartyhasinfactgiveneffecttotheCommitteesrecommendations,even > thoughtheStatepartydidnotitselfprovidethatinformation. 8 229.Thepresentannualreportadoptsadifferentformatforthepresentationoffollowupinformation ,| comparedtopreviousannualreports.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollowupreplies &v fromStatespartiesreceivedasof28July2005,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefound  p violationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollowuprepliesareorhavebeen j consideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsofcomplyingwiththeCommitteesViews,orwhether d thedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollowuponViewscontinues.The ^ notesfollowinganumberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollowupreplies.  X 230.FollowupinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentativessince !L thelastannualreportissetoutinanewannexVII,containedinVolumeIIofthepresentannualreport. "F This,moredetailed,followupinformationalsoindicatesactionstilloutstandinginthosecasesthatremain #@  underreview. $: ! _   '(#$ TRO'3#Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeLaser Ta Landscape3'LetterT   FOLLOWUPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   >R*6D7ed dUUUU45..,'bZ,4bZ, bZ,'bZ,bZ,bZ,bb+  6DD' @6SXX{#SSE#SSUS.,CE.,EUKUS.,Statepartyand  numberofcases o withviolation#SSxT#SSUS.,UK.,TCEUS., ;DD,!8 @DD @;#SS Shehad,however,filedanewclaimforcompensationforthetimethathadbeenwastedwhileshehad 8 beenwaitingforthepassport,whichhadpreventedherfrom_ travelling_ ԀtoSwitzerlandtostudy. 2 28.Mr._ SOLARI_ Ԁ_ YRIGOYEN_ saidthatthe otherdocumentsmentionedinthefinalparagraphofthe &v authorsresponsehadnotbeenmentionedintheoriginalcommunication.Thewordsshouldthereforebe  p deleted. j 29.TheCHAIRPERSONendorsedMr._ Solari_ Ԁ_ Yrigoyen_ ssuggestion. ^ ... !R #X{XXX{z#  "F TRX3'LetterX3'Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta3'LetterscapeX3'3'Letter2-294/295 Laser TaXX T _ CCPR_ ,A/61/40vol.I(2006)   ...  L  M  L  M  CHAPTERVIFOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   227.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._ Ando_ ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventy-firstsession). t  228.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights;429Viewsoutofthe547Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehadbeena \  violationoftheCovenant. V 229.Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseandsubjective: J itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies.Manyfollow-up D repliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingnessoftheStatepartyto > implementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantanappropriateremedy.Other 8 repliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddresstheCommitteesViewsatall 2 oronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethatthevictimhasfiledaclaimfor ,| compensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensationcanthereforebepaid.Stillother &v repliesindicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartytoprovidearemedy,butthataremedy  p willbeaffordedtothecomplainantonanL  M  exgratiaL  M  Ԁbasis. j 230.Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualorlegal ^ grounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promiseaninvestigationof  X thematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,foronereasonoranother, !R giveeffecttotheCommitteesViews. !L 231.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffectthatthe #@  CommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitionerhasinformed $: ! theCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommitteesrecommendations,even %4!" thoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. &."# 232.Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-upinformationas ("$% thelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-uprepliesfromStatesparties )%& receivedupto7July2006,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant. *&' Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryor +'( unsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommitteesViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetween , () theStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViewscontinues.TheNotesfollowinga -)* numberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollow-upreplies.  233.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/60/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIofthe  presentannualreport.   TRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeX3'3'LetterscapeX3'TL  M  L  M  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   *2D3dd6UU6UU01..,dd ,dd , dd ,dd ,dd ,edd ,dd +  $ $Stateparty R andnumber L ofcaseswith  F violation ' @ 'L  M  L  M  Communication R number,authorand L  location ' F  'L  M  L  M  Follow-upresponse R  receivedfromStateparty L  andlocation ' F  'L  M  L  M  Satisfactory R response 'L 'L  M  L  M  Unsatisfactory R response 'L 'L  M  L  M  No R follow-up L response  F received ' @ 'L  M  L  M  Follow-up R dialogue L ongoing  F ...  ~    ~    ~    ~    ~    ~    ~  LibyanArab  \  _ Jamahiriya_  V ! (2) &P " &L  M  L  M  440/1990,L  M  El-_ Megreisi_ L  M    \ # A/49/40L  M  L  M  L  M   V $    \ %    \ &    \ ' X   \ ( X   \ )   0 ) 1107/2002,L  M  El_ Ghar_ L  M    * A/60/40   +    ,    -    . L  M  L  M  X  / L  M  A/61/40   0 X   1 ...  l2   l3   l4   l5   l6   l7  l8    F8 TRX3'LetterO'3Letter Landscape3'Letteremajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeen '3Letter LandscapeX3'TX{XXX{CEUS., _ CCPR_ ,A/61/40vol.II(2006)   ...  AnnexVII  FOLLOW-UPOFTHEHUMANRIGHTSCOMMITTEEONINDIVIDUALCOMMUNICATIONS   UNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOLTOTHEINTERNATIONALCOVENANTONCIVIL   ANDPOLITICALRIGHTS   ThisreportsetsoutallinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandauthorsortheircounselsincethelast t  AnnualReport(A/60/40).  n   ... h  *9:dddd dd  dd dd dd edd edd 2D3(#(#,bUU,UU+  1'\ \  1 Stateparty  \   LIBYANARAB_ JAMAHIRIYA_  6,\   6 Case  n    El_ Ghar_ ,1107/2002 ?5n  ? Viewsadoptedon  0  29March2004 6,0  6 Issuesand  violationsfound    RefusalbytheStatepartytoissuetheauthorwithapassportArticle12,  paragraph2. ?5  ? Remedy ^ recommended  X  TheStatepartyisunderanobligationtoensurethattheauthorhasaneffective ^ remedy,includingcompensation.TheCommitteeurgestheStatepartytoissue X theauthorwithapassportwithoutfurtherdelay. ?5R  ? DuedateforState d partyresponse  ^  4February2005 ?5d   ? Stateparty  ! response  !"  None ?5 #  ? Authorsresponse  #$  TheCommitteewillrecall,assetoutinthe84threport,thatbyletterdated23 #% June2005,theauthorreferredtotheStatepartysfailuretoimplementthe $& CommitteesViews. % ' On21February2006,theauthorinformedtheCommitteethataftermany t'") meetingswiththeLibyanconsulateinMorocco,inwhichshewasaccused, n(#* interalia,ofhavingcommittedtreasonagainsttheStatepartybybringingher h)$+ casebeforetheCommittee,itstilldoesnotappearlikelythatshewillreceive b*%, herpassport. \+&-  V,'. TheauthorinformedtheSecretariatinOctober2005thattheLibyanconsulate  inCasablancastillrefusedtoissueherpassport.InJune2006,sheinformed  theSecretariatbyphonethatshehadbeenpromisedherpassport.On7July  2006,sheinformedtheSecretariatthatshehadreceivedherpassport,butthat  shehadnotreceivedanycompensation.-#!   -US.,CE.,Y#X{XXX{:#  T   _ CCPR_ ,_ CCPR_ /C/SR.2450(2007)   HumanRightsCommittee  Eighty-ninthsession  Summaryrecordofthe2450thmeeting  HeldatHeadquarters,NewYork,onThursday,29March2007,at10a.m.   ...      FollowuptoconcludingobservationsonStatereportsandtoViewsundertheOptionalProtocol  z   ProgressreportoftheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uponViews(CCPR/C/89/R.5) n  1.  Mr.Shearer (SpecialRapporteurforfollow-uponViews)introducedhisreport,whichcompiled b  informationreceivedduringtheeighty-eighthandeighty-ninthsessionsoftheCommittee... \  ... V 10.  Mr.Shearer drewattentiontothecaseofElGahrv.LibyanArabJamahiriya(communication P No.1107/2002).TheStatepartyhadimplementedtheCommittee'sViewsbyfinallyissuingapassportto J theauthorforherstudiesinEurope,butapassportvalidforonlytwo,nottheusualfive,years.Under D "furtheraction",theCommitteewouldnotethedecisiontoprovidetheauthorwithapassportbutwould > requesttheStatepartytocommentonitsreasonsforissuingapassportvalidforonlytwoyears. 8 11.  Mr.Schmidt (TeamLeader,PetitionsUnit)saidthecasehadbeendiscussedwiththeStateparty ,| sincetheadoptionoftheCommittee'sViewsinMarch2004;regularupdateshadalsobeenreceivedfrom &v theauthor.Theredidseemtobeanelementofvindictivenessintheissuanceofapassportvalidforonly  p twoyears,whentheauthor'sstudieswouldrequireatleastthreeyearsandshewouldthereforebeforced j torequesttheissuanceofanotherpassport.Infollow-uptelephonecallstheauthorhadalsoraisedthe d questionoffinancialcompensationforthehardshipandfinanciallosscausedbytheStateparty'srefusalto ^ issueapassport.  X 12.  Mr.Khalil ,supportedby Mr.Bhagwati ,saidthattheCommitteemustrequestanexplanation !L fromtheStateparty.Thecasehadbeendraggingonforalongtimeandtheissuanceofapassportvalid "F foronlytwoyearsseemedclearlyvindictive.TheCommitteeshouldtrytoprevailontheStatepartytoat #@  leastissuetheauthorapassportvalidforthedurationofherstudies. $: ! 13.  TheChairperson saidtheCommittee'scommentsonfurtheractionwouldincludearequestthat &."# theStatepartyexplainitsdecisiontoissueapassportfortwoyearsratherthantheusualfiveyears. '(#$ ... ("$%   )%&  _ CCPR_ ,A/62/40vol.I(2007)   ...    CHAPTERVI.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   213.  InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._ Ando_ ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventy-firstsession). t  214.  In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights;452Viewsoutofthe570Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehadbeena \  violationoftheCovenant. V 215.  Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseand J subjective:itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies.Many D follow-uprepliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingnessoftheState > partytoimplementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantanappropriateremedy. 8 OtherrepliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddresstheCommitteesViews 2 atalloronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethatthevictimhasfiledaclaimfor ,| compensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensationcanthereforebepaid.Stillotherreplies &v indicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartytoprovidearemedy,butthataremedywillbe  p affordedtothecomplainantonanexgratiabasis. j 216.  Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualorlegal ^ grounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promiseaninvestigationof  X thematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,foronereasonoranother, !R giveeffecttotheCommitteesViews. !L 217.  Inmanycases,theCommitteesecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstothe #@  effectthattheCommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitioner $: ! hasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommittees %4!" recommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. &."# 218.  Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-upinformationas ("$% thelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-uprepliesfromStatesparties )%& receivedupto7July2007,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant. *&' Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryor +'( unsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommitteesViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetween , () theStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViewscontinues.TheNotesfollowinga -)* numberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollow-upreplies.  219.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/61/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIofthe  presentannualreport.  8_     TRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter Landscape   CHAPTERVI. 3'Letteremajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeen T  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   %*;<ddbUUbUU9:..,/\R,\R,\R,\R,\R,f\R,\\+  8DDD'  8Statepartyand  numberofcases  withviolation =DDD,!DDD =Communication  number,  authorandlocation =DDD,!DDD =Follow-upresponse   receivedfromState   partyandlocation =DDD,! DDD =Satisfactory   response =DDD,! DDD =Unsatisfactory  response =DDD,!DDD =Nofollow-up  response  received ?DDDD,!DDD ?Follow-up  dialogue  ongoing SDDB,  DDDD S... @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ @DD/! DD @ BDDD/! DD B ND?'  DDD NLibyanArab   _ Jamahiriya_ Ԁ(4) 4DD# D 4440/1990,El-_ Megreisi_    A/49/40 4DD#  DD 4 4DD# !DD 4 4DD# "DD 4 4DD# #DD 4X 6DDD# $DD 6X ED6 % DDD E 4DD# &D 41107/2002,El_ Ghar_   ' A/60/40 4DD# (DD 4X  ) A/61/40 4DD# *DD 4 4DD# +DD 4 4DD# ,DD 4 6DDD# -DD 6X  . A/62/40 ED6 / DDD E 4DD# 0D 41143/2002,_ Dernawi_   1 A/62/40 4DD# 2DD 4Notyetdue 4DD# 3DD 4 4DD# 4DD 4 4DD# 5DD 4 6DDD# 6DD 6 GDD6 7 DDD G 4DD# 8DD 41295/2004,El_ Awani_   9 A/61/40 4DD# :DD 4Notyetdue 4DD# ;DD 4 4DD# <DD 4 4DD# =DD 4 6DDD# >DD 6 9DD( ? DDD 9... +DD @DD + +DD ADD + +DD BDD + +DD CDD + +DD DDD + -DDD EDD -.$" F  DDD .