WPC U)Iʦ Z%TMOަSPfF.IZj,fܢBąp`GKK܋KIOLp+ I5N) zaՒ{'Pjt}[-r(`ӄL;/G 83_[wN;o]UhNb!0ζ'(GX 4S(A$n +hkN8JSo|K|sT'3Ӻs 4&5kYO#Կ-oW4B8j+SylG!Y)W#M%DE|@B'&hgR\L&i(⣲~jgϢ/Wid&І/Px\/) e@$)%ȇhs}G/K HT L^ _DvLzZ#UN % 0r ^ { w 4   m N 0J 0 U> f3 a5 UBI U> f a DE f$a& B-::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Bzg 0(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX(J$  XXXXXXXXp8 p8:i+003|xU42ParaNo. 8.9 AIQ!$8S\  `&Times New RomanS8.9 AIQ!$8S\  `&Times New RomanS<SS:Footnote TexS\  `&Times New RomanSS\  `&Times New RomanS\  `&Times New RomanhTABLE A\  `*Times New RomanTT\  `&Times New Roman$TABLE B88889Hairline!dxdxTABLE A)Hairline d d !  X{XXXX{XXX{  _  HXX{SENEGAL#X{XH#   u UKUS.,Follow-upJurisprudence    ActionbyTreatyBodiesUS.,UK.,  CCPRA/51/40,vol.I(1996)  h    VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   ...    429.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasat   26July1996providesthefollowingpicture:   ...   Senegal:Onedecisionfindingviolations;apreliminaryfollow-upreply,dated26June1995,promised v furtherinformationuponconclusionofStatepartyinvestigationsinthevictim'scase.Afurthersatisfactory p follow-upreply,dated15July1996,indicatedthatcompensationwouldbepaidtothevictim(seepara. j 461). d ... X 432.TheCommitteeisequallyawarethattheabsenceofspecificenablinglegislationisacrucialfactor L whichoftenstandsinthewayofmonetarycompensationtovictimsofviolationsoftheCovenant,orthe F grantingofotherremediesbasedontheCommittee'sviews.Thatargumentwas,forexample,adduced @ bytheGovernmentofAustriainitsfollow-upreplyontheviewsincaseNo.415/1990(Paugerv.Austria) : andbytheGovernmentofSenegalinitsfirstfollow-upreplyontheviewsincaseNo.386/1989(Kon 4 v.Senegal).TheCommitteecommendsthoseStatespartieswhichhavecompensatedvictimsofviolations . ~ oftheCovenant;iturgesStatespartiestoconsidertheadoptionofspecificenablinglegislationand,pending (!x that,tomakeexgratiapaymentsbywayofcompensation. ""r ... $f  Overviewofpositiveexamplesoffollow-upcooperation/replies  &Z!" ... 'N#$ 461.Duringthefifty-secondsession,inOctober1994,theCommitteeadoptedviewsoncommunication )B%& No.386/1989(Konv.Senegal),findingaviolationofarticle9,paragraph3,andrecommendingthat *<&' compensationbeawardedtotheauthor.Bysubmissiondated26June1995,theStatepartypromised +6'( informationupontheconclusionofthoroughinvestigationsintothevictim'scase.Afterareminder ,0() addressedtotheStatepartyinFebruary1996,theStateparty,bysubmissionof15July1996,informed -*)* theCommitteethatthePresidentofSenegalgaveinstructionstotheStateparty'sMinisterforJusticeto  makeanexgratiapaymenttoMr.Kon,ascompensationforthedurationofhispretrialdetention.    CCPRA/52/40,vol.I(1997)   VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  524.Acountry-by-countrybreakdownoffollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof   30June1997providesthefollowingpicture(Viewsinwhichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-up   informationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded):   ... t  Senegal:Onedecisionfindingviolations:386/1989-FamaraKon(1995Report);16/forStateparty's h  follow-upreply,see1996Report,10/para.461.Byletterof29April1997,authorconfirmsthat b  compensationwasofferedtohimbutrejectsitasinadequate. \  ____________ >   16/[OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,]FiftiethSession,SupplementNo.40(A/50/40). 8   10/[OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,]FiftyfirstSession,SupplementNo.40(A/51/40). 2   &v  CCPRA/53/40,vol.I(1998)   VIII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  486.TheCommittee'spreviousreport(A/52/40)containedadetailedcountry-by-countrybreakdownof   follow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1997.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollow-upinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates(Viewsin   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded).Italso z   indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethepreviousreport.ThisisbecausetheresourcesavailablefortheCommittee'sworkwere n  considerablyreducedinthecurrentyear,preventingitfromundertakingacomprehensivesystematic h  follow-upprogramme. b  ... V Senegal:Onedecisionfindingviolations:386/1989-FamaraKon(1995Report(A/50/40));forState J party'sfollow-upreply,see1996Report(A/51/40),para.461.Byletterof29April1997,authorconfirms D thatcompensationwasofferedtohimbutrejectsitasinadequate.Atthesixty-firstsession,theStateparty > informedtheCommitteethatthecompensationofferedhadbeenincreased,seesummaryrecord 8 (CCPR/C/SR.1619)of21October1997. 2   &v  CCPRA/54/40,vol.I(1999)   VII.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  461.TheCommittee'spreviousreport(A/53/40)containedadetailedcountry-by-countrybreakdown   offollow-uprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1998.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollow-upinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates(Viewsin   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollow-upinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded).Italso z   indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethelastreport.ThisisbecausetheresourcesavailablefortheCommittee'sworkhavebeen n  considerablyreducedpreventingitfromundertakingacomprehensivesystematicfollow-upprogramme. h  ... \  Senegal:Onedecisionfindingviolations:386/1989-FamaraKon(A/50/40);forStateparty'sfollow-up P reply,seeA/51/40,para.461.Byletterof29April1997,authorconfirmedthatcompensationwas J offeredtohimbutherejecteditasinadequate.Atthesixty-firstsession,theStatepartyinformedthe D Committeethatthecompensationofferedhadbeenincreased.Seesummaryrecordofthe1619thmeeting, > heldon21October1997(CCPR/C/SR.1619). 8   !R  CCPRA/55/40,vol.I(2000)   UKUS.,VI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  596.TheCommitteespreviousreport(A/54/40)containedadetailedcountrybycountrybreakdownof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June1999.Thelistthatfollowsshows   theadditionalcasesinrespectofwhichfollowupinformationhasbeenrequestedfromStates.(Viewsin   whichthedeadlineforreceiptoffollowupinformationhadnotyetexpiredhavenotbeenincluded.)Italso z   indicatesthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding.Inmanyofthesecasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethelastreport.ThisisbecausethelimitedresourcesavailablefortheCommitteesworkpreventit n  fromundertakingacomprehensiveorsystematicfollowupprogramme. h  ...US.,UK.,+UKUS., \  Senegal:Onedecisionfindingviolations:386/1989FamaraKon(A/50/40);fortheStatepartysfollow P upreply,seeA/51/40,para.461.Seealsosummaryrecordofthe1619thmeeting,heldon21October J 1997(CCPR/C/SR.1619).US.,UK.," D    !R  CCPRA/56/40,vol.I(2001)   X{XXX{UKUS.,ChapterIV.FollowupActivitiesundertheOptionalProtocolUS.,UK.,$UKUS.,#X{XXX{##X{XXX{    ...  180.  TheCommitteespreviousannualreport(A/55/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailedcountry   bycountrysurveyonfollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2000.The   listthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnot   takeintoaccounttheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventysecondsession,forwhichfollowup z   repliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesincethepreviousreport. t  ...#X{XXX{$#X{XXX{US.,UK.,p$UKUS., h  Senegal:Viewsinonecasefindingviolations:386/1989FamaraKon(A/50/40);forfollowupreply, \  seeA/51/40,paragraph461.Seealsosummaryrecordofthe1619thmeeting,heldon21October1997 V (CCPR/C/SR.1619).#X{XXX{'#US.,UK.,'  P  UKUS.,CCPRA/57/40,vol.I(2002)   ChapterVI.Followupactivitiesundertheoptionalprotocol  ...  228.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee(A/56/40,vol.I,chap.VI)containedadetailed   countrybycountrysurveyoffollowuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2001.   Thelistthatfollowsupdatesthatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoes   notincluderesponsesconcerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventyfourthandseventy z   fifthsessions,forwhichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdue.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesince t  thepreviousreport. n  ... b  Senegal:Viewsinonecasewithfindingsofviolations: V 386/1989FamaraKon(A/50/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/51/40,paragraph461.Seealsosummary J recordofthe1619thmeeting,heldon21October1997(CCPR/C/SR.1619). D ... 8 229.ForfurtherinformationonthestatusofalltheViewsinwhichfollowupinformationremains ,| outstandingorinrespectofwhichfollowupconsultationshavebeenorwillbescheduled,referenceis &v madetothefollowupprogressreportpreparedfortheseventy-fourthsessionoftheCommittee  p (CCPR/C/74/R.7/Rev.1,dated28March2002),discussedinpublicsessionattheCommittees2009th j meetingon4April2002(CCPR/C/SR.2009).ReferenceisalsomadetotheCommitteesprevious d reports,inparticularA/56/40,paragraphs182to200. ^ US.,UK.,V)   X  CEUS.,CCPRA/58/40,vol.I(2003)   CHAPTERVI.FollowupactivitiesundertheOptionalProtocol  ...  223.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountrybycountrysurveyof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2002.Thelistthatfollowsupdates   thatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotincluderesponses   concerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheseventyseventhandseventyeighthsessions,for z   whichfollowuprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochange t  sincethepreviousreport.* n  ... b  Senegal: ` 0 Viewsinonecasewithfindingsofviolations:V (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#386/1989FamaraKon(A/50/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/51/40, J paragraph461.Seealsosummaryrecordofthe1619thmeeting,heldon21 D October1997(CCPR/C/SR.1619).> (# (# Notes ,| 1.[OfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly],FiftyseventhSession,SupplementNo.40(A/57/40),  p vol.I,chap.VI. j *ThedocumentsymbolA/[SessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordoftheGeneralAssembly ^ inwhichthecaseappears;annexVIreferstothepresentreport,vol.II.  X US.,CE.,0_  !L CEUS., _CCPR_ԀA/59/40vol.I(2004)   CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL  ...  230.ThepreviousannualreportoftheCommittee1containedadetailedcountry-by-countrysurveyof   followuprepliesreceivedorrequestedandoutstandingasof30June2003.Thelistthatfollowsupdates   thatsurvey,indicatingthosecasesinwhichrepliesareoutstanding,butdoesnotincluderesponses   concerningtheCommitteesViewsadoptedduringtheeightiethandeightyfirstsessions,forwhichfollow z   uprepliesarenotyetdueinthemajorityofcases.Inmanycasestherehasbeennochangesincethe t  previousreport.* n  ... b  Senegal: ` 0 Viewsinonecasewithfindingsofviolations:V (# (# 0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#386/1989_Famara_Ԁ_Kon_(A/50/40);forfollowupreply,seeA/51/40, J paragraph461.Seealsosummaryrecordofthe1619thmeeting,heldon21 D October1997(_CCPR_/C/SR.1619).> (# (# US.,CE.,7CEUS.,US.,CE.,=CEUS.,US.,CE.,=CEUS.,_______________ ,| Notes &v 1/Ibid.,FiftyeighthSession,SupplementNo.40(A/58/40),vol.I,chap.VI. j *ThedocumentsymbolA/[sessionNo.]/40referstotheOfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssemblyin ^ whichthecaseappears;annexIXreferstothepresentreport,volumeII.  X US.,CE.,=  "F CEUS., _CCPR_,A/60/40vol.I(2005)   ...  CHAPTERVI.FOLLOWUPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   224.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollowuptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forthefollowuponViewstothiseffect.Mr.AndohasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventyfirstsession). t  225.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollowupinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights.Atotalof391Viewsoutofthe503Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehad \  beenaviolationoftheCovenant. V 228.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffectthatthe J CommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitionerhasinformed D theCommitteethattheStatepartyhasinfactgiveneffecttotheCommitteesrecommendations,even > thoughtheStatepartydidnotitselfprovidethatinformation. 8 229.Thepresentannualreportadoptsadifferentformatforthepresentationoffollowupinformation ,| comparedtopreviousannualreports.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollowupreplies &v fromStatespartiesreceivedasof28July2005,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefound  p violationsoftheCovenant.Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollowuprepliesareorhavebeen j consideredassatisfactoryorunsatisfactory,intermsofcomplyingwiththeCommitteesViews,orwhether d thedialoguebetweentheStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollowuponViewscontinues.The ^ notesfollowinganumberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollowupreplies.  X 230.FollowupinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentativessince !L thelastannualreportissetoutinanewannexVII,containedinVolumeIIofthepresentannualreport. "F This,moredetailed,followupinformationalsoindicatesactionstilloutstandinginthosecasesthatremain #@  underreview. $: !   '(#$ TRO'3#Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeLaser Ta Landscape3'LetterT   FOLLOWUPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   #L*64Y7ed dd Xdd Xdd X..,'bZ,4bZ, bZ,'bZ,bZ,bZ,bb+  6YY' @6ԃXX{ԃԃUS.,CE.,?UKUS.,Statepartyand  numberofcases o withviolation#ԃԃMN#US.,UK.,NCEUS., ;YY,!8 @YY @;ԃԃUS.,CE.,+OUKUS.,Communicationnumber,  authorand_locationa_#ԃԃxO#US.,UK.,OCEUS., ;YY,!o@YY @;  ԃԃUS.,CE.,dPUKUS.,Followupresponsereceivedfrom   Statepartyandlocation#ԃԃP#US.,UK.,PCEUS., ;YY,!o @YY @;Satisfactory   response ;YY,!o @YY @;Unsatisfactory   response ;YY,!o@YY @;Nofollowup  response ?YYY,!o@YY @?Followup  dialogue o ongoing IYY:'8 @  YYY @I... ;YY,! a@YY @; ;YY,! a@YY @; ;YY,! a@YY @; ;YY,! a@YY @; ;YY,! a@YY @; ?YYY,! a@YY @? PYYY?' a@  YYY @PSenegal(1) =YYY,! :@YYY @=386/1989,_Famara_Ԁ_Kon_  : A/50/40 =YYY,! @YYY @=X  : A/51/40,summaryrecord   of1619thmeetingheld |   on21October1997 E ! (_CCPR_/C/SR.1619) =YYY,!^ "@YYY @=X =YYY,! :#@YYY @= =YYY,! :$@YYY @= ?YYYY,! :%@YYY @?<20 :&@    YYYY <#X{Xԃ.N#aThelocationreferstothedocumentsymboloftheOfficialRecordsoftheGeneralAssembly,SupplementNo.40,whichistheannualreport ) ' oftheCommitteetotherespectivesessionsoftheAssembly. # ( US.,CE.,Q  + TRX3'LetterO'3#Avery 12-294/295 Laser Ta Landscape3'LetterscapeX3''3Letter LandscapeLaser Ta LandscapeT _CCPR_,A/61/40vol.I(2006)   ...  L  M  L  M  CHAPTERVIFOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   227.InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._Ando_ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventy-firstsession). t  228.In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights;429Viewsoutofthe547Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehadbeena \  violationoftheCovenant. V 229.Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseandsubjective: J itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies.Manyfollow-up D repliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingnessoftheStatepartyto > implementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantanappropriateremedy.Other 8 repliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddresstheCommitteesViewsatall 2 oronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethatthevictimhasfiledaclaimfor ,| compensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensationcanthereforebepaid.Stillother &v repliesindicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartytoprovidearemedy,butthataremedy  p willbeaffordedtothecomplainantonanL  M  exgratiaL  M  Ԁbasis. j 230.Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualorlegal ^ grounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promiseaninvestigationof  X thematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,foronereasonoranother, !R giveeffecttotheCommitteesViews. !L 231.Inmanycases,theSecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstotheeffectthatthe #@  CommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitionerhasinformed $: ! theCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommitteesrecommendations,even %4!" thoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. &."# 232.Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-upinformationas ("$% thelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-uprepliesfromStatesparties )%& receivedupto7July2006,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant. *&' Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryor +'( unsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommitteesViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetween , () theStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViewscontinues.TheNotesfollowinga -)* numberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollow-upreplies.  233.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/60/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIofthe  presentannualreport.      TRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeX3'3'LetterscapeX3'TL  M  L  M  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   *Yded'bZ'4bZ4 bZ 'bZ'bZbZbb64Y7..,dd ,dd , dd ,dd ,dd ,edd ,dd +  $ $Stateparty R and L numberof  F caseswith  @ violation ' : 'L  M  L  M  Communication R  number,authorand L  location ' F  'L  M  L  M  Follow-upresponse R  receivedfromStateparty L  andlocation ' F 'L  M  L  M  Satisfactory R response 'L 'L  M  L  M  Unsatisfactory R response 'L 'L  M  L  M  No R follow-up L response  F received ' @ 'L  M  L  M  Follow-up R dialogue L ongoing  F ...  x    x    x    x    x    x    x   Senegal(1)  V ! 386/1989,L  M  _Famara_ V " _Kon_L  M   P # A/50/40  J $ L  M  L  M  X V % L  M  A/51/40,summaryrecordof P & 1619thmeetingheldon J ' 21October1997  D ( X  V )   V *   V +   V , ...  -   .   /   0   1   2  3    3 TRX3'LetterO'3Letter Landscape3'Lettertbeenincluded.)Italso z   indicatest'3Letter LandscapeX3'T _CCPR_,A/62/40vol.I(2007)   ...  CHAPTERVI.FOLLOW-UPACTIVITIESUNDERTHEOPTIONALPROTOCOL   213.  InJuly1990,theCommitteeestablishedaprocedureforthemonitoringoffollow-uptoitsViews   underarticle5,paragraph4,oftheOptionalProtocol,andcreatedthemandateoftheSpecialRapporteur   forfollow-uptoViewstothiseffect.Mr._Ando_ԀhasbeentheSpecialRapporteursinceMarch2001 z   (seventy-firstsession). t  214.  In1991,theSpecialRapporteurbegantorequestfollow-upinformationfromStatesparties.Such h  informationhasbeensystematicallyrequestedinrespectofallViewswithafindingofaviolationof b  Covenantrights;452Viewsoutofthe570Viewsadoptedsince1979concludedthattherehadbeena \  violationoftheCovenant. V 215.  Allattemptstocategorizefollow-uprepliesbyStatespartiesareinherentlyimpreciseand J subjective:itaccordinglyisnotpossibletoprovideaneatstatisticalbreakdownoffollow-upreplies.Many D follow-uprepliesreceivedmaybeconsideredsatisfactory,inthattheydisplaythewillingnessoftheState > partytoimplementtheCommitteesrecommendationsortoofferthecomplainantanappropriateremedy. 8 OtherrepliescannotbeconsideredsatisfactorybecausetheyeitherdonotaddresstheCommitteesViews 2 atalloronlyrelatetocertainaspectsofthem.Somerepliessimplynotethatthevictimhasfiledaclaimfor ,| compensationoutsidestatutorydeadlinesandthatnocompensationcanthereforebepaid.Stillotherreplies &v indicatethatthereisnolegalobligationontheStatepartytoprovidearemedy,butthataremedywillbe  p affordedtothecomplainantonanexgratiabasis. j 216.  Theremainingfollow-upreplieschallengetheCommitteesViewsandfindingsonfactualorlegal ^ grounds,constitutemuch-belatedsubmissionsonthemeritsofthecomplaint,promiseaninvestigationof  X thematterconsideredbytheCommitteeorindicatethattheStatepartywillnot,foronereasonoranother, !R giveeffecttotheCommitteesViews. !L 217.  Inmanycases,theCommitteesecretariathasalsoreceivedinformationfromcomplainantstothe #@  effectthattheCommitteesViewshavenotbeenimplemented.Conversely,inrareinstances,thepetitioner $: ! hasinformedtheCommitteethattheStatepartyhadinfactgiveneffecttotheCommittees %4!" recommendations,eventhoughtheStatepartyhadnotitselfprovidedthatinformation. &."# 218.  Thepresentannualreportadoptsthesameformatforthepresentationoffollow-upinformationas ("$% thelastannualreport.Thetablebelowdisplaysacompletepictureoffollow-uprepliesfromStatesparties )%& receivedupto7July2007,inrelationtoViewsinwhichtheCommitteefoundviolationsoftheCovenant. *&' Whereverpossible,itindicateswhetherfollow-uprepliesareorhavebeenconsideredassatisfactoryor +'( unsatisfactory,intermsoftheircompliancewiththeCommitteesViews,orwhetherthedialoguebetween , () theStatepartyandtheSpecialRapporteurforfollow-uptoViewscontinues.TheNotesfollowinga -)* numberofcaseentriesconveyanideaofthedifficultiesincategorizingfollow-upreplies.  219.  Follow-upinformationprovidedbyStatespartiesandbypetitionersortheirrepresentatives  subsequenttothelastannualreport(A/61/40,vol.I,chap.VI)issetoutinannexVIItovolumeIIofthe  presentannualreport.      XRO'3Letter LandscapeX3'Letter'3Letter LandscapeX3'3'Lettertbeenincluded.)Italso z   indicatestvX  FOLLOW-UPRECEIVEDTODATEFORALLCASESOFVIOLATIONSOFTHECOVENANT   }*dddd dd  dd dd dd edd edd Y..,/\R,\R,\R,\R,\R,f\R,\\+  8YYY'  8Statepartyand  numberofcases  withviolation =YYY,!YYY =Communication  number,  authorandlocation =YYY,!YYY =Follow-upresponse   receivedfromState   partyandlocation =YYY,! YYY =Satisfactory   response =YYY,! YYY =Unsatisfactory  response =YYY,!YYY =Nofollow-up  response  received ?YYYY,!YYY ?Follow-up  dialogue  ongoing SYYB,  YYYY S... @YY/! YY @ @YY/! YY @ @YY/! YY @ @YY/! YY @ @YY/! YY @ BYYY/! YY B PYY?'  YYY PSenegal(1) 4YY# YY 4386/1989,_Famara_Ԁ_Kon_   A/50/40 4YY# YY 4X    A/51/40,summary  ! recordof1619th  " meetingheldon  # 21October1997 4YY# $YY 4X  % Ѐ 4YY# &YY 4 4YY# 'YY 4 6YYY# (YY 6 9YY( ) YYY 9... +YY *YY + +YY +YY + +YY ,YY + +YY -YY + +YY .YY + -YYY /YY -.$" 0  YYY .