Bayefsky.com

The United Nations Human Rights Treaties

How To Complain About Human Rights Treaty Violations

Index of Cases of CCPR by Article

Printer-friendly version

for cases by state party see Jurisprudence
to update generally see jurisprudence at: http://www.unhchr.ch/tbs/doc.nsf
A= admissibility decision
DC= discontinued cases
DJ= decision to deal with cases jointly
I= interim measures
V= views


ARTICLE 1

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lubicon Lake Band v.Canada (V) 167/1984 26 March 1990 Violation
E.P. et al. v. Colombia (A) 318/1988 25 July 1990 Inadmissible
A.B. et al. v. Italy (A) 413/1990 2 November 1990 Inadmissible
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus (V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Wilson v. Australia (A) 1239/2004 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
S.N.A. v. Cameroon (A) 1962/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Martinez et al. v. Algeria (A) 1922/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
H.E.A.K. v. Denmark (V) 2343/2014 23 July 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 1(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Šroub v. Czech Republic (A) 1573/2007 27 October 2009 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 2

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)
30 July 1981 Violation
Stalla Costa v. Uruguay (V) 198/1985 9 July 1987 No violation
Nahlik v. Austria (A) 608/1995 22 July 1996 Inadmissible
Drobek v. Slovakia (A) 643/1995 14 July 1997 Inadmissible
Lestourneaud v. France (A) 861/1999 3 November 1999 Inadmissible
Ignatane v. Latvia (V) 884/1999 25 July 2001 Violation
Mazou v. Cameroon (V) 630/1995 26 July 2001 Violation
Äärelä and Näkkäläjärvi v. Finland (V) 779/1997 24 October 2001 Violation
Des Fours v. Czech Republic (V) 747/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Brok v. Czech Republic (V) 774/1997 31 October 2001 Violation
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo(V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Patera v. Czech Republic (V) 946/2000 25 July 2002 Violation
Pezoldova v. Czech Republic (V) 757/1997 25 October 2002 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus (V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Veriter v. France (A) 1088/2002 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Zheikov v. Russian Federation(V) 889/1999 17 March 2006 Violation
Sinitsin v. Belarus (V) 1047/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Alzery v. Sweden (V) 1416/2005 25 October 2006 Violation
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
Mavlonov and Sa’di v. Uzbekistan (V) 1334/2004 19 March 2009 Violation
Vassilari et al. v. Greece (V) 1570/2007 19 March 2009 No violation
Munaf v. Romania (V) 1539/2006 30 July 2009 No violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Eshonov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1225/2003 22 July 2010 Violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation
Albareda et. al v. Uruguay (V) 1637/2007,1757&1765/2008 24 October 2011 Violation
Nenova et al v. Libya (V) 1880/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
Krasovskaya & Krasovskay v. Belarus (A) 1820/2008 26 March 2012 Inadmissible
Katsora v. Belarus (V) 1836/2008 24 October 2012 Violation
Naidenova et al v. Bulgaria (V) 2073/2011 30 October 2012 Violation
Israil v. Kazakhstan (V) 2024/2011 31 October 2011 Violation
Singh v. France (V) 1852/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Kholodova v. Russian Federation (V) 1548/2007 1 November 2012 Violation
Bakurov v. Russian Federation (V) 1861/2009 25 March 2013 No violation
A.P. v. Russian Federation (A) 1857/2008 28 March 2013 Inadmissible
Pichugina v. Belarus (V) 1592/2007 17 July 2013 Violation
Singh v. France (V) 1928/2010 19 July 2013 Violation
Shakeel v. Canada (V) 1881/2009 24 July 2013 Violation
Alekperov v. Russian Federation (V) 1764/2008 21 October 2013 No violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Rizvanovic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1997/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Dorofeev v. Russian Federation (V) 2041/2011 11 July 2014 Violation
Pronina v. France (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Hickey v. Australia (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
S.I.D. et al v. Bulgaria (A) 1926/2010 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Yachnik v. Belarus (A) 1990/2010 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Jum'a et al v. Libya (V) 1958/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Kuznetsov et al v. Belarus (V) 1976/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Evrezov et al v. Belarus (V) 1999/2010 10 October 2014 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2114/2011 22 October 2014 Violation
Husseini v. Denmark (V) 2243/2013 24 October 2014 Violation
Pinchuk v. Belarus (V) 2165/2012 24 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Leghaei v. Australia (V) 1937/2010 26 March 2015 Violation
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
B. & C. v. Czech Republic (A) 1967/2010 2 April 2015 Inadmissible
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
H.E.A.K. v. Denmark (V) 2343/2014 23 July 2015 Violation
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
G.C.A.A. v. Uruguay (A) 2358/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Zeynalov v. Estonia (V) 2040/2011 4 November 2015 Violation
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Chani v. Algeria (V) 2297/2013 11 March 2016 Violation
V.L. v. Belarus (A) 2084/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
X. v. Netherlands (A) 2729/2016 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
Ortikov v. Uzbekistan (V) 2317/2013 26 October 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 2(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Toonen v. Australia (V) 488/1992 30 March 1994 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation
Arenz v. Germany (A) 1138/2002 24 March 2004 Inadmissible
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Solís v. Peru (V) 1016/2001 27 March 2006 No Violation
Tsarjov v. Estonia (V) 1223/2003 26 October 2007 No Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Munaf v. Romania (V) 1539/2006 30 July 2009 No violation
Hamida v. Canada (V) 1544/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation
Katsaris v. Greece (V) 1558/2007 18 July 2012 Violation
Lin v. Australia (V) 1957/2010 21 March 2013 No violation
Q.H.L. v. Australia (A) 1938/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Castaneda v. Mexico (V) 2202/2012 18 July 2013 No violation
Martinez et al. v. Algeria (A) 1922/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
F.B.L v. Costa Rica (A) 1612/2007 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
Pronina v. France (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Vojnovic v. Croatia (A) 2068/2011 10 October 2014 Inadmissible
Monika v. Cameroon (V) 1965/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Leven v. Kazakhstan (V) 2131/2012 21 October 2014 No violation
X. v. Czech Republic (A) 1961/2010 2 April 2015 Inadmissible
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 2082/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Mellet v. Ireland (V) 2324/2013 31 March 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 2(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Castaneda v. Mexico (V) 2202/2012 18 July 2013 No violation
F.B.L v. Costa Rica (A) 1612/2007 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Jusinskas v. Lithuania (A) 2014/2010 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Poliakov v. Belarus (V) 2103/2011 17 July 2014 Violation
Poliakov v. Belarus (V) 2030/2011 17 July 2014 Violation
Nepomnyaschikh v. Belarus (V) 2156/2012 10 October 2014 Violation
Griffiths v. Australia (V) 1973/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
V.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2043/2011 15 July 2015 No violation
Yusupova v. Russian Federation (A) 2036/2010 21 July 2015 Inadmissible
Mikhalchenko v. Belarus (V) 1982/2010 22 July 2015 Violation
Poplavny v. Belarus (V) 2019/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Yusupova v. Russian Federation (A) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Inadmissible
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
Poplavny, Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2139/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
El Boathi v. Algeria (V) 2259/2013 17 March 2017 Violation
F. A. H. v. Colombia (A) 2121/2011 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 2(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Fanali v. Italy (V) 75/1980 31 March 1983 No violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Rodrínez Veiga v.Uruguay (A) 487/1992 18 July 1994 Inadmissible
Rodríguez v. Uruguay (V) 322/1988 19 July 1994 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Weiss v. Austria (V) 1086/2002 3 April 2003 Violation
Chambala v. Zambia (V) 856/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Kankanamge v. Sri Lanka (V) 909/2000 27 July 2004 Violation
Czernin v. Czech Republic (V) 823/1998 29 March 2005 Violation
Faure v.Australia (V) 1036/2001 31 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Blaga v. Romania (V) 1158/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Boucherf v. Algeria (V) 1196/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
Pimentel v. Philippines (V) 1320/2004 19 March 2007 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Shams et al. v. Australia (V) 1255,1256,
1259,1260,
1266,1268,
1270,1288/2004
20 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Banda v. Sri Lanka (V) 1426/2005 26 October 2007 Violation
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Kalamiotis v. Greece (V) 1486/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Umetaliev and Tashtanbekova v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1275/2004 30 October 2008 Violation
Marcellana and Gumanoy v. The Philippines (V) 1560/2007 30 October 2008 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Poma v. Peru (V) 1457/2006 27 March 2009 Violation
Amirov and Amirova v. Russian Federation (V) 1447/2006 2 April 2009 Violation
Williams Lecraft v. Spain (V) 1493/2006 27 July 2009 Violation
Dumont v. Canada (V) 1467/2006 16 March 2010 Violation
Pestaño v. Philippines (V) 1619/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Gonzalez v. Republic of Guyana (V) 1246/2004 25 March 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Hernandez v. Philippines 1559/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Georgopoulos et al. v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Novaković v. Republic of Serbia (V) 1556/2007 21 October 2010 Violation
Avadanov v. Azerbaijan (V) 1633/2007 25 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
McCallum v. South Africa (V) 1818/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Sechremelis et al. v. Greece 1507/2006 25 October 2010 No violation
González v. Argentina (V) 1458/2006 17 March 2011 Violation
Yevdokimov and Rezanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1410/2005 21 March 2011 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V) 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Zyuskin v. Russian Federation (V) 1605/2007 19 July 2011 Violation
Zhumbaeva and Moidunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1756/2008 19 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation
Israil v. Kazakhstan (V) 2024/2011 31 October 2011 Violation
Djebrouni v. Algeria (V) 1781/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Traoré v. Côte d’Ivoire (V) 1759/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Chihoub v. Algeria (V) 1811/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Jumaa v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1755/2008 19 March 2012 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
G. K. v. Netherlands (V) 1801/2008 22 March 2012 No violation
Benitez v. Paraguay (V) 1829/2008 22 March 2012 Violation
Kirani v. Algeria (V) 1905/2009 26 March 2012 Violation
Katsaris v. Greece (V) 1558/2007 18 July 2012 Violation
Guezout et al. v. Algeria (V) 1753/2008 19 July 2012 Violation
Maharjan v. Nepal (V) 1863/2009 19 July 2012 Violation
Chiti v. Zambia (V) 1303/2004 26 July 2012 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Mandic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2064/2011 5 November 2012 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Saadoun v. Algeria (V) 1806/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Puertas v. Spain (V) 1945/2010 27 March 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Sedhai v. Nepal (V) 1865/2009 19 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
F.B.L v. Costa Rica (A) 1612/2007 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Jusinskas v. Lithuania (A) 2014/2010 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
A.W.P v. Denmark (A) 1879/2009 1 November 2013 Inadmissible
Terafi v. Algeria (V) 1899/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Rizvanovic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1997/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Mehalli et al. v. Algeria (V) 1900/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
T.W. and G.M. v. Slovak Republic (A) 1963/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Horvath v. Australia (V) 1885/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
Duric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1956/2010 16 July 2014 Violation
Selimovic et al v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2003/2010 17 July 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Pronina v. France (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Fedsi v. Algeria (V) 1964/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Bouzaout v. Algeria (V) 1974/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Bouzenia v. Algeria (V) 1931/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Koktish v. Belarus (V) 1985/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Timmer v. Netherlands (V) 2097/2011 24 July 2014 Violation
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
D’Amore v. Argentina (A) 2071/2011 24 July 2014 Inadmissible
Nepomnyaschikh v. Belarus (V) 2156/2012 10 October 2014 Violation
Bolivar v. Venezuela (V) 2085/2011 16 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Monika v. Cameroon (V) 1965/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Chaulagain v. Nepal (V) 2018/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Hero v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1966/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Kozljak v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1970/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Sassene v. Algeria (V) 2026/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Basnet v. Nepal (V) 2051/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Bhandari v. Nepal (V) 2031/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Dehimi & Ayache v. Algeria (V) 2086/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Louddi v. Algeria (V) 2117/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Ammari v. Algeria (V) 2098/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Kroumi v. Algeria (V) 2083/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
A.H.G. v. Canada (V) 2091/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
Ernazarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2054/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1992/2010 27 March 2015 Violation
Hamulic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2022/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Icic & Mevlida v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2028/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Guneththige v. Sri Lanka (V) 2087/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
X. v. Czech Republic (A) 1961/2010 2 April 2015 Inadmissible
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Yusupova v. Russian Federation (A) 2036/2010 21 July 2015 Inadmissible
Dovadzija et al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Akmatov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2052/2011 29 October 2015 Violation
Poplavny v. Belarus (V) 2019/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
X v. Norway (V) 2474/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
F.M. v. Canada (V) 2284/2013 5 November 2015 No violation
Kadiric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2048/2011 5 November 2015 Violation
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
A.S v. Nepal (V) 2077/2011 6 November 2015 Violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Mohamed Rabbae v. Netherlands (V) 2124/2011 14 July 2016 No violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
X. and Y. v. Canada (A) 2771/2016 3 November 2016 Inadmissible
Poplavny, Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2139/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
Kerrouche v. Algeria (V) 2128/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
Dmitry Tyan v. Kazakhstan (V) 2125/2011 16 March 2017 Violation
El Boathi v. Algeria (V) 2259/2013 17 March 2017 Violation
Contreras v. Canada (V) 2613/2015 27 March 2017 Violation
F. A. H. v. Colombia (A) 2121/2011 28 March 2017 Inadmissible
N.R. v. New Zealand (A) 2801/2016 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

 
ARTICLE 2(3)(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Agabekova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1071/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Vlček v. Czech Republic (V) 1485/2006 10 July 2008 Violation
Kohoutek v. Czech Republic (V) 1448/2006 17 July 2008 Violation
Preiss v. Czech Republic (V) 1497/2006 17 July 2008 Violation
Aboushanif v. Norway (V) 1542/2007 17 July 2008 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 July 2008 Violation
Bandaranayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1376/2005 24 July 2008 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Amundson v. Czech Republic (V) 1508/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Isaev and Karimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1163/2003 20 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Tornel et al. v. Spain (V) 1473/2006 20 March 2009 Violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Reshetnikov v. Russian Federation (V) 1278/2004 23 March 2009 Violation
Persan v. Czech Republic (V) 1479/2006 24 March 2009 Violation
Asensi v. Paraguay 1407/2005 27 March 2009 Violation
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Sattorov v. Tajikistan (V) 1200/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Uclés v. Spain (V) 1364/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Kibaya v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1483/2006 30 July 2009 Violation
Batyrov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1585/2007 30 July 2009 Violation
Slezák v. Czech Republic (V) 1574/2007 20 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Martínez v. Spain (V) 1363/2005 19 October 2009 Violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Lukyanchik v. Belarus (V) 1392/2005 21 October 2009 Violation
Khostikoev v. Tajikistan (V) 1519/2006 22 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Latifulin v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1312/2004 10 March 2010 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Kaldarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1338/2005 18 March 2010 Violation
Hamida v. Canada (V) 1544/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Gapirjanov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1589/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Guerra de la Espriella v. Colombia (V) 1623/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Tillman v. Australia (V) 1635/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Jung et al. v. Republic of Korea (V) 1593-1603/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pestaño v. Philippines (V) 1619/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Castaneda v. Mexico (V) 2202/2012 18 July 2013 No violation
X.Q.H. V. New Zealand (A) 2197/2012 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Griffiths v. Australia (V) 1973/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
V.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2043/2011 15 July 2015 No violation
Romanovsky v. Belarus (V) 2011/2010 29 October 2015 Violation
T.V. & A.G. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2044/2011 11 March 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible


ARTICLE 2(3)(b)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Goyet v. France (A) 1746/2008 30 October 2008 Inadmissible
Vojnovic v. Croatia (A) 2068/2011 10 October 2014 Inadmissible
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

 
ARTICLE 2(3)(c)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kibaya v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1483/2006 30 July 2009 Violation
Castaneda v. Mexico (V) 2202/2012 18 July 2013 No violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

 
ARTICLE 3

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)
30 July 1981 Violation
Avellanal v. Peru (V) 202/1986 28 October 1988 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
A.A.C. v. Sweden (V) 277/2003 16 November 2006 No Violation
Tebourski v. France (V) 300/2006 1 May 2007 Violation
C.A.R.M. et al. v. Canada (V) 298/2006 18 May 2007 No violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
F.B.L v. Costa Rica (A) 1612/2007 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
Yusupova v. Russian Federation (A) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Inadmissible
X v. Canada (V) 2366/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Y v. Canada (V) 2327/2014 10 March 2016 No violation
Mellet v. Ireland (V) 2324/2013 31 March 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 4

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 5

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
M.A. v. Italy (A) 117/1981 10 April 1984 Inadmissible
J.A.B.G. v. Spain (A) 1891/2009 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
M.N. et al. v. Tajikistan (A) 1500/2006 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
F.B.L v. Costa Rica (A) 1612/2007 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Martinez et al. v. Algeria (A) 1922/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Dorofeev v. Russian Federation (V) 2041/2011 11 July 2014 Violation
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 5(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Romanovsky v. Belarus (V) 2011/2010 29 October 2015 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 2082/2011 14 July 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 5(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Sevostyanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1856/2008 1 November 2013 Violation
Kozlov v. Belarus (V) 1986/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Y v. Canada (V) 2327/2014 10 March 2016 No violation
X. v. Netherlands (A) 2729/2016 14 July 2016 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 6

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)
29 March 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Miango v. Zaire (V) 194/1985 27 October 1987 Violation
Herrera v. Colombia (V) 161/1983 2 November 1987 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Arévalo v. Colombia (V) 181/1984 3 November 1989 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Little v. Jamaica (V) 283/1988 1 November 1991 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Simmonds v. Jamaica (V) 338/1988 23 October 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 307/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Kindler v. Canada (V) 470/1991 30 July 1993 No violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 333/1988 23 March 1994 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Champagnie et. al v. Jamaica (V) 445/1991 18 July 1994 Violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 &482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Piandiong et al. v. Philippines (V) 869/1999 19 October 2000 No violation
Mansaraj et al. v. Sierra Leone (V) 839, 840 &841/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Sahadath v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 684/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Sarma v. Sri Lanka (V) 950/2000 16 July 2003 Violation
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Aliev v. Ukraine (V) 781/1997 07 August 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Arutyunyan v. Uzbekistan (V) 917/2000 29 March 2004 Violation
Smartt v. Republic of Guyana (V) 867/1999 6 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Mulai v. Republic of Guyana (V) 811/1998 20 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation
Celal v. Greece (A) 1235/2003 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Siragev v. Uzbekistan (V) 907/2000 1 November 2005 Violation
Hussain and Hussain v. Guyana (V) 862/1999 25 October 2005 Violation
Chan v. Guyana (V) 913/2000 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
Khan v. Canada (A) 1302/2004 25 July 2006 Inadmissible
Brun v. France (A) 1453/2006 18 October 2006 Inadmissible
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Yakupova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1205/2003 3 April 2008 No violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Kaur v. Canada (A) 1455/2006 30 October 2008 Inadmissible
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Amirov and Amirova v. Russian Federation (V) 1447/2006 2 April 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Kwok v. Australia (V) 1442/2005 23 October 2009 Violation
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Pestaño v. Philippines (V) 1619/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Novaković v. Republic of Serbia (V) 1556/2007 21 October 2010 Violation
Hernandez v. Philippines 1559/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V) 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation
Peiris v. Sri Lanka (V) 1862/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Israil v. Kazakhstan (V) 2024/2011 31 October 2011 Violation
X. v. Sweden (V) 1833/2008 1 November 2011 Violation
Nenova et al v. Libya (V) 1880/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
Kamoyo v. Zambia (V) 1859/2009 23 March 2012 Violation
Chiti v. Zambia (V) 1303/2004 26 July 2012 Violation
Kholodova v. Russian Federation (V) 1548/2007/td> 1 November 2012 Violation
Mandic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2064/2011 5 November 2012 Violation
Lin v. Australia (V) 1957/2010 21 March 2013 No violation
Bakurov v. Russian Federation (V) 1861/2009 25 March 2013 No violation
Q.H.L. v. Australia (A) 1938/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Alekperov v. Russian Federation (V) 1764/2008 21 October 2013 No violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Mehalli et al. v. Algeria (V) 1900/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Rizvanovic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1997/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Duric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1956/2010 16 July 2014 Violation
Selimovic et al v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2003/2010 17 July 2014 Violation
Hickey v. Australia (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
X. v. Denmark (V) 2186/2012 22 October 2014 Violation
Chaulagain v. Nepal (V) 2018/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Kozljak v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1970/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Hero v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1966/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Bhandari v. Nepal (V) 2031/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Hamulic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2022/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Icic & Mevlida v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2028/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
AH v. Denmark (V) 2370/2014 16 July 2015 Violation
Dovadzija et al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
R.G. et al. v. Denmark (A) 2351/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
G.C.A.A. v. Uruguay (A) 2358/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Kadiric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2048/2011 5 November 2015 Violation
A. v. Denmark (A) 2357/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
A and B v. Denmark (V) 2291/2013 13 July 2016 No violation
S.M. v. Bulgaria (A) 2100/2011 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
El Boathi v. Algeria (V) 2259/2013 17 March 2017 Violation
Contreras v. Canada (V) 2613/2015 27 March 2017 Violation

ARTICLE 6(1)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
de Guerrero v. Colombia (V) 45/1979
(R.11/45)
31 March 1982 Violation
Baboeram et al. v. Suriname (V) 146 & 148-154/1983 4 April 1985 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
Mojica v. Dominican Republic (V) 449/1991 15 July 1994 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Thompson v. Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (V) 806/1998 18 October 2000 Violation
Chongwe v. Zambia (V) 821/1998 25 October 2000 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation
Lantsova v. Russian Federation (V) 763/1997 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
Carpo et al. v. Philippines (V) 1077/2002 28 March 2003 Violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Telitsin v. Russian Federation (V) 888/1999 29 March 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Hussain and Hussain v. Guyana (V) 862/1999 25 October 2005 Violation
Persaud v. Guyana (V) 812/1998 21 March 2006 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Umetaliev and Tashtanbekova v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1275/2004 30 October 2008 Violation
Marcellana and Gumanoy v. The Philippines (V) 1560/2007 30 October 2008 Violation
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Tornel et al. v. Spain (V) 1473/2006 20 March 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Eshonov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1225/2003 22 July 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Hernandez v. Philippines 1559/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
González v. Argentina (V) 1458/2006 17 March 2011 Violation
Zhumbaeva and Moidunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1756/2008 19 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation
Traoré v. Côte d’Ivoire (V) 1759/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Chihoub v. Algeria (V) 1811/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Djebrouni v. Algeria (V) 1781/2008 31 October 2011 Violation

Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V)

1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Olmedo v. Paraguay (V) 1828/2008 22 March 2012 Violation
Kirani v. Algeria (V) 1905/2009 26 March 2012 Violation

Guezout et al. v. Algeria (V)

1753/2008 19 July 2012 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Thuraisamy v. Canada (V) 1912/2009 31 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Sedhai v. Nepal (V) 1865/2009 19 July 2013 Violation
Shakeel v. Canada (V) 1881/2009 24 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Johnson v. Ghana (V) 2177/2012 27 March 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Pronina v. France (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Fedsi v. Algeria (V) 1964/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Bouzaout v. Algeria (V) 1974/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Bouzenia v. Algeria (V) 1931/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
B.L. v. Australia (V) 2053/2011 16 October 2014 No violation
Shikhmuradov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2069/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Monika v. Cameroon (V) 1965/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Yuzepchuk v. Belarus (V) 1906/2009 24 October 2014 Violation
Tonenkaya v. Ukraine (A) 2123/2011 28 October 2014 6 Inadmissible
Sassene v. Algeria (V) 2026/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Louddi v. Algeria (V) 2117/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Dehimi & Ayache v. Algeria (V) 2086/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Kroumi v. Algeria (V) 2083/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
A.H.G. v. Canada (V) 2091/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
Ernazarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2054/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
Guneththige v. Sri Lanka (V) 2087/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Y. v. Canada, Sri Lanka (V) 2280/2013 22 July 2015 No violation
Akmatov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2052/2011 29 October 2015 Violation
F.M. v. Canada (V) 2284/2013 5 November 2015 No violation
X v. Canada (V) 2366/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Y v. Canada (V) 2327/2014 10 March 2016 No violation
Y. v. Canada (V) 2314/2013 22 March 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 6(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v.Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V) 985/2001 18 October 2005 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Strakhov and Fayzullaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1017/2001 and 1066/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Tulyaganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1041/2001 20 July 2007 Violation
Khudayberganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1140/2002 24 July 2007 Violation
Uteeva v. Uzbekistan (V) 1150/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 6(4)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation

ARTICLE 6(5)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
C. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 592/1994 20 October 1998 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
O.K. v. Latvia (A) 1935/2010 19 March 2014 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 7

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)
23 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)
28 October 1981 Violation
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)
29 March 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)
1 April 1982 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)
26 July 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Larrosa v. Uruguay (V) 88/1981 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Quinteros v. Uruguay (V) 107/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
M. F. v. The Netherlands (A) 173/1984 2 November 1984 Inadmissible
Wight v. Madagascar (V) 115/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Arzuada v. Uruguay (V) 147/1983 1 November 1985 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Miango v. Zaire (V) 194/1985 27 October 1987 Violation
Herrera v. Colombia (V) 161/1983 2 November 1987 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Acosta v. Uruguay (V) 162/1983 25 October 1988 Violation
J.H. v. Finland (A) 300/1988 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
R.M. v. Finland (A) 301/1988 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Torres v. Finland (V) 291/1988 2 April 1990 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
García v. Ecuador (V) 319/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Prince v. Jamaica (V) 269/1987 30 March 1992 No violation
Barrett and Sutcliffe v. Jamaica (V) 270 & 271/1988 30 March 1992 Violation
Ellis v. Jamaica (V) 276/1988 28 July 1992 No violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Griffiths v. Jamaica (V) 274/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Martin v. Jamaica (V) 317/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 334/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Soogrim v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 362/1989 8 April 1993 Violation
Kindler v. Canada (V) 470/1991 30 July 1993 No violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 321/1988 19 October 1993 Violation
Kanana v. Zaire (V) 366/1989 2 November 1993 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
El-Megreisi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 440/1990 23 March 1994 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 407/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mojica v. Dominican Republic (V) 449/1991 15 July 1994 Violation
Rodríguez v. Uruguay (V) 322/1988 19 July 1994 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Simms v. Jamaica (A) 541/1993 3 April 1995 Inadmissible
Rogers v. Jamaica (A) 494/1992 4 April 1995 Inadmissible
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
Chaplin v. Jamaica (V) 596/1994 2 November 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Tshishimbi v. Zaire (V) 542/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 512/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 600/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Spence v. Jamaica (V) 599/1994 18 July 1996 Violation
Sterling v. Jamaica (V) 598/1994 22 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Canepa v. Canada (V) 558/1993 3 April 1997 No violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 587/1994 3 April 1997 Violation
Ortega v. Ecuador (V) 481/1991 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Edwards v. Jamaica (V) 529/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Singh v. Canada (A) 761/1997 29 July 1997 Inadmissible
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Bickaroo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 555/1993 29 October 1997 No violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 609/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Young v. Jamaica (V) 615/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggart v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Daley v.Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
C. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 592/1994 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Colin Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 653/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Henry v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 752/1997 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Osbourne v. Jamaica (V) 759/1997 15 March 2000 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Thompson v. Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (V) 806/1998 18 October 2000 Violation
Jensen v. Australia (A) 762/1997 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Rojas García v. Colombia (V) 687/1996 3 April 2001 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Higginson v. Jamaica (V) 792/1998 28 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Sahadath v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 684/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
C. v. Australia (V) 900/1999 28 October 2002 Violation
Van Grinsven. v. The Netherlands(A) 1142/2002 27 March 2003 Inadmissible
Banderenko v. Belarus (V) 886/1999 3 April 2003 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Belarus (V) 887/1999 3 April 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Sarma v. Sri Lanka (V) 950/2000 16 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Cabal and Pasini v. Australia (V) 1020/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Pryce v. Jamaica (V) 793/1998 15 March 2004 Violation
Telitsin v. Russian Federation (V) 888/1999 29 March 2004 Violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Byahuranga v. Denmark (V) 1222/2003 1 November 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines (V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V) 985/2001 18 October 2005 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V) 1042/2001 20 October 2005 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V) 1058/2002 26 October 2005 Violation
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Siragev v. Uzbekistan (V) 907/2000 1 November 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Zheikov v. Russian Federation(V) 889/1999 17 March 2006 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Persaud v. Guyana (V) 812/1998 21 March 2006 Violation
Kouidis v. Greece (V) 1070/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Sankara v. Burkina Faso (V) 1159/2003 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Boucherf v. Algeria (V) 1196/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Khan v. Canada (A) 1302/2004 25 July 2006 Inadmissible
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Alzery v. Sweden (V) 1416/2005 25 October 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Agabekova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1071/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Obodzinsky v. Canada (V) 1124/2002 19 March 2007 No violationn
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violationn
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violationn
P.K. v. Canada (A) 1234/2003 1234/2003 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violationn
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Strakhov and Fayzullaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1017/2001 and 1066/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Tulyaganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1041/2001 20 July 2007 Violation
Khudayberganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1140/2002 24 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Banda v. Sri Lanka (V) 1426/2005 26 October 2007 Violation
Uteeva v. Uzbekistan (V) 1150/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
A., B., C., D. and E. v. Australia (A) 1429/2005 1 April 2008 Inadmissible
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Chadzjian and Barsgian v. The Netherlands (A) 1494/2006 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 July 2008 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Kalamiotis v. Greece (V) 1486/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Kaur v. Canada (A) 1455/2006 30 October 2008 Inadmissible
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Isaev and Karimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1163/2003 20 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Tarlue v. Canada (A) 1551/2007 27 March 2009 Inadmissible
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Sattorov v. Tajikistan (V) 1200/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Amirov and Amirova v. Russian Federation (V) 1447/2006 2 April 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Kibaya v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1483/2006 30 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Kwok v. Australia (V) 1442/2005 23 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Hamida v. Canada (V) 1544/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Gapirjanov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1589/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kaba v. Canada (V) 1465/2006 25 March 2010 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
Eshonov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1225/2003 22 July 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Avadanov v. Azerbaijan (V) 1633/2007 25 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
McCallum v. South Africa (V) 1818/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
Pillai et al. v. Canada 1763/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Zyuskin v. Russian Federation (V) 1605/2007 19 July 2011 Violation
Zhumbaeva and Moidunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1756/2008 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation
X. H. L. v. Netherlands 1564/2007 22 July 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation
Peiris v. Sri Lanka (V) 1862/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Israil v. Kazakhstan (V) 2024/2011 31 October 2011 Violation
Djebrouni v. Algeria (V) 1781/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Traoré v. Côte d’Ivoire (V) 1759/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Chihoub v. Algeria (V) 1811/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
X. v. Sweden (V) 1833/2008 1 November 2011 Violation
Nenova et al v. Libya (V) 1880/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Musaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1914-1916/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Benitez v. Paraguay (V) 1829/2008 22 March 2012 Violation
Kamoyo v. Zambia (V) 1859/2009 23 March 2012 Violation
Kirani v. Algeria (V) 1905/2009 26 March 2012 Violation
Katsaris v. Greece (V) 1558/2007 18 July 2012 Violation
Guezout et al. v. Algeria (V) 1753/2008 19 July 2012 Violation
Maharjan v. Nepal (V) 1863/2009 19 July 2012 Violation
A. P. v. Ukraine (A) 1834/2008 23 July 2012 Inadmissible
Chiti v. Zambia (V) 1303/2004 26 July 2012 Violation
Weiss v. Austria (V) 1821/2008 24 October 2012 No violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Thuraisamy v. Canada (V) 1912/2009 31 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Mandic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2064/2011 5 November 2012 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Lin v. Australia (V) 1957/2010 21 March 2013 No violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Saadoun v. Algeria (V) 1806/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
H.P.N. v. Spain (A) 1943/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Bakurov v. Russian Federation (V) 1861/2009 25 March 2013 No violation
Q.H.L. v. Australia (A) 1938/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
S.N.A. v. Cameroon (A) 1962/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Puertas v. Spain (V) 1945/2010 27 March 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Sedhai v. Nepal (V) 1865/2009 19 July 2013 Violation
Shakeel v. Canada (V) 1881/2009 24 July 2013 Violation
M.I. v. Sweden (V) 2149/2012 25 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
M.M.M. et al. v. Australia (V) 2136/2012 25 July 2013 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Alekperov v. Russian Federation (V) 1764/2008 21 October 2013 No violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Valetov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2104/2011 17 March 2014 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
Terafi v. Algeria (V) 1899/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Mehalli et al. v. Algeria (V) 1900/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
X v. the Republic of Korea (V) 1908/2009 25 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
X. v. Denmark (V) 2007/2010 26 March 2014 Violation
Johnson v. Ghana (V) 2177/2012 27 March 2014 Violation
Horvath v. Australia (V) 1885/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
Baruani v. Democratic Republic of Congo (V) 1890/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
Duric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1956/2010 16 July 2014 Violation
Selimovic et al v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2003/2010 17 July 2014 Violation
Zinsou v. Benin (V) 2055/2011 18 July 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Z. v. Australia (V) 2049/2011 18 July 2014 Violation
Huseynov v. Azerbaijan (A) 2042/2011 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Jum'a et al v. Libya (V) 1958/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Fedsi v. Algeria (V) 1964/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Bouzenia v. Algeria (V) 1931/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
B.L. v. Australia (V) 2053/2011 16 October 2014 No violation
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Shikhmuradov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2069/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Khakdar v. Russian Federation (V) 2126/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Monika v. Cameroon (V) 1965/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Blessington and Elliot v. Australia (V) 1968/2010 22 October 2014 Violation
X. v. Denmark (V) 2186/2012 22 October 2014 Violation
Husseini v. Denmark (V) 2243/2013 24 October 2014 Violation
Yuzepchuk v. Belarus (V) 1906/2009 24 October 2014 Violation
Chaulagain v. Nepal (V) 2018/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Kozljak v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1970/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Hero v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1966/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
N.U. v. Norway (A) 2341/2014 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Basnet v. Nepal (V) 2051/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Sassene v. Algeria (V) 2026/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Bhandari v. Nepal (V) 2031/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Louddi v. Algeria (V) 2117/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Kroumi v. Algeria (V) 2083/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Ammari v. Algeria (V) 2098/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Dehimi & Ayache v. Algeria (V) 2086/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
A.H.G. v. Canada (V) 2091/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
Ernazarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2054/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
Abdullayev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2218/2012 25 March 2015 Violation
N.S. v. Russian Federation (V) 2192/2012 27 March 2015 Violation
Hamulic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2022/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Icic & Mevlida v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2028/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Guneththige v. Sri Lanka (V) 2087/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
PT v. Denmark (V) 2272/2013 1 April 2015 No violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Khadzhiev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2079/2011 1 April 2015 Violation
X. v. Denmark (A) 2515/2014 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
X. v. Denmark (A) 2523/2015 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Bakur v. Belarus (V) 1902/2009 15 July 2015 Violation
Z. v. Denmark/Iran (V) 2329/2014 15 July 2015 No violation
AH v. Denmark (V) 2370/2014 16 July 2015 Violation
K. v. Denmark (V) 2393/2014 16 July 2015 No violation
Jasin v. Denmark (V) 2360/2014 22 July 2015 Violation
Dovadzija et al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation
Y. v. Canada, Sri Lanka (V) 2280/2013 22 July 2015 No violation
X v. Denmark (V) 2389/2014 22 July 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
H.E.A.K. v. Denmark (V) 2343/2014 23 July 2015 Violation
Gruca v. Poland (A) 2183/2012 23 July 2015 Inadmissible
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
N. v. Denmark (A) 2426/2014 23 July 2015 Inadmissible
Hudaybergenov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2222/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Akmatov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2052/2011 29 October 2015 Violation
Japparow v. Turkmenistan (V) 2223/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Hudaybergenov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2221/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
E.P. and F.P. v. Denmark (A) 2344/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
R.G. et al. v. Denmark (A) 2351/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
G.C.A.A. v. Uruguay (A) 2358/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Rasappu v. Denmark (V) 2258/2013 4 November 2015 Violation
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
J.P.D. v. France (A) 2621/2015 5 November 2015 Inadmissible
X v. Norway (V) 2474/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
Kadiric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2048/2011 5 November 2015 Violation
X v. Canada (V) 2366/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
A.S v. Nepal (V) 2077/2011 6 November 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
K.B. v. Russian Federation (V) 2193/2012 10 March 2016 Violation
Y v. Canada (V) 2327/2014 10 March 2016 No violation
Z v. Denmark (V) 2422/2014 11 March 2016 No violation
T.V. & A.G. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2044/2011 11 March 2016 Violation
Chani v. Algeria (V) 2297/2013 11 March 2016 Violation
Y. v. Canada (V) 2314/2013 22 March 2016 No violation
A.A.I. and A.H.A. V. Denmark(A) 2402/2014 29 March 2016 Inadmissible
Ali & Mohamad v. Denmark(V) 2409/2014 29 March 2016 No violation
V.K. v. Russian Federation (A) 2411/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
V.L. v. Belarus (A) 2084/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
A. v. Denmark (A) 2357/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Mellet v. Ireland (V) 2324/2013 31 March 2016 Violation
E.U.R. v. Denmark (V) 2469/2014 1 July 2016 Violation
Ahmed v. Denmark (V) 2379/2014 7 July 2016 Violation
A and B v. Denmark (V) 2291/2013 13 July 2016 No violation
S.M. v. Bulgaria (A) 2100/2011 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
Ortikov v. Uzbekistan (V) 2317/2013 26 October 2016 Violation
Kerrouche v. Algeria (V) 2128/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
A.P.J. v. Denmark (V) 2253/2013 16 March 2017 No violation
Dmitry Tyan v. Kazakhstan (V) 2125/2011 16 March 2017 Violation
El Boathi v. Algeria (V) 2259/2013 17 March 2017 Violation
Contreras v. Canada (V) 2613/2015 27 March 2017 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 8

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Järvinen v. Finland (V) 295/1988 25 July 1990 No violation
Maille v. France (V) 689/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Venier and Nicolas v. France (V) 690 & 691/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Van Grinsven. v. The Netherlands(A) 1142/2002 27 March 2003 Inadmissible
Radosevic v. Germany (A) 1292/2004 22 July 2005 Inadmissible
Faure v.Australia (V) 1036/2001 31 October 2005 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 9

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)
29 March 1982 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Quinteros v. Uruguay (V) 107/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
J.R.C. v. Costa Rica (A) 296/1988 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Arévalo v. Colombia (V) 181/1984 3 November 1989 Violation
van Alphen v. The Netherlands (V) 305/1988 23 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
García v. Ecuador (V) 319/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
El-Megreisi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 440/1990 23 March 1994 Violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Jalloh v. The Netherlands (V) 794/1998 26 March 2002 No violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
Sarma v. Sri Lanka (V) 950/2000 16 July 2003 Violation
Rameka v. New Zealand(V) 1090/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Fijalkowska v. Poland (V) 1061/2002 26 July 2004 Violation
Jorge Luis Quispe Roque v. Peru (V) 1125/2002 21 October 2005 Violation
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Boucherf v. Algeria (V) 1196/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Shafiq v. Australia (V) 1324/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
A., B., C., D. and E. v. Australia (A) 1429/2005 1 April 2008 Inadmissible
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Mamour v. Central African Republic (V) 1587/2007 20 July 2009 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Rastorguev v. Poland (V) 1517/2006 28 March 2011 Violation
Traoré v. Côte d’Ivoire (V) 1759/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Chihoub v. Algeria (V) 1811/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Djebrouni v. Algeria (V) 1781/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Jumaa v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1755/2008 19 March 2012 Violation
Nenova et al v. Libya (V) 1880/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Kirani v. Algeria (V) 1905/2009 26 March 2012 Violation
Guezout et al. v. Algeria (V) 1753/2008 19 July 2012 Violation
Maharjan v. Nepal (V) 1863/2009 19 July 2012 Violation
Cedeno v. Venezuela (V) 1940/2010 29 October 2012 Violation
Lin v. Australia (V) 1957/2010 21 March 2013 No violation
S.N.A. v. Cameroon (A) 1962/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Q.H.L. v. Australia (A) 1938/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Sedhai v. Nepal (V) 1865/2009 19 July 2013 Violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Terafi v. Algeria (V) 1899/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Mehalli et al. v. Algeria (V) 1900/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Rizvanovic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1997/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Baruani v. Democratic Republic of Congo (V) 1890/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
Duric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1956/2010 16 July 2014 Violation
Selimovic et al v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2003/2010 17 July 2014 Violation
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Jum'a et al v. Libya (V) 1958/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Bouzenia v. Algeria (V) 1931/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Shikhmuradov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2069/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Toregozhina v. Kazakhstan (V) 2137/2012 21 October 2014 Violation
Lozenko v. Belarus (V) 1929/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Pinchuk v. Belarus (V) 2165/2012 24 October 2014 Violation
Kozljak v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1970/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Chaulagain v. Nepal (V) 2018/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Hero v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1966/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Basnet v. Nepal (V) 2051/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Bhandari v. Nepal (V) 2031/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Sassene v. Algeria (V) 2026/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Louddi v. Algeria (V) 2117/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Ammari v. Algeria (V) 2098/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Dehimi & Ayache v. Algeria (V) 2086/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
N.S. v. Russian Federation (V) 2192/2012 27 March 2015 Violation
Hamulic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2022/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Icic & Mevlida v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2028/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
E.Z. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2021/2010 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Bakur v. Belarus (V) 1902/2009 15 July 2015 Violation
Dovadzija et al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation
Y. v. Canada, Sri Lanka (V) 2280/2013 22 July 2015 No violation
H.E.A.K. v. Denmark (V) 2343/2014 23 July 2015 Violation
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
G.C.A.A. v. Uruguay (A) 2358/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Kadiric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2048/2011 5 November 2015 Violation
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
Chani v. Algeria (V) 2297/2013 11 March 2016 Violation
V.L. v. Belarus (A) 2084/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
S.M. v. Bulgaria (A) 2100/2011 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
Ortikov v. Uzbekistan (V) 2317/2013 26 October 2016 Violation
Dmitry Tyan v. Kazakhstan (V) 2125/2011 16 March 2017 Violation
El Boathi v. Algeria (V) 2259/2013 17 March 2017 Violation
Spisso v. Venezuela (V) 2481/2014 17 March 2017 Violation
Contreras v. Canada (V) 2613/2015 27 March 2017 Violation

ARTICLE 9(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)
23 July 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)
26 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Jaona v. Madagascar (V) 132/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Kanana v. Zaire (V) 366/1989 2 November 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mojica v. Dominican Republic (V) 449/1991 15 July 1994 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Colamarco v. Panama (A) 437/1990 21 October 1994 Inadmissible
Thompson v. Panama (A) 438/1990 21 October 1994 Inadmissible
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Baustista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Tshishimbi v. Zaire (V) 542/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423, & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
A v. New Zealand (V) 754/1997 15 July 1999 No violation
Spakmo v. Norway (V) 631/1995 5 November 1999 Violation
Dias v. Angola (V) 711/1996 20 March 2000 Violation
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Chongwe v. Zambia (V) 821/1998 25 October 2000 Violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation
Jayawardena v. Sri Lanka (V) 916/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
C. v. Australia (V) 900/1999 28 October 2002 Violation
Chambala v. Zambia (V) 856/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Baban et al. v. Australia (V) 1014/2001 6 August 2003 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Everett v. Spain (A) 961/2000 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Fernando v. Sri Lanka (V) 1189/2003 31 March 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines (V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Fijalkowska v. Poland (V) 1061/2002 26 July 2005 Violation
Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V) 1058/2002 26 October 2005 Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Sankara v. Burkina Faso (V) 1159/2003 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
D. and E. v. Australia (V) 1050/2002 11 July 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
Shafiq v. Australia (V) 1324/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Zundel v. Canada (A) 1341/2005 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Shams et al. v. Australia (V) 1255,1256,
1259,1260,
1266,1268,
1270,1288/2004
20 July 2007 Violation
Manuel v. New Zealand (V) 1385/2005 18 October 2007 No Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Marcellana and Gumanoy v. The Philippines (V) 1560/2007 30 October 2008 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Castro v. Spain (V) 1388/2005 19 March 2009 No violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Kwok v. Australia (V) 1442/2005 23 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Latifulin v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1312/2004 10 March 2010 Violation
Tillman v. Australia (V) 1635/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Fardon v. Australia (V) 1629/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Peiris v. Sri Lanka (V) 1862/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Israil v. Kazakhstan (V) 2024/2011 31 October 2011 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Thuraisamy v. Canada (V) 1912/2009 31 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Saadoun v. Algeria (V) 1806/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Shakeel v. Canada (V) 1881/2009 24 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
M.M.M. et al. v. Australia (V) 2136/2012 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Sevostyanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1856/2008 1 November 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Horvath v. Australia (V) 1885/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Vojnovic v. Croatia (A) 2068/2011 10 October 2014 Inadmissible
Kim et al v. Republic of Korea (V) 2179/2012 15 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Griffiths v. Australia (V) 1973/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Monika v. Cameroon (V) 1965/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Symonik v. Belarus (V) 1952/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Kroumi v. Algeria (V) 2083/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation
Guneththige v. Sri Lanka (V) 2087/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Khadzhiev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2079/2011 1 April 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
V.S. v. New Zealand (A) 2072/2011 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
X v. Canada (V) 2366/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
A.S v. Nepal (V) 2077/2011 6 November 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Y v. Canada (V) 2327/2014 10 March 2016 No violation
T.V. & A.G. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2044/2011 11 March 2016 Violation
Y. v. Canada (V) 2314/2013 22 March 2016 No violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 9(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Borda et al. v. Colombia (V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)
27 July 1982 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Jaona v. Madagascar (V) 132/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1997 30 March 1992 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Thompson v. Panama (A) 438/1990 21 October 1994 Inadmissible
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 597/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1988 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1988 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
Zheludkov v. Ukraine (V) 726/1996 29 October 2002 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Latifulin v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1312/2004 10 March 2010 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V) 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Saadoun v. Algeria (V) 1806/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
M.M.M. et al. v. Australia (V) 2136/2012 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Monika v. Cameroon (V) 1965/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Guneththige v. Sri Lanka (V) 2087/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Bakur v. Belarus (V) 1902/2009 15 July 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
A.S v. Nepal (V) 2077/2011 6 November 2015 Violation
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 9(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977 (R.1/5) 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)
28 October 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)
29 March 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)
1 April 1982 Violation
Borda et al. v. Colombia(V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)
27 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 &242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
W. B. E. v. The Netherlands (A) 432/1990 23 October 1992 Inadmissible
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Koné v. Senegal (V) 386/1989 21 October 1994 Violation
Shalto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 447/1991 4 April 1995 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Kulomin v. Hungary (V) 521/1992 22 March 1996 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 597/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Elahie v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 533/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Smart v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 672/1995 29 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1988 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 616/1995 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Zheludkov v. Ukraine (V) 726/1996 29 October 2002 Violation
Evans v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 908/2000 21 March 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Lobban v. Jamaica (V) 797/1998 16 March 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Nazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 911/2000 6 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation

Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V)

1042/2001

20 October 2005

Violation

Platonov v. Russian Federation (V)

1218/2003

1 November 2005

Violation

Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan (V) 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Smantser v. Belarus (V) 1178/2003 23 October 2008 Violation
Reshetnikov v. Russian Federation (V) 1278/2004 23 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Kaldarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1338/2005 18 March 2010 Violation
Gapirjanov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1589/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Peirano Basso v. Uruguay (V) 1887/2009 19 October 2010 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V) 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Torobekov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1547/2007 27 October 2011 Violation
Musaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1914-1916/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Saadoun v. Algeria (V) 1806/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Kovsh v. Belarus (V) 1787/2008 27 March 2013 Violation
Pichugina v. Belarus (V) 1592/2007 17 July 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Griffiths v. Australia (V) 1973/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Yuzepchuk v. Belarus (V) 1906/2009 24 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 9(4)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Valcada v. Uruguay (V) 9/1977 26 October 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)
23 July 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)
29 March 1982 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)
26 July 1982 Violation
Borda et al. v. Colombia (V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)
27 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Hammel v. Madagascar (V) 155/1983 3 April 1987 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Torres v. Finland (V) 291/1988 2 April 1990 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 597/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
A v. New Zealand (V) 754/1997 15 July 1999 No violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
C. v. Australia (V) 900/1999 28 October 2002 Violation
Baban et al. v. Australia (V) 1014/2001 6 August 2003 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Rameka v. New Zealand(V) 1090/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Fijalkowska v. Poland (V) 1061/2002 26 July 2005 Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Shafiq v. Australia (V) 1324/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Shams et al. v. Australia (V) 1255,1256,
1259,1260,
1266,1268,
1270,1288/2004
20 July 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V) 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Saadoun v. Algeria (V) 1806/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
M.M.M. et al. v. Australia (V) 2136/2012 25 July 2013 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Sevostyanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1856/2008 1 November 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
X v. the Republic of Korea (V) 1908/2009 25 March 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Griffiths v. Australia (V) 1973/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Guneththige v. Sri Lanka (V) 2087/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
T.V. & A.G. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2044/2011 11 March 2016 Violation
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 9(5)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423 & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
Uebergang v. Australia (A) 963/2001 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Chambala v. Zambia (V) 856/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Fijalkowska v. Poland (V) 1061/2002 26 July 2005 Violation
Horvath v. Australia (V) 1885/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
V.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2043/2011 15 July 2015 No violation
Yusupova v. Russian Federation (A) 2036/2010 21 July 2015 Inadmissible
Timoshenko v. Belarus (V) 1950/2010 22 July 2015 Violation
Gruca v. Poland (A) 2183/2012 23 July 2015 Inadmissible
Yusupova v. Russian Federation (A) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Inadmissible
A.S v. Nepal (V) 2077/2011 6 November 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 10

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Párkányi v. Hungary (V) 410/1990 27 July 1992 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Rogers v. Jamaica (A) 494/1992 4 April 1995 Inadmissible
Kulomin v. Hungary (V) 521/1992 22 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Chanderbali v. Austria (A) 944/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 28 October 2005 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2006 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
S.N.A. v. Cameroon (A) 1962/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
H.P.N. v. Spain (A) 1943/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Rizvanovic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1997/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Horvath v. Australia (V) 1885/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
Duric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1956/2010 16 July 2014 Violation
Selimovic et al v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2003/2010 17 July 2014 Violation
Huseynov v. Azerbaijan (A) 2042/2011 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Chaulagain v. Nepal (V) 2018/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Basnet v. Nepal (V) 2051/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Bhandari v. Nepal (V) 2031/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Icic & Mevlida v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2028/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
E.Z. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2021/2010 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Japparow v. Turkmenistan (V) 2223/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Chani v. Algeria (V) 2297/2013 11 March 2016 Violation
V.K. v. Russian Federation (A) 2411/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
Dmitry Tyan v. Kazakhstan (V) 2125/2011 16 March 2017 Violation
El Boathi v. Algeria (V) 2259/2013 17 March 2017 Violation
Spisso v. Venezuela (V) 2481/2014 17 March 2017 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 10(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)
23 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)
28 October 1981 Violation
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)
29 October 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)
29 March 1982 Violation
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)
29 March 1982 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)
1 April 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)
1 April 1982 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)
26 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Larrosa v. Uruguay (V) 88/1981 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Estradet v. Uruguay (V) 105/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Quinteros v. Uruguay (V) 107/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Machado v. Uruguay (V) 83/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Romero v. Uruguay (V) 85/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Manera v. Uruguay (V) 123/1982 6 April 1984 Violation
de Voituret v. Uruguay (V) 109/1981 10 April 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Wight v. Madagascar (V) 115/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Arzuada v. Uruguay (V) 147/1983 1 November 1985 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Herrera v. Colombia (V) 161/1983 2 November 1987 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Acosta v. Uruguay (V) 162/1983 25 October 1988 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1998 26 March 1992 Violation
Barrett and Sutcliffe v. Jamaica (V) 270 & 271/1988 30 March 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 334/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Soogrim v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 362/1989 8 April 1993 Violation
Orihuela v. Peru (V) 309/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 321/1988 19 October 1993 Violation
Kanana v. Zaire (V) 366/1989 2 November 1993 Violation
El-Megreisi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 440/1990 23 March 1994 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 407/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mika Miha v Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Chaplin v. Jamaica (V) 596/1994 2 November 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 512/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 600/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Spence v. Jamaica (V) 599/1994 18 July 1996 Violation
Sterling v. Jamaica (V) 598/1994 22 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 587/1994 3 April 1997 Violation
Ortega v. Ecuador (V) 481/1991 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Edwards v. Jamaica (V) 529/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Elahie v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 533/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Bickaroo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 555/1993 29 October 1997 No violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 609/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Matthews v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 569/1993 31 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Colin Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 653/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Henry v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 752/1997 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 616/1995 23 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Thompson v. Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (V) 806/1998 18 October 2000 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Simpson v. Jamaica (V) 695/1996 31 October 2001 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Lantsova v. Russian Federation (V) 763/1997 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Sahadath v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 684/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Zheludkov v. Ukraine (V) 726/1996 29 October 2002 Violation
Evans v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 908/2000 21 March 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Cabal and Pasini v. Australia (V) 1020/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Rameka v. New Zealand(V) 1090/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Telitsin v. Russian Federation (V) 888/1999 29 March 2004 Violation
Lobban v. Jamaica (V) 797/1998 16 March 2004 Violation
Arutyunyan v. Uzbekistan (V) 917/2000 29 March 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation

Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V)

1058/2002 26 October 2005 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
McCallum v. South Africa (V) 1818/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Bozbey v. Turkmenistan (V) 1530/2006 27 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V) 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V) 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Traoré v. Côte d’Ivoire (V) 1759/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Chihoub v. Algeria (V) 1811/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Djebrouni v. Algeria (V) 1781/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Kirani v. Algeria (V) 1905/2009 26 March 2012 Violation
Guezout et al. v. Algeria (V) 1753/2008 19 July 2012 Violation
Maharjan v. Nepal (V) 1863/2009 19 July 2012 Violation
Pavlyuchenkov v. Russian Federation (V) 1628/2007 20 July 2012 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Sedhai v. Nepal (V) 1865/2009 19 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
M.M.M. et al. v. Australia (V) 2136/2012 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Larbi v. Algeria (V) 1831/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
Mehalli et al. v. Algeria (V) 1900/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Bouzenia v. Algeria (V) 1931/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Sassene v. Algeria (V) 2026/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
E.V. v. Belarus (A) 1989/2010 30 October 2014 Inadmissible
Louddi v. Algeria (V) 2117/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Ammari v. Algeria (V) 2098/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Kroumi v. Algeria (V) 2083/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Dehimi & Ayache v. Algeria (V) 2086/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Abdullayev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2218/2012 25 March 2015 Violation
Guneththige v. Sri Lanka (V) 2087/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Khadzhiev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2079/2011 1 April 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Gruca v. Poland (A) 2183/2012 23 July 2015 Inadmissible
Hudaybergenov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2222/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Hudaybergenov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2221/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
A.S v. Nepal (V) 2077/2011 6 November 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Ortikov v. Uzbekistan (V) 2317/2013 26 October 2016 Violation
Kerrouche v. Algeria (V) 2128/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 10(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)
29 October 1981 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1998 26 March 1992 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
D. Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 800/1998 8 April 1999 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Nenova et al v. Libya (V) 1880/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 10(2)(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Cabal and Pasini v. Australia (V) 1020/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Minogue v. Australia (A) 954/2000 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 10(2)(b)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 10(3)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
D. Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 800/1998 8 April 1999 Violation
Jensen v. Australia (A) 762/1997 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
Blessington and Elliot v. Australia (V) 1968/2010 22 October 2014 Violation
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 11

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Seto Martinez v. Spain (A) 1624/2007 19 March 2010 Inadmissible
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 11(2)(b)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Nguyen v. the Netherlands 3/2004 14 August 2006 No violation

ARTICLE 12

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)
30 July 1981 Violation
Nunez v. Uruguay (V) 108/1981 22 July 1983 Violation
Gillot v. France (V) 932/2000 15 July 2002 No violation

Randolph v. Togo (V)

910/2000

27 October 2003

No violation

Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Singh v. France (V) 1928/2010 19 July 2013 Violation
Martinez et al. v. Algeria (A) 1922/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Jum'a et al v. Libya (V) 1958/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Toregozhina v. Kazakhstan (V) 2137/2012 21 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
E.Z. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2021/2010 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Chani v. Algeria (V) 2297/2013 11 March 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 12(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Celepli v. Sweden (V) 456/1991 18 July 1994 No violation
Ackla v. Togo (V) 505/1992 25 March 1996 Violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation
El Ghar v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1107/2002 2 November 2004 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Ory v. France (V) 1960/2010 28 March 2014 Violation

ARTICLE 12(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Martins v. Uruguay (V) 57/1979
(R.13/57)
23 March 1982 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Lichtensztejn v. Uruguay (V) 77/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Montero v. Uruguay (V) 106/1981 31 March 1983 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Peltonen v. Finland (V) 492/1992 21 July 1994 No violation
El Ghar v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1107/2002 2 November 2004 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Batyrov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1585/2007 30 July 2009 Violation
Orazova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1883/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation

ARTICLE 12(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Celepli v. Sweden (V) 456/1991 18 July 1994 No violation
Peltonen v. Finland (V) 492/1992 21 July 1994 No violation
Ackla v. Togo (V) 505/1992 25 March 1996 Violation
Karker v. France (V) 833/1998 26 October 2000 No violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Batyrov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1585/2007 30 July 2009 Violation

ARTICLE 12(4)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Stewart v. Canada (V) 538/1993 1 November 1996 No violation
Canepa v. Canada (V) 558/1993 3 April 1997 No violation
Toala et al. v. New Zealand (V) 675/1995 2 November 2000 No violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation
Vojnovic v. Croatia (A) 2068/2011 10 October 2014 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 13

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Maroufidou v. Sweden (V) 58/1979
(R.13/58)
9 April 1981 No violation
Hammel v. Madagascar (V) 155/1983 3 April 1987 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Giry v. Dominican Republic (V) 193/1985 20 July 1990 Violation
García v. Ecuador (V) 319/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Sohn v. Republic of Korea (V) 518/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Karker v. France (V) 833/1998 26 October 2000 No violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Elahi v. Switzerland (V) 222/2002 3 May 2005 No Violation
Alzery v. Sweden (V) 1416/2005 25 October 2006 Violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Griffiths v. Australia (V) 1973/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Husseini v. Denmark (V) 2243/2013 24 October 2014 Violation
Leghaei v. Australia (V) 1937/2010 26 March 2015 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
F.M. v. Canada (V) 2284/2013 5 November 2015 No violation
A. v. Denmark (A) 2357/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
A and B v. Denmark (V) 2291/2013 13 July 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 14
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Borda et al. v. Colombia (V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)
27 July 1982 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
J.H. v. Finland (A) 300/1998 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
R.M. v. Finland (A) 301/1998 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
B.d.B. et al. v. The Netherlands (A) 273/1989 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
J.R.C. v. Costa Rica (A) 296/1988 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Little v. Jamaica (V) 283/1988 1 November 1991 Violation
Barrett and Sutcliffe v. Jamaica (V) 270 & 271/1988 30 March 1992 Violation
Ellis v. Jamaica (V) 276/1988 28 July 1992 No violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Perera v. Australia (A) 536/1993 28 March 1995 Inadmissible
Simms v. Jamaica (A) 541/1993 3 April 1995 Inadmissible
de Groot v. The Netherlands (A) 578/1994 14 July 1995 Inadmissible
Bullock v. Trinidad and Tobago (A) 553/1993 19 July 1995 Inadmissible
Marriot v. Jamaica (V) 519/1992 27 October 1995 Violation
Kulomin v. Hungary (V) 521/1992 22 March 1996 Violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Singh v. Canada (A) 761/1997 29 July 1997 Inadmissible
Perel v. Latvia (V) 650/1995 30 March 1998 No violation
Ajaz and Jamil v. Republic of Korea (V) 644/1995 13 July 1999 No violation
Hankle v. Jamaica (V) 710/1996 28 July 1999 No violation
G. v. Canada (A) 934/2000 17 July 2000 Inadmissible
Piandiong et al. v. Philippines (V) 869/1999 19 October 2000 No violation
Rogl v. Germany (A) 808/1998 25 October 2000 Inadmissible
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo(V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Veriter v. France (A) 1088/2002 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Bochaton v. France (A) (A) 1084/2002 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Nazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 911/2000 6 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation
Kolyada v. Russian Federation (A) 1357/2005 29 March 2005 Inadmissible
Van Den Hemel v. The Netherlands(A) 1185/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
Teun Sanders v. The Netherlands (A) 1193/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
Jorge Luis Quispe Roque v. Peru (V) 1125/2002 21 October 2005 Violation
Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V) 1058/2002 26 October 2005 Violation
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Becerra v. Colombia (V) 1298/2004 11 July 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Zundel v. Canada(A) 1341/2005 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
Chadzjian and Barsgian v. The Netherlands (A) 1494/2006 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Guerra de la Espriella v. Colombia (V) 1623/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sechremelis et al. v. Greece 1507/2006 25 October 2010 No violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V) 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Jumaa v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1755/2008 19 March 2012 Violation
Nenova et al v. Libya (V) 1880/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
S.K. v. Belarus (A) 2169/2012 31 October 2012 Inadmissible
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Kholodova v. Russian Federation (V) 1548/2007/td> 1 November 2012 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Bakurov v. Russian Federation (V) 1861/2009 25 March 2013 No violation
D.T.T. V. Colombia (A) 1904/2009 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
B.W.M.Z. v. Netherlands (A) 1788/2008 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Shakeel v. Canada (V) 1881/2009 24 July 2013 Violation
Alekperov v. Russian Federation (V) 1764/2008 21 October 2013 No violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
X. v. Denmark (V) 2007/2010 26 March 2014 Violation
Huseynov v. Azerbaijan (A) 2042/2011 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Pronina v. France (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Volchek v. Belarus (V) 1991/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Kozlov v. Belarus (V) 1986/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Evrezov et al v. Belarus (V) 1999/2010 10 October 2014 Violation
X. v. Denmark (V) 2186/2012 22 October 2014 Violation
Lozenko v. Belarus (V) 1929/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Pinchuk v. Belarus (V) 2165/2012 24 October 2014 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
AH v. Denmark (V) 2370/2014 16 July 2015 Violation
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
Arkadyevich v. Russian Federation (V) 2141/2012 23 October 2015 Violation
G.C.A.A. v. Uruguay (A) 2358/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
T.V. & A.G. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2044/2011 11 March 2016 Violation
Chani v. Algeria (V) 2297/2013 11 March 2016 Violation
V.K. v. Russian Federation (A) 2411/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
V.L. v. Belarus (A) 2084/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
A. v. Denmark (A) 2357/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
A and B v. Denmark (V) 2291/2013 13 July 2016 No violation
S.M. v. Bulgaria (A) 2100/2011 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
Ortikov v. Uzbekistan (V) 2317/2013 26 October 2016 Violation
Dmitry Tyan v. Kazakhstan (V) 2125/2011 16 March 2017 Violation
Spisso v. Venezuela (V) 2481/2014 17 March 2017 Violation

ARTICLE 14(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v.Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)
29 March 1982 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)
1 April 1982 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay(V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
C.A. v. Italy (A) 127/1982 31 March 1983 Inadmissible
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Y.L. v. Canada (A) 112/1981 8 April 1986 Inadmissible
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Avellanal v. Peru (V) 202/1986 28 October 1988 Violation
Muñoz v. Peru (V) 203/1986 4 November 1988 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 223/1987 30 March 1989 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
van Meurs v. The Netherlands (V) 215/1986 13 July 1990 Violation
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Sawyers and McLean v. Jamaica (V) 226 & 256/1987 11 April 1991 No violation
Barzhig v. France (V) 327/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Z.P. v. Canada (A) 341/1988 11 April 1991 Inadmissible
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 272/1988 31 March 1992 Violation
Hibbert v. Jamaica (V) 293/1988 27 July 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Párkányi v. Hungary (V) 410/1990 27 July 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Karttunen v. Finland (V) 387/1989 23 October 1992 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Gordon v. Jamaica (V) 237/1987 5 November 1992 No violation
Griffiths v. Jamaica (V) 274/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 307/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 441/1990 19 July 1994 No violation
Poongavanam v. Mauritius (A) 567/1993 26 July 1994 Inadmissible
Fei v. Colombia (V) 514/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Pons v. Spain (V) 454/1991 30 October 1995 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Adu v. Canada (A) 654/1995 18 July 1997 Inadmissible
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Young v. Jamaica (V) 615/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Henry v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 752/1997 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Fraser and Fisher v. Jamaica (V) 722/1996 31 March 1999 No violation
Maleki v. Italy (V) 699/1996 15 July 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Mukunto v. Zambia (V) 768/1997 23 July 1999 Violation
Tamihere v. New Zealand (A) 891/1999 15 March 2000 Inadmissible
Ben Said v. Norway (V) 767/1997 29 March 2000 No violation
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Mahuika et al. v. New Zealand (V) 547/1993 27 October 2000 No violation
Jansen-Gielen v. The Netherlands (V) 846/1999 3 April 2001 Violation
Kavanagh v. Ireland (V) 819/1998 4 April 2001 Violation
Torregrosa Lafuente et al. v. Spain (A) 866/1999 16 July 2001 Inadmissible
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Äärelä and Näkkäläjärvi v. Finland (V) 779/1997 24 October 2001 Violation
Des Fours v. Czech Republic (V) 747/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Gutiérrez Vicanco v. Peru (V) 678/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Rodríguez Orejuela v. Colombia (V) 848/1999 23 July 2002 Violation
Ruiz Agudo v. Spain (V) 864/1999 31 October 2002 Violation
Evans v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 908/2000 21 March 2003 Violation
Weiss v. Austria (V) 1086/2002 3 April 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus (V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Kolanowski v. Poland (A) 837/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Aliev v. Ukraine (V) 781/1997 7 August 2003 Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain (A) 956/2000 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Semey v. Spain (V) 986/2001 30 July 2003 Violation
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation
Perera v. Sri Lanka (A) 1091/2002 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Martínez Muñoz v.Spain (V) 1006/2001 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Sanlés Sanlés v. Spain (A) 1024/2001 30 March 2004 Inadmissible
Wilson v. Australia (A) 1239/2004 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Van Marcke v. Belgium (V) 904/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Perterer v. Austria (V) 1015/2001 20 July 2004 Violation
Mulai v. Republic of Guyana (V) 811/1998 20 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation
Riedl-Riedenstein v. Germany (A) 1188/2003 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Olavi v. Finland (V) 1076/2002 15 March 2005 No violation
Czernin v. Czech Republic (V) 823/1998 29 March 2005 Violation
Ostroukhov v. Russian Federation (A) 967/2001 31 March 2005 Inadmissible
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines (V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Karatsis v. Cyprus (A) 1182/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
López v. Spain (A) 1105/2002 26 July 2005 Inadmissible
Dimitrov v. Bulgaria (A) 1030/2001 28 October 2005 Inadmissible
Khachatrian v. Armenia (A) 1056/2002 28 October 2005 Inadmissible
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Lassâad Aouf (V) 1010/2001 17 March 2006 No Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Puertas v. Spain (A) 1183/2003 27 March 2006 Inadmissible
Sankara v. Burkina Faso (V) 1159/2003 28 March 2006 Violation
Kouidis v. Greece (V) 1070/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Dranichnikov v. Australia (V) 1291/2004 20 October 2006 No violation
Verlinden v. The Netherlands (A) 1187/2003 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
González Cruz v. Spain (A) 1151/2003 1 November 2006 Inadmissible
E.B. v. New Zealand (V) 1368/2005 16 March 2007 Violation
Pimentel v. Philippines (V) 1320/2004 19 March 2007 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
P.K. v. Canada (A) 1234/2003 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Rodríguez and Sánchez v. Spain (A) 1213/2003 28 March 2007 Inadmissible
Lederbauer v. Austria (V) 1454/2006 13 July 2007 Violation
Dudko v. Australia (V) 1347/2005 23 July 2007 Violation
Asensi v. Spain (V) 1413/2005 1 April 2008 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Babkin v. Russian Federation (V) 1310/2004 3 April 2008 Violation
Jenny v. Austria (V) 1437/2005 9 July 2008 No violation
Donskov v. Russian Republic (V) 1149/2002 17 July 2008 No Violation
Kibale v. Canada (A) 1562/2007 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 July 2008 Violation
Y. v. Spain (V) 1456/2006 24 July 2008 No Violation
Castedo v. Spain (V) 1122/2002 20 October 2008 Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Kaur v. Canada (A) 1455/2006 30 October 2008 Inadmissible
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Reshetnikov v. Russian Federation (V) 1278/2004 23 March 2009 Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Khostikoev v. Tajikistan (V) 1519/2006 22 October 2009 Violation
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Tiyagarajah v. Sri Lanka (A) 1523/2007 19 March 2010 Inadmissible
Manzano et al. v. Colombia (A) 1616/2007 19 March 2010 Inadmissible
Gonzalez Muñoz v. Guyana (V) 1246/2004 25 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Crochet v. France (V) 1777/2008 25 October 2010 No violation
Bozbey v. Turkmenistan (V) 1530/2006 27 October 2010 Violation
I. S. v. Belarus (A) 1994/2010 25 March 2011 Inadmissible
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
Sedljar and Lavrov v. Estonia (V) 1532/2006 29 March 2011 No violation
Jessop v. New Zealand (V) 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Bonilla Lerma v. Colombia (V) 1611/2007 26 July 2011 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 1812/2008 26 July 2011 No Violation
Cunillera Arias v. Spain (V) 1531/2006 27 July 2011 No Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Korneenko v. Belarus (V) 1226/2003 20 July 2012 Violation
A. P. v. Ukraine (A) 1834/2008 23 July 2012 Inadmissible
Cedeno v. Venezuela (V) 1940/2010 29 October 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Kusherbaev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2027/2011 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Kovsh v. Belarus (V) 1787/2008 27 March 2013 Violation
A.P. v. Russian Federation (A) 1857/2008 28 March 2013 Inadmissible
Pichugina v. Belarus (V) 1592/2007 17 July 2013 Violation
Castaneda v. Mexico (V) 2202/2012 18 July 2013 No violation
V.S. v. Lithuania (A) 2437/2014 23 July 2013 Inadmissible
Turchenyak et al v. Belarus (V) 1948/2010 24 July 2013 Violation
F.B.L v. Costa Rica (A) 1612/2007 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
R.C. v. France (A) 1923/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Jusinskas v. Lithuania (A) 2014/2010 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Sevostyanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1856/2008 1 November 2013 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
X.Q.H. V. New Zealand (A) 2197/2012 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Paksas v. Lithuania (V) 2155/2012 25 March 2014 Violation
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Paadar et al. v. Finland (V) 2102/2011 26 March 2014 No violation
Johnson v. Ghana (V) 2177/2012 27 March 2014 Violation
Poliakov v. Belarus (V) 2103/2011 17 July 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Koktish v. Belarus (V) 1985/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Vojnovic v. Croatia (A) 2068/2011 10 October 2014 Inadmissible
Bolshakov v. Russian Federation (V) 1946/2010 15 October 2014 No violation
Bolivar v. Venezuela (V) 2085/2011 16 October 2014 Violation
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
Bolivar v. Venezuela (V) 2085/2011 16 October 2014 Violation
Shikhmuradov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2069/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Griffiths v. Australia (V) 1973/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Symonik v. Belarus (V) 1952/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Yuzepchuk v. Belarus (V) 1906/2009 24 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Mora v. Spain (A) 2070/2011 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Tonenkaya v. Ukraine (A) 2123/2011 28 October 2014 6 Inadmissible
S.S.F., S.S.E. and E.J.S.E. v. Spain (A) 2105/2011 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
D’Amore v. Argentina (A) 2071/2011 24 July 2014 Inadmissible
E.V. v. Belarus (A) 1989/2010 30 October 2014 Inadmissible
Kozlov et al v. Belarus (V) 1949/2010 25 March 2015 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1992/2010 27 March 2015 Violation
L.F. v. New Zealand (A) 2211/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Khadzhiev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2079/2011 1 April 2015 Violation
E.Z. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2021/2010 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
X. v. Czech Republic (A) 1961/2010 2 April 2015 Inadmissible
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Bakur v. Belarus (V) 1902/2009 15 July 2015 Violation
V.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2043/2011 15 July 2015 No violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
V.S. v. New Zealand (A) 2072/2011 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Ben Ali v. Tunisia (A) 2130/2012 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
J.P.D. v. France (A) 2521/2015 5 November 2015 Inadmissible
Z v. Australia (V) 2279/2013 5 November 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
S.V. v. Belarus(A) 2047/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 2082/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
X. and Y. v. Canada (A) 2771/2016 3 November 2016 Inadmissible
Kerrouche v. Algeria (V) 2128/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
F. A. H. v. Colombia (A) 2121/2011 28 March 2017 Inadmissible
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible
M.B. v. New Zealand (A) 2934/2017 28 March 2017 Inadmissible
N.R. v. New Zealand (A) 2801/2016 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Muñoz v. Peru (V) 203/1986 4 November 1988 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Sánchez López v. Spain (A) 777/1997 18 October 1999 Inadmissible
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Sineiro Fernández v. Spain (V) 1007/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Rameka v. New Zealand(V) 1090/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Everett v. Spain (A) 961/2000 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Arutyuniantz v. Uzbekistan (V) 971/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Yakupova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1205/2003 3 April 2008 No violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation
Cedeno v. Venezuela (V) 1940/2010 29 October 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
V.S. v. Lithuania (A) 2437/2014 23 July 2013 Inadmissible
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Sevostyanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1856/2008 1 November 2013 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
Paksas v. Lithuania (V) 2155/2012 25 March 2014 Violation
Zinsou v. Benin (V) 2055/2011 18 July 2014 Violation
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Yuzepchuk v. Belarus (V) 1906/2009 24 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Ben Ali v. Tunisia (A) 2130/2012 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
S.V. v. Belarus(A) 2047/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
M.B. v. New Zealand (A) 2934/2017 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v.Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)
23 July 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)
28 October 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)
29 March 1982 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Z.P. v. Canada (A) 341/1988 11 April 1991 Inadmissible
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v.Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Everett v. Spain (A) 961/2000 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Guerra de la Espriella v. Colombia (V) 1623/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Valetov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2104/2011 17 March 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Bolivar v. Venezuela (V) 2085/2011 16 October 2014 Violation
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
S.V. v. Belarus(A) 2047/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
M.B. v. New Zealand (A) 2934/2017 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
O.F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Willianms v Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1994 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggart v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Khachatrian v. Armenia (A) 1056/2002 28 October 2005 Inadmissible
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Cedeno v. Venezuela (V) 1940/2010 29 October 2012 Violation
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Ben Ali v. Tunisia (A) 2130/2012 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)(b)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)
1 April 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)
1 April 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Machado v. Uruguay (V) 83/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Oxandabarat v. Uruguay (V) 103/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Manera v. Uruguay (V) 123/1982 6 April 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
O. F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Wight v. Madagascar (V) 115/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Sawyers and McLean v. Jamaica (V) 226 & 256/1987 11 April 1991 No violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 272/1988 31 March 1992 Violation
Hibbert v. Jamaica (V) 293/1988 27 July 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Simmonds v. Jamaica (V) 338/1988 23 October 1992 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Gentles et. al. v. Jamaica (V) 352/ 1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 335/1989 8 July 1994 Violation
Harward v. Norway (V) 451/1991 15 July 1994 No violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Smart v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 672/1995 29 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Hussain v. Mauritius (A) 980/2001 18 March 2002 Inadmissible
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
van Hulst v. The Netherlands (V) 903/1999 1 November 2004 No Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V) 1042/2001 20 October 2005 Violation
Siragev v. Uzbekistan (V) 907/2000 1 November 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Chan v. Guyana (V) 913/2000 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Babkin v. Russian Federation (V) 1310/2004 3 April 2008 Violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Onoufriou v. Cyprus (A) 1636/2007 25 October 2010 Inadmissible
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Rastorguev v. Poland (V) 1517/2006 28 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 1812/2008 26 July 2011 No Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation
Musaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1914-1916/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
A. P. v. Ukraine (A) 1834/2008 23 July 2012 Inadmissible
Cedeno v. Venezuela (V) 1940/2010 29 October 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Zhirnov v. Russian Federation (V) 1795/2008 28 October 2013 No violation
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Ben Ali v. Tunisia (A) 2130/2012 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)(c)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)
29 October 1981 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)
1 April 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Machado v. Uruguay (V) 83/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Oxandabarat v. Uruguay (V) 103/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Manera v. Uruguay (V) 123/1982 6 April 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
van Alphen v. The Netherlands (V) 305/1988 23 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Martin v. Jamaica (V) 317/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 333/1988 23 March 1994 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 335/1989 8 July 1994 Violation
Champagnie et. al v. Jamaica (V) 445/1991 18 July 1994 Violation
Shalto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 447/1991 4 April 1995 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Seerattan v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 434/1990 26 October 1995 Violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Elahie v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 533/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Smart v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 672/1995 29 July 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 616/1995 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Paraga v. Croatia (V) 727/1996 4 April 2001 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Gutiérrez Vicanco v. Peru (V) 678/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Ruiz Agudo v. Spain (V) 864/1999 31 October 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Filpovich v. Lithuania (V) 875/1999 4 August 2003 Violation
Martínez Muñoz v.Spain (V) 1006/2001 30 October 2003 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Kankanamge v. Sri Lanka (V) 909/2000 27 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation

Rouse v. The Philippines (V)

1089/2002

25 July 2005

Violation

Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Lumango and Santos v. Philippines (V) 1466/2006 20 March 2008 Violation
Smantser v. Belarus (V) 1178/2003 23 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Peirano Basso v. Uruguay (V) 1887/2009 19 October 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
Jessop v. New Zealand (V) 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation
Kamoyo v. Zambia (V) 1859/2009 23 March 2012 Violation
Cedeno v. Venezuela (V) 1940/2010 29 October 2012 Violation
J.A.B.G. v. Spain (A) 1891/2009 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
T.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1911/2009 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Foumbi v. Cameroon (A) 2325/2013 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)(d)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)
1 April 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
J.S. v. Canada (A) 130/1982 6 April 1983 Inadmissible
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
O. F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 223/1987 30 March 1989 Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 229/1987 8 April 1991 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Quelch v. Jamaica (V) 292/1988 23 October 1992 No violation
Simmonds v. Jamaica (V) 338/1988 23 October 1992 Violation
Gordon v. Jamaica (V) 237/1987 5 November 1992 No violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 307/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Gentles et. al. v. Jamaica (V) 352/ 1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
Chaplin v. Jamaica (V) 596/1994 2 November 1995 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v.Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v.Georgia (V) 623, 624,626 &627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
C. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 592/1994 20 October 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Lumley v. Jamaica (V) 662/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Maleki v. Italy (V) 699/1996 15 July 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Simpson v. Jamaica (V) 695/1996 31 October 2001 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Rodríguez Orejuela v. Colombia (V) 848/1999 23 July 2002 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Aliev v. Ukraine (V) 781/1997 7 August 2003 Violation
Arutyunyan v. Uzbekistan (V) 917/2000 29 March 2004 Violation
Smartt v. Republic of Guyana (V) 867/1999 6 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation

Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V)

985/2001 18 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Chan v. Guyana (V) 913/2000 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Corriea de Matos v. Portugal (V) 1123/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Donskov v. Russian Federation (V) 1149/2002 17 July 2008 No Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation
Adonis v. The Philippines (V) 1815/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Aboufaied v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1782/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
A. P. v. Ukraine (A) 1834/2008 23 July 2012 Inadmissible
Zhirnov v. Russian Federation (V) 1795/2008 28 October 2013 No violation
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Dorofeev v. Russian Federation (V) 2041/2011 11 July 2014 Violation
Kuznetsov et al v. Belarus (V) 1976/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
L.F. v. New Zealand (A) 2211/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
E.Z. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2021/2010 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Mikhalchenko v. Belarus (V) 1982/2010 22 July 2015 Violation
Ben Ali v. Tunisia (A) 2130/2012 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Zeynalov v. Estonia (V) 2040/2011 4 November 2015 Violation
Dzhakishev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2304/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)(e)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
O. F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 223/1987 30 March 1989 Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 229/1987 8 April 1991 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Cadoret and Bihan v. France (V) 221 & 323/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Sawyers and McLean v. Jamaica (V) 226 & 256/1987 11 April 1991 No violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Prince v. Jamaica (V) 269/1987 30 March 1992 No violation
Hibbert v. Jamaica (V) 293/1988 27 July 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Párkányi v. Hungary (V) 410/1990 27 July 1992 Violation
Gordon v. Jamaica (V) 237/1987 5 November 1992 No violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Compass v. Jamaica (V) 375/1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Young v. Jamaica (V) 615/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Lumley v. Jamaica (V) 662/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Rodríguez Orejuela v. Colombia (V) 848/1999 23 July 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines (V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Khachatrian v. Armenia (A)

1056/2002

28 October 2005 Inadmissible
Lassâad Aouf (V) 1010/2001 17 March 2006 No Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Sedljar and Lavrov v. Estonia (V) 1532/2006 29 March 2011 No violation
Jessop v. New Zealand (V) 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Sevostyanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1856/2008 1 November 2013 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Khadzhiev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2079/2011 1 April 2015 Violation
E.Z. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2021/2010 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)(f)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Cadoret and Bihan v. France (V) 221 & 323/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Barzhig v. France (V) 327/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Shukuru Juma v. Australia (A) 984/2001 28 July 2003 Inadmissible
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Bozbey v. Turkmenistan (V) 1530/2006 27 October 2010 Violation
Yuzepchuk v. Belarus (V) 1906/2009 24 October 2014 Violation
Zeynalov v. Estonia (V) 2040/2011 4 November 2015 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(3)(g)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)
1 April 1982 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
Sánchez López v. Spain (A) 777/1997 18 October 1999 Inadmissible
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Gomaríz v. Spain (V) 1095/2002 22 July 2005 Violation
Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V) 985/2001 18 October 2005 Violation
Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V) 1042/2001 20 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Kouidis v. Greece (V) 1070/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Strakhov and Fayzullaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1017/2001 and 1066/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Tulyaganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1041/2001 20 July 2007 Violation
Khudayberganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1140/2002 24 July 2007 Violation
Uteeva v. Uzbekistan (V) 1150/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Yakupova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1205/2003 3 April 2008 No violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Isaev and Karimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1163/2003 20 March 2009 Violation
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Sattorov v. Tajikistan (V) 1200/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V) 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V) 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation
Musaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1914-1916/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Chiti v. Zambia (V) 1303/2004 26 July 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Q.H.L. v. Australia (A) 1938/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Zhuk v. Belarus (V) 1910/2009 30 October 2013 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
G.J. v. Lithuania (A) 1894/2009 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Grishkovtsov v. Belarus (V) 2013/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Khadzhiev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2079/2011 1 April 2015 Violation
Burdyko v. Belarus (V) 2017/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Selyun v. Belarus (V) 2289/2013 6 November 2015 Violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(4)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Yuzepchuk v. Belarus (V) 1906/2009 24 October 2014 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 14(5)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)
29 October 1981 Violation
de Montejo v. Colombia (V) 64/1979
(R.15/64)
24 March 1982 Violation
Fanali v. Italy (V) 75/1980 31 March 1983 No Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Martin v. Jamaica (V) 317/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Gentles et. al. v. Jamaica (V) 352/ 1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 333/1988 23 March 1994 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 335/1989 8 July 1994 Violation
Champagnie et. al v. Jamaica (V) 445/1991 18 July 1994 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Lumley v. Jamaica (V) 662/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Bryhn v. Norway (V) 789/1997 29 October 1999 No violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Gómez v. Spain (V) 701/1996 20 July 2000 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Mansaraj et al. v. Sierra Leone (V) 839, 840, 841/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Ruiz Agudo v. Spain (V) 864/1999 31 October 2002 Violation
Gelazauskas v. Lithuania (V) 836/1998 17 March 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Shukuru Juma v. Australia (A) 984/2001 28 July 2003 Inadmissible
Semey v. Spain (V) 986/2001 30 July 2003 Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain (A) 956/2000 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Sineiro Fernández v. Spain (V) 1007/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Romanov v. Ukraine (A) 842/1998 30 October 2003 Inadmissible
Lovell v. Australia (V) 920/2000 24 March 2004 No violation
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
van Hulst v. The Netherlands (V) 903/1999 1 November 2004 No Violation
Alba Cabriada v. Spain (V) 1101/2002 1 November 2004 Violation
Terrón Jesús v. Spain (V) 1073/2002 5 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Gayoso Martínez v. Spain (V) 1104/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Parra Corral v. Spain (V) 1356/2005 29 March 2005 Inadmissible
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation
Gomaríz v. Spain (V) 1095/2002 22 July 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines(V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Cuartero Casado v. Spain (A) 1399/2005 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V) 985/2001 18 October 2005 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Lozano v. Spain 1323/2004 28 October 2005 Inadmissible
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Escolar v. Spain (V) 1156/2003 28 March 2006 No Violation
Olivero v. Spain (V) 1211/2003 11 July 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Villamón v. Spain (A) 1305/2004 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Conde v. Spain (V) 1325/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Sánchez and Clares v. Spain (V) 1332/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Gayoso Martínez v. Spain (A) 1098/2002 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Amador v. Spain (V) 1181/2003 31 October 2006 No violation
Moreno v. Spain (V) 1381/2005 25 July 2007 Violation
Kharkhal v. Belarus (A) 1161/2003 31 October 2007 Inadmissible
Serena and Rodríguez v. Spain (V) 1351/2005 and 1352/2005 25 March 2008 Violation
Aboushanif v. Norway (V) 1542/2007 17 July 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Uclés v. Spain (V) 1364/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain (V) 1366/2005 22 July 2009 No violation
Martínez v. Spain (V) 1363/2005 19 October 2009 Violation
Possemiers v. Spain (V) 1398/2005 20 October 2009 No violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Mennen v. The Netherlands (V) 1797/2008 27 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation
 Jessop v. New Zealand (V) 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation
Musaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1914-1916/2008 21 March 2012 Violation
Bruges v. Colombia (V) 1641/2007 23 March 2012 Violation
Kamoyo v. Zambia (V) 1859/2009 23 March 2012 Violation
X. v. Netherlands (A) 1886/2009 28 March 2012 Inadmissible
Weiss v. Austria (V) 1821/2008 24 October 2012 No violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
J.J.U.B v. Spain (A) 1892/2009 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
V.S. v. Lithuania (A) 2437/2014 23 July 2013 Inadmissible
H.P.N. v. Spain (A) 1943/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Sevostyanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1856/2008 1 November 2013 Violation
Johnson v. Ghana (V) 2177/2012 27 March 2014 Violation
Dorofeev v. Russian Federation (V) 2041/2011 11 July 2014 Violation
T.L.N. v. Norway (V) 1942/2010 16 July 2014 No violation
M.R.R. v. Spain (A) 2037/2011 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Timmer v. Netherlands (V) 2097/2011 24 July 2014 Violation
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
H.K. v. Norway (V) 2004/2010/td> 16 October 2014 No violation
Shikhmuradov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2069/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
S.S.F., S.S.E. and E.J.S.E. v. Spain (A) 2105/2011 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
E.Z. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2021/2010 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
V.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2043/2011 15 July 2015 No violation
S.V. v. Belarus(A) 2047/2011 30 March 2016 Inadmissible
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible
M.B. v. New Zealand (A) 2934/2017 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(6)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Muhonen v. Finland (V) 89/1981 8 April 1985 No violation
W. J. H. v. The Netherlands (A) 408/1990 22 July 1992 Inadmissible
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Simunek et al. v. Czech Republic (V) 516/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Uebergang v. Australia (A) 963/2001 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Strik v. The Netherlands(A) 1001/2001 1 November 2002 Inadmissible
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Dumont v. Canada (V) 1467/2006 16 March 2010 Violation
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 14(7)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
A.P. v. Italy (A) 204/1986 2 November 1987 Inadmissible
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Strik v. The Netherlands (A) 1001/2001 1 November 2002 Inadmissible
Babkin v. Russian Federation (V) 1310/2004 3 April 2008 Violation
Tillman v. Australia (V) 1635/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
H.P.N. v. Spain (A) 1943/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
V.S. v. Lithuania (A) 2437/2014 23 July 2013 Inadmissible
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
S.S.F., S.S.E. and E.J.S.E. v. Spain (A) 2105/2011 28 October 2014 Inadmissible
Abdullayev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2218/2012 25 March 2015 Violation
J.G. v. New Zealand (A) 2631/2015 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
A.G.S. v. Spain (A) 2626/2015 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Mohamed Rabbae v. Netherlands (V) 2124/2011 14 July 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 15

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kivenmaa v. Finland (V) 412/1990 31 March 1994 Violation
de Groot v. The Netherlands (A) 578/1994 14 July 1995 Inadmissible
Westerman v. The Netherlands (V) 682/1996 3 November 1999 No violation
Strik v. The Netherlands (A) 1001/2001 1 November 2002 Inadmissible
Van Grinsven. v. The Netherlands(A) 1142/2002 27 March 2003 Inadmissible
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Bakurov v. Russian Federation (V) 1861/2009 25 March 2013 No violation
D.T.T. V. Colombia (A) 1904/2009 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Alekperov v. Russian Federation (V) 1764/2008 21 October 2013 No violation
Paksas v. Lithuania (V) 2155/2012 25 March 2014 Violation
Huseynov v. Azerbaijan (A) 2042/2011 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Shikhmuradov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2069/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
G.C.A.A. v. Uruguay (A) 2358/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
V.K. v. Russian Federation (A) 2411/2014 30 March 2016 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 15(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Van Duzen v. Canada (V) 50/1979
(R.12/50)
7 April 1982 No violation
MacIsaac v. Canada (V) 55/1979 14 October 1982 No violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Filpovich v. Lithuania (V) 875/1999 4 August 2003 Violation
Nicholas v. Australia (V) 1080/2002 19 March 2004 No violation

Ostroukhov v. Russian Federation (A)

967/2001

31 March 2005

Inadmissible

Gavrilin v. Belarus (V) 1342/2005 28 March 2007 No violation
van der Plaat v. New Zealand (A) 1492/2006 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Fardon v. Australia (V) 1629/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Tofanyuk v. Ukraine (V) 1346/2005 20 October 2010 No violation
Cochet v. France (V) 1760/2008 21 October 2010 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
K.S. v. Australia (A) 1921/2009 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
V.S. v. Lithuania (A) 2437/2014 23 July 2013 Inadmissible
Quliyev v. Azerbaijan (V) 1972/2010 16 October 2014 Violation
Blessington and Elliot v. Australia (V) 1968/2010 22 October 2014 Violation
V.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2043/2011 15 July 2015 No violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 15(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 16

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
A.A.C. v. Sweden (V) 277/2003 16 November 2006 No Violation
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Traoré v. Côte d’Ivoire (V) 1759/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Chihoub v. Algeria (V) 1811/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Djebrouni v. Algeria (V) 1781/2008 31 October 2011 Violation
Kirani v. Algeria (V) 1905/2009 26 March 2012 Violation
Guezout et al. v. Algeria (V) 1753/2008 19 July 2012 Violation
Mezine v. Algeria (V) 1779/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
M.N. et al. v. Tajikistan (A) 1500/2006 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Abushaala v. Libya (V) 1913/2009 18 March 2013 Violation
Saadoun v. Algeria (V) 1806/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Mechani v. Algeria (V) 1807/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
A.P. v. Russian Federation (A) 1857/2008 28 March 2013 Inadmissible
Khazmi v. Libya (V) 1832/2008 18 July 2013 Violation
Zerrougui v. Algeria (V) 1796/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Azouz v. Algeria (V) 1798/2008 25 July 2013 Violation
Mihoubi v. Algeria (V) 1874/2009 18 October 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
F.B.L v. Costa Rica (A) 1612/2007 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Terafi v. Algeria (V) 1899/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Mehalli et al. v. Algeria (V) 1900/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Rizvanovic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1997/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Duric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1956/2010 16 July 2014 Violation
Selimovic et al v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2003/2010 17 July 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Al Daquel v. Libya (V) 1882/2009 21 July 2014 Violation
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Kozljak v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1970/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Hero v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1966/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Basnet v. Nepal (V) 2051/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Bhandari v. Nepal (V) 2031/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Sassene v. Algeria (V) 2026/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Ammari v. Algeria (V) 2098/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Kroumi v. Algeria (V) 2083/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Dehimi & Ayache v. Algeria (V) 2086/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Hamulic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2022/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Icic & Mevlida v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2028/2011 30 March 2015 Violation
Katwal v. Nepal (V) 2000/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Dovadzija et al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation
Kadiric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2048/2011 5 November 2015 Violation
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
El Boathi v. Algeria (V) 2259/2013 17 March 2017 Violation
N.R. v. New Zealand (A) 2801/2016 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 17

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
van Alphen v. The Netherlands (V) 305/1988 23 July 1990 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Orihuela v. Peru (V) 309/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Coeriel and Aurik v. The Netherlands (V) 453/1991 31 October 1994 Violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Fei v. Colombia (V) 514/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Stewart v. Canada (V) 538/1993 1 November 1996 No violation
Canepa v. Canada (V) 558/1993 3 April 1997 No violation
Rogl v. Germany (A) 808/1998 25 October 2000 Inadmissible
Buckle v. New Zealand (V) 858/1999 25 October 2000 No violation
Rojas García v. Colombia (V) 687/1996 3 April 2001 Violation
Winata v. Australia (V) 930/2000 26 July 2001 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Patera v. Czech Republic (V) 946/2000 25 July 2002 Violation
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Ngambi v. France (A) 1179/2003 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Byahuranga v. Denmark (V) 1222/2003 1 November 2004 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Brun v. France (A) 1453/2006 18 October 2006 Inadmissible
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 July 2008 Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Dauphin v. Canada (V) 1792/2008 28 July 2009 Violation
Georgpoulos v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation
Raihman v. Latvia 1621/2007 28 October 2010 Violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation
Peiris v. Sri Lanka (V) 1862/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Chiti v. Zambia (V) 1303/2004 26 July 2012 Violation
Bulgakov v. Ukraine (V) 1803/2008 29 October 2012 Violation
M.N. et al. v. Tajikistan (A) 1500/2006 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
Naidenova et al v. Bulgaria (V) 2073/2011 30 October 2012 Violation
Singh v. France (V) 1852/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Khwildy v. Libya (V) 1804/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Mandic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2064/2011 5 November 2012 Violation
Lin v. Australia (V) 1957/2010 21 March 2013 No violation
Boudjemai v. Algeria (V) 1791/2008 22 March 2013 Violation
Q.H.L. v. Australia (A) 1938/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
S.N.A. v. Cameroon (A) 1962/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Alekperov v. Russian Federation (V) 1764/2008 21 October 2013 No violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Martinez et al. v. Algeria (A) 1922/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
Horvath v. Australia (V) 1885/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
Baruani v. Democratic Republic of Congo (V) 1890/2009 27 March 2014 Violation
S.I.D. et al v. Bulgaria (A) 1926/2010 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Jum'a et al v. Libya (V) 1958/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Vojnovic v. Croatia (A) 2068/2011 10 October 2014 Inadmissible
Shikhmuradov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2069/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Khakdar v. Russian Federation (V) 2126/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Sassene v. Algeria (V) 2026/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Kroumi v. Algeria (V) 2083/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
Dehimi & Ayache v. Algeria (V) 2086/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
A.H.G. v. Canada (V) 2091/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
Leghaei v. Australia (V) 1937/2010 26 March 2015 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation
H.S. v. Australia (A) 2015/2010 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
E.L.K. v. Netherlands (A) 2050/2011 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
Dovadzija et al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Kruk v. Belarus (V) 1996/2010 29 October 2015 Violation
Z v. Australia (V) 2279/2013 5 November 2015 Violation
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
A.S v. Nepal (V) 2077/2011 6 November 2015 Violation
Mellet v. Ireland (V) 2324/2013 31 March 2016 Violation
X. v. Netherlands (A) 2729/2016 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
Mohamed Rabbae v. Netherlands (V) 2124/2011 14 July 2016 No violation
D.T. and A.A. v. Canada (V) 2081/2011 15 July 2016 Violation
Kerrouche v. Algeria (V) 2128/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
Contreras v. Canada (V) 2613/2015 27 March 2017 Violation

ARTICLE 17(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
R.7/27)
29 October 1981 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Toonen v. Australia (V) 488/1992 30 March 1994 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 512/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
van Hulst v. The Netherlands (V) 903/1999 1 November 2004 No Violation
E.B. v. New Zealand (V) 1368/2005 16 March 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Tornel et al. v. Spain (V) 1473/2006 20 March 2009 Violation
Gonzalez v. Republic of Guyana (V) 1246/2004 25 March 2010 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
X.Q.H. V. New Zealand (A) 2197/2012 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Khadzhiev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2079/2011 1 April 2015 Violation
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
Amanklychev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2078/2011 31 March 2016 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 17(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 18

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
L.T.K. v. Finland (A) 185/1984 9 July 1985 Inadmissible
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Bhinder v. Canada (V) 208/1986 9 November 1989 no violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Westerman v. The Netherlands (V) 682/1996 3 November 1999 No violation
Ross v. Canada (V) 736/1997 18 October 2000 No violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Leirvåg v. Norway (V) 1155/2003 3 November 2004 violation
Hudoyberganova v. Uzbekistan (V) 931/2000 5 November 2004 violation
Narrain et al v. Mauritius (V) 1744/2008 27 July 2012 Violation
Kovaleva & Kozyar v. Belarus (V) 2120/2011 29 October 2012 Violation
Singh v. France (V) 1852/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Singh v. France (V) 1928/2010 19 July 2013 Violation
X. v. Denmark (V) 2007/2010 26 March 2014 Violation
Z. v. Australia (V) 2049/2011 18 July 2014 Violation
Bouzaout v. Algeria (V) 1974/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
B.L. v. Australia (V) 2053/2011 16 October 2014 No violation
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
X. v. Denmark (A) 2515/2014 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Z. v. Denmark/Iran (V) 2329/2014 15 July 2015 No violation
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
R.G. et al. v. Denmark (A) 2351/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
A and B v. Denmark (V) 2291/2013 13 July 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 18(1)

v
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Malakhovsky v. Belarus (V) 1207/2003 26 July 2005 Violation
Immaculate Joseph et al. v. Sri Lanka (V)

1249/2004

21 October 2005

Violation

Yoon and Choi v. Republic of Korea (V) 1321 & 1322/2004 3 November 2006 Violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation
Jung et al. v. Republic of Korea (V) 1593-1603/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Min-Kyu Jeong et al. v. Republic of Korea (V) 1642-1741/2007 24 March 2011 Violation
Singh v. France 1876/2009 22 July 2011 Violation
Atasoy and Sarkut v. Turkey (V) 1853-1854/2008 29 March 2012 Violation
Kim et al v. Republic of Korea (V) 1786/2008 25 October 2012 Violation
Yachnik v. Belarus (A) 1990/2010 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Kim et al v. Republic of Korea (V) 2179/2012 15 October 2014 Violation
Leven v. Kazakhstan (V) 2131/2012 21 October 2014 No violation
Abdullayev v. Turkmenistan (V) 2218/2012 25 March 2015 Violation
Hudaybergenov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2222/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Japparow v. Turkmenistan (V) 2223/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Hudaybergenov v. Turkmenistan (V) 2221/2012 29 October 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 18(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Hudoyberganova v. Uzbekistan (V) 931/2000 5 November 2004 violation
A.P. v. Russian Federation (A) 1857/2008 28 March 2013 Inadmissible
Yachnik v. Belarus (A) 1990/2010 21 July 2014 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 18(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Hudoyberganova v. Uzbekistan (V) 931/2000 5 November 2004 violation
Malakhovsky v. Belarus (V) 1207/2003 26 July 2005 Violation
Immaculate Joseph et al. v. Sri Lanka 1249/2004 21 October 2005 Violation
Yoon and Choi v. Republic of Korea (V) 1321 & 1322/2004 3 November 2006 Violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation
Singh v. France 1876/2009 22 July 2011 Violation
Leven v. Kazakhstan (V) 2131/2012 21 October 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 18(4)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Hartikainen v. Finland (V) 40/1978 9 April 1981 No violation
Leirvåg v. Norway (V) 1155/2003 3 November 2004 violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 1867/2009, 1936/2010, 1975/2010, 1977-1981/2010 and 2010/2010 19 July 2012 Violation
Korneenko v. Belarus (V) 1226/2003 20 July 2012 Violation
Schumilin v. Belarus (V) 1784/2008 23 July 2012 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 19

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
J.R.T. and the W .G. Party v. Canada (A) 104/1981 6 April 1983 Inadmissible
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
L.T.K. v. Finland (A) 185/1984 9 July 1985 Inadmissible
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Ballantyne, Davidson and MacIntyre v. Canada (V) 359 & 385/1989 31 March 1993 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Koné v. Senegal (V) 386/1989 21 October 1994 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423, & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
Park v. Republic of Korea (V) 628/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Ross v. Canada (V) 736/1997 18 October 2000 No violation
Paraga v. Croatia (V) 727/1996 4 April 2001 Violation
Dergachev v. Belarus (V) 921/2000 2 April 2002 Violation
Nam v. Republic of Korea (A) 693/1996 28 July 2003 Inadmissible
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Kankanamge v. Sri Lanka (V) 909/2000 27 July 2004 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
Mavlonov and Sa’di v. Uzbekistan (V) 1334/2004 19 March 2009 Violation
Govsha, Syritsa and Mezyak v. Belarus (V) 1790/2008 27 July 2012 Violation
Katsora v. Belarus (V) 1836/2008 24 October 2012 Violation
M.N. et al. v. Tajikistan (A) 1500/2006 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
S.K. v. Belarus (A) 2169/2012 31 October 2012 Inadmissible
Fedotova v. Russian Federation (V) 1932/2010 31 October 2012 Violation
Kholodova v. Russian Federation (V) 1548/2007/td> 1 November 2012 Violation
Yasinovich & Shevchenko v. Belarus (V) 1835/2008 20 March 2013 Violation
Kusherbaev v. Kazakhstan (V) 2027/2011 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
S.N.A. v. Cameroon (A) 1962/2010 25 March 2013 Inadmissible
Castaneda v. Mexico (V) 2202/2012 18 July 2013 No violation
Protsko & Tolchi v. Belarus (V) 1919-1920/2009 1 November 2013 Violation
Youbko v. Belarus (V) 1903/2009 17 March 2014 Violation
Pustovoit v. Ukraine (V) 1405/2005 20 March 2014 Violation
Z. v. Australia (V) 2049/2011 18 July 2014 Violation
Al-Rabassi v. Libya (V) 1860/2009 18 July 2014 Violation
Kuznetsov et al v. Belarus (V) 1976/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Koktish v. Belarus (V) 1985/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Bazarov v. Belarus (V) 1934/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Volchek v. Belarus (V) 1991/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Kozlov v. Belarus (V) 1986/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Evrezov et al v. Belarus (V) 1999/2010 10 October 2014 Violation
Nepomnyaschikh v. Belarus (V) 2156/2012 10 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Toregozhina v. Kazakhstan (V) 2137/2012 21 October 2014 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2114/2011 22 October 2014 Violation
Lozenko v. Belarus (V) 1929/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1992/2010 27 March 2015 Violation
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
Surgan v. Belarus (V) 1969/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Z. v. Denmark/Iran (V) 2329/2014 15 July 2015 No violation
K. v. Denmark (V) 2393/2014 16 July 2015 No violation
Mikhalchenko v. Belarus (V) 1982/2010 22 July 2015 Violation
H.E.A.K. v. Denmark (V) 2343/2014 23 July 2015 Violation
Arkadyevich v. Russian Federation (V) 2141/2012 23 October 2015 Violation
Statkevich & Matskevich v. Belarus (V) 2133/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Poplavny v. Belarus (V) 2019/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Androsenko v. Belarus (V) 2092/2011 30 March 2016 Violation
Askarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 2231/2012 31 March 2016 Violation
Mellet v. Ireland (V) 2324/2013 31 March 2016 Violation
E.U.R. v. Denmark (V) 2469/2014 1 July 2016 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 2082/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
X. and Y. v. Canada (A) 2771/2016 3 November 2016 Inadmissible
Poplavny, Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2139/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
Kerrouche v. Algeria (V) 2128/2012 3 November 2016 Violation
A.P.J. v. Denmark (V) 2253/2013 16 March 2017 No violation

ARTICLE 19(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Symonik v. Belarus (V) 1952/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Bakur v. Belarus (V) 1902/2009 15 July 2015 Violation
X v. Canada (V) 2366/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
T.V. & A.G. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2044/2011 11 March 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 19(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Hertzberg et al. v. Finland (V) 61/1979
(R.14/61)
2 April 1982 No violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Jaona v. Madagascar (V) 132/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
R.T. v. France (A) 262/1987 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Kivenmaa v. Finland (V) 412/1990 31 March 1994 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Singer v. Canada (V) 455/1991 26 July 1994 Violation
Sohn v. Republic of Korea (V) 518/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Gauthier v. Canada (V) 633/1995 7 April 1999 Violation
Laptsevich v. Belarus (V) 780/1997 20 March 2000 Violation
Zündel v. Canada (A) 953/2000 27 July 2003 Inadmissible
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Shin v. Republic of Korea (V) 926/2000 16 March 2004 Violation
Lovell v. Australia (V) 920/2000 24 March 2004 No violation
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Jong-Cheol v. Republic of Korea (V) 968/2001 27 July 2005 No violation
Velichkin v. Belarus (V) 1022/2001 20 October 2005 Violation
Bodrozic v. Serbia and Montenegro (V) 1180/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Shchetko v. Belarus (V) 1009/2001 11 July 2006 Violation
Coleman v. Australia (V) 1157/2003 17 July 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Katsora v. Belarus (V) 1377/2005 19 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Toktakunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1470/2006 28 March 2011 Violation
Zalesskaya v. Belarus (V) 1604/2007 28 March 2011 Violation
Kungurov v. Uzbekistan 1478/2006 20 July 2011 Violoation
P. L. v. Belarus (A) 1814/2008 26 July 2011 Inadmissible
Gryb v. Belarus (V) 1316/2004 26 October 2011 Violation
Tulzhenkova v. Belarus (V) 1838/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1750/2008 14 March 2012 Violation
Belyazeka v. Belarus (V) 1772/2008 23 March 2012 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 1867/2009, 1936/2010, 1975/2010, 1977-1981/2010 and 2010/2010 19 July 2012 Violation
Korneenko v. Belarus (V) 1226/2003 20 July 2012 Violation
Schumilin v. Belarus (V) 1784/2008 23 July 2012 Violation
Pivonos v. Belarus (V) 1830/2008 29 October 2012 Violation
Olechkevitch v. Belarus (V) 1785/2008 18 March 2013 Violation
Kovalenko v. Belarus (V) 1808/2008 17 July 2013 Violation
Castaneda v. Mexico (V) 2202/2012 18 July 2013 No violation
Turchenyak et al v. Belarus (V) 1948/2010 24 July 2013 Violation
Komarovsky v. Belarus (V) 1839/2008 25 October 2013 Violation
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Poliakov v. Belarus (V) 2103/2011 17 July 2014 Violation
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Aleksandrov v. Belarus (V) 1933/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Praded v. Belarus (V) 2029/2011 10 October 2014 Violation
Stambrovsky v. Belarus (V) 1987/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Symonik v. Belarus (V) 1952/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Kozlov et al v. Belarus (V) 1949/2010 25 March 2015 Violation
Pugach v. Belarus (V) 1984/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Kruk v. Belarus (V) 1996/2010 29 October 2015 Violation
Derzhavtsev v. Belarus (V) 2076/2011 29 October 2015 Violation
V.S. v. New Zealand (A) 2072/2011 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
T.V. & A.G. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2044/2011 11 March 2016 Violation
Evzrezov v. Belarus (V) 2101/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Misnikov v. Belarus (V) 2093/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Basarevsky & Rybchenkov v. Belarus (V) 2108/2011, 2109/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Korol v. Belarus (V) 2089/2011 14 July 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 19(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)
1 April 1982 Violation
Hertzberg et al. v. Finland (V) 61/1979
(R.14/61)
2 April 1982 No violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Sohn v. Republic of Korea (V) 518/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Faurisson v. France (V) 550/1993 8 November 1996 No violation
Kim v. Republic of Korea (V) 574/1994 2 November 1998 Violation
Gauthier v. Canada (V) 633/1995 7 April 1999 Violation
Laptsevich v. Belarus (V) 780/1997 20 March 2000 Violation
Baban et al. v. Australia (V) 1014/2001 6 August 2003 Violation
Shin v. Republic of Korea (V) 926/2000 16 March 2004 Violation
Lovell v. Australia (V) 920/2000 24 March 2004 No violation
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Jong-Cheol v. Republic of Korea (V) 968/2001 27 July 2005 No violation
Shchetko v. Belarus (V) 1009/2001 11 July 2006 Violation
Coleman v. Australia (V) 1157/2003 17 July 2006 Violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
A.K. and A.R. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1233/2003 31 March 2009 No violation
Katsora v. Belarus (V) 1377/2005 19 July 2010 Violation
Toktakunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1470/2006 28 March 2011 Violation
Zalesskaya v. Belarus (V) 1604/2007 28 March 2011 Violation
Adonis v. The Philippines (V) 1815/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1750/2008 14 March 2012 Violation
Belyazeka v. Belarus (V) 1772/2008 23 March 2012 Violation
Olechkevitch v. Belarus (V) 1785/2008 18 March 2013 Violation

ARTICLE 20(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
J.R.T. and the W.G. Party v. Canada (A) 104/1981 6 April 1983 Inadmissible
Vassilari et al. v. Greece (V) 1570/2007 19 March 2009 No violation
A.W.P v. Denmark (A) 1879/2009 1 November 2013 Inadmissible
Mohamed Rabbae v. Netherlands (V) 2124/2011 14 July 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 21

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kivenmaa v. Finland (V) 412/1990 31 March 1994 Violation
Zalesskaya v. Belarus (V)

1604/2007 28 March 2011 Violation
Gryb v. Belarus (V) 1316/2004 26 October 2011 Violation
Belyazeka v. Belarus (V) 1772/2008 23 March 2012 Violation
Chebotareva v. Russian Federation (V) 1866/2009 26 March 2012 Violation
Katsora v. Belarus (V) 1836/2008 24 October 2012 Violation
Pivonos v. Belarus (V) 1830/2008 29 October 2012 Violation
Benali v. Libya (V) 1805/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Kovalenko v. Belarus (V) 1808/2008 17 July 2013 Violation
Turchenyak et al v. Belarus (V) 1948/2010 24 July 2013 Violation
Komarovsky v. Belarus (V) 1839/2008 25 October 2013 Violation
Alekseev v. Russian Federation (V) 1873/2009 25 October 2013 Violation
Sekerko v. Belarus (V) 1851/2008 28 October 2013 Violation
Youbko v. Belarus (V) 1903/2009 17 March 2014 Violation
Kirsanov v. Belarus (V) 1864/2009 20 March 2014 Violation
Poliakov v. Belarus (V) 2030/2011 17 July 2014 Violation
Kuznetsov et al v. Belarus (V) 1976/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Bazarov v. Belarus (V) 1934/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Evrezov et al v. Belarus (V) 1999/2010 10 October 2014 Violation
Praded v. Belarus (V) 2029/2011 10 October 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Kozulina v. Belarus (V) 1773/2008 21 October 2014 Violation
Toregozhina v. Kazakhstan (V) 2137/2012 21 October 2014 Violation
Lozenko v. Belarus (V) 1929/2010 24 October 2014 Violation
Kozlov et al v. Belarus (V) 1949/2010 25 March 2015 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1992/2010 27 March 2015 Violation
Surgan v. Belarus (V) 1969/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Bakur v. Belarus (V) 1902/2009 15 July 2015 Violation
Evrezov v. Belarus (V) 1988/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
Pugach v. Belarus (V) 1984/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Arkadyevich v. Russian Federation (V) 2141/2012 23 October 2015 Violation
Derzhavtsev v. Belarus (V) 2076/2011 29 October 2015 Violation
Statkevich & Matskevich v. Belarus (V) 2133/2012 29 October 2015 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2016/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Poplavny v. Belarus (V) 2019/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
Androsenko v. Belarus (V) 2092/2011 30 March 2016 Violation
Evzrezov v. Belarus (V) 2101/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 2082/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Basarevsky & Rybchenkov v. Belarus (V) 2108/2011, 2109/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Korol v. Belarus (V) 2089/2011 14 July 2016 Violation
Poplavny, Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 2139/2012 3 November 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 22

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
J.B. et al. v. Canada (A) 118/1982 18 July 1986 Inadmissible
Park v. Republic of Korea (V) 628/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Wallman v. Austria (V) 1002/2001 1 April 2004 No Violation
Korneenko et al. v. Belarus 1274/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Tebourski v. France (V) 300/2006 1 May 2007 Violation
C.A.R.M. et al. v. Canada (V) 298/2006 18 May 2007 No violation
Govsha, Syritsa and Mezyak v. Belarus (V) 1790/2008 27 July 2012 Violation
M.N. et al. v. Tajikistan (A) 1500/2006 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
Protsko & Tolchi v. Belarus (V) 1919-1920/2009 1 November 2013 Violation
Pinchuk v. Belarus (V) 2165/2012 24 October 2014 Violation
Mikhailovskaya & Volchek v. Belarus (V) 1993/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
M. v. Belgium (A) 2176/2012 30 March 2015 Inadmissible
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Hicks v. Australia (V) 2005/2010 5 November 2015 Violation
F. A. H. v. Colombia (A) 2121/2011 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 22(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Wallman v. Austria (V) 1002/2001 1 April 2004 No violation
Lee v. Republic of Korea (V) 1119/2002 20 July 2005 Violation
Zvozskov et al. v. Belarus 1039/2001 17 October 2006 Violation
Korneenko et al. v. Belarus 1274/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Belyatsky et al. v. Belarus (V) 1296/2004 24 July 2007 Violation
Katsora et. al v. Belarus (V) 1383/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Kungurov v. Uzbekistan 1478/2006 20 July 2011 Violoation
Korneenko v. Belarus (V) 1226/2003 20 July 2012 Violation
Romanovsky v. Belarus (V) 2011/2010 29 October 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 22(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lee v. Republic of Korea (V) 1119/2002 20 July 2005 Violation
Zvozskov et al. v. Belarus 1039/2001 17 October 2006 Violation
Korneenko et al. v. Belarus 1274/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Belyatsky et al. v. Belarus (V) 1296/2004 24 July 2007 Violation
Katsora et. al v. Belarus (V) 1383/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Kungurov v. Uzbekistan 1478/2006 20 July 2011 Violoation
Kalyakin v. Belarus 2153/2012 10 October 2014 Violoation
Romanovsky v. Belarus (V) 2011/2010 29 October 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 23

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)
30 July 1981 Violation
Hendricks v. The Netherlands (V) 201/1985 27 July 1988 No violation
Stewart v. Canada (V) 538/1993 1 November 1996 No violation
Buckle v. New Zealand (V) 858/1999 25 October 2000 No violation
Ngambi v. France (A) 1179/2003 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Asensi v. Paraguay 1407/2005 27 March 2009 Violation
El-Hichou v. Denmark (V) 1554/2007 22 July 2010 Violation
Georgopoulos et al. v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Jum'a et al v. Libya (V) 1958/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Mohamed v. Libya (V) 2046/2011 17 October 2014 Violation
Leghaei v. Australia (V) 1937/2010 26 March 2015 Violation
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
Z v. Australia (V) 2279/2013 5 November 2015 Violation
Lumbala v. DR Congo (V) 2214/2012 5 November 2015 Violation
X. v. Netherlands (A) 2729/2016 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
D.T. and A.A. v. Canada (V) 2081/2011 15 July 2016 Violation
Contreras v. Canada (V) 2613/2015 27 March 2017 Violation

ARTICLE 23(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Santacana v. Spain (V) 417/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Winata v. Australia (V) 930/2000 26 July 2001 Violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
Sahid v. New Zealand (V) 893/1999 28 March 2003 Violation
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Byahuranga v. Denmark (V) 1222/2003 1 November 2004 Violation
E.B. v. New Zealand (V) 1368/2005 16 March 2007 Violation
Dauphin v. Canada (V) 1792/2008 28 July 2009 Violation
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation
Peiris v. Sri Lanka (V) 1862/2008 26 October 2011 Violation
Belyazeka v. Belarus (V) 1772/2008 23 March 2012 Violation
Chiti v. Zambia (V) 1303/2004 26 July 2012 Violation
Mandic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2064/2011 5 November 2012 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
Aouali, Faraoun and Bouregba v. Algeria (V) 1884/2009 18 Octover 2013 Violation
Marouf v. Algeria (V) 1889/2009 21 March 2014 Violation
X.Q.H. V. New Zealand (A) 2197/2012 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Bouzenia v. Algeria (V) 1931/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Boudehane v. Algeria (V) 1924/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
Husseini v. Denmark (V) 2243/2013 24 October 2014 Violation
Louddi v. Algeria (V) 2117/2011 30 October 2014 Violation
A.H.G. v. Canada (V) 2091/2011 25 March 2015 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation
Serna et al v. Colombia (V) 2134/2012 9 July 2015 Violation
Dovadzija at al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 23(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation

ARTICLE 23(4)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Santacana v. Spain (V) 417/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Fei v. Colombia (V) 514/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation
Y.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2059/2011 31 March 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 24

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
D. Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 800/1998 8 April 1999 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
X. H. L. v. Netherlands 1564/2007 22 July 2011 Violation
Choudhary v. Canada (V) 1898/2009 28 October 2013 Violation
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Husseini v. Denmark (V) 2243/2013 24 October 2014 Violation
Leghaei v. Australia (V) 1937/2010 26 March 2015 Violation
Kadiric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2048/2011 5 November 2015 Violation
Z v. Australia (V) 2279/2013 5 November 2015 Violation
X. v. Netherlands (A) 2729/2016 14 July 2016 Inadmissible
D.T. and A.A. v. Canada (V) 2081/2011 15 July 2016 Violation
Berezhnoy v. Russian Federation (V) 2107/2011 28 October 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 24(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Santacana v. Spain (V) 417/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Winata v. Australia (V) 930/2000 26 July 2001 Violation
Jalloh v. The Netherlands (V) 794/1998 26 March 2002 No violation
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Asensi v. Paraguay 1407/2005 27 March 2009 Violation
Kaba v. Canada (V) 1465/2006 25 March 2010 Violation
El-Hichou v. Denmark (V) 1554/2007 22 July 2010 Violation
F.K.A.G. v. Australia (V) 2094/2011 26 July 2013 Violation
Al-Maqrif & Matar v. Libya (V) 2006/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
X.Q.H. V. New Zealand (A) 2197/2012 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Selimovic et al v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2003/2010 17 July 2014 Violation
Blessington and Elliot v. Australia (V) 1968/2010 22 October 2014 Violation
Kozljak v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1970/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Hero v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1966/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Tripathi v. Nepal (V) 2111/2011 29 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
M.G.C. v. Australia (V) 1875/2009 26 March 2015 Violation
Tharu et al v. Nepal (V) 2038/2011 3 July 2015 Violation
Dovadzija et al. v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2143/2012 22 July 2015 No violation

ARTICLE 24(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation

ARTICLE 24(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation

ARTICLE 25

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)
15 August 1979 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Silva et al. v. Uruguay (V) 34/1978 8 April 1981 Violation
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)
29 March 1982 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Rodríguez Veiga v. Uruguay (A) 487/1992 18 July 1994 Inadmissible
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Debreczeny v. The Netherlands (V) 500/1992 3 April 1995 No violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Ignatane v. Latvia (V) 884/1999 25 July 2001 Violation
Mazou v. Cameroon (V) 630/1995 26 July 2001 Violation
Karakurt v. Austria (V) 965/2000 4 April 2002 Violation
Gillot v. France (V) 932/2000 15 July 2002 No violation
Arenz v. Germany (A) 1138/2002 24 March 2004 Inadmissible
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Lukyanchik v. Belarus (V) 1392/2005 21 October 2009 Violation
Yevdokimov and Rezanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1410/2005 21 March 2011 Violation
Narrain et al v. Mauritius (V) 1744/2008 27 July 2012 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1992/2010 27 March 2015 Violation
Spisso v. Venezuela (V) 2481/2014 17 March 2017 Violation

ARTICLE 25(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Marshall et al. v. Canada (V) 205/1986 4 November 1991 No violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Mátyus v. Slovakia (V) 923/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Beydon v. France (A) 1400/2005 2 November 2005 Inadmissible
Brun v. France (V) 1473/2006 7 November 2006 No violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation
Korneenko v. Belarus (V) 1226/2003 20 July 2012 Violation
A.P. v. Russian Federation (A) 1857/2008 28 March 2013 Inadmissible
Paksas v. Lithuania (V) 2155/2012 25 March 2014 Violation

ARTICLE 25(b)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Shchetko v. Belarus (V) 1009/2001 11 July 2006 Violation
Sinitsin v. Belarus (V) 1047/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
Lukyanchik v. Belarus (V) 1392/2005 21 October 2009 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation
M.N. et al. v. Tajikistan (A) 1500/2006 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
A.P. v. Russian Federation (A) 1857/2008 28 March 2013 Inadmissible
Paksas v. Lithuania (V) 2155/2012 25 March 2014 Violation
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible


ARTICLE 25(c)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Stalla Costa v. Uruguay (V) 198/1985 9 July 1987 No violation
Muñoz v. Peru (V) 203/1986 4 November 1988 Violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423 & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
Kall v. Poland (V) 522/1993 14 July 1997 No violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Marín Gómez v. Spain (V) 865/1999 22 October 2001 No violation
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Mátyus v. Slovakia (V) 923/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus(V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
Karatsis v. Cyprus (A)

1182/2003

25 July 2005

Inadmissible
Solís v. Peru (V) 1016/2001 27 March 2006 No Violation
Raosavljevic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (A) 1219/2003 28 March 2007 Inadmissible
Bandaranayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1376/2005 24 July 2008 Violation
Bandaranayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1376/2005 24 July 2008 Violation
Jusinskas v. Lithuania (A) 2014/2010 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Paksas v. Lithuania (V) 2155/2012 25 March 2014 Violation

ARTICLE 26

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)
30 July 1981 Violation
E.H. v. Finland (A) 170/1984 25 October 1985 Inadmissible
S.W.M. Brooks v. The Netherlands (V) 172/1984 9 April 1987 Violation
Danning v. The Netherlands (V) 180/1984 9 April 1987 No violation
Zwaan-de Vries v. The Netherlands (V) 182/1984 9 April 1987 Violation
Stalla Costa v. Uruguay (V) 198/1985 9 July 1987 No violation
P. P. C. v The Netherlands (A) 212/1986 24 March 1988 Inadmissible
Blom v. Sweden (V) 191/1985 4 April 1988 No violation
Avellanal v. Peru (V) 202/1986 28 October 1988 Violation
Vos v. The Netherlands (V) 218/1986 29 March 1989 No violation
R.T. v. France (A) 262/1987 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
B. d. B. et al. v. The Netherlands (A) 273/1989 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Gueye et al. v. France (V) 196/1983 3 April 1989 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
Bhinder v. Canada (V) 208/1986 9 November 1989 no violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Järvinen v. Finland (V) 295/1988 25 July 1990 No violation
Lindgren et al. and Lundquist et al. v. Sweden (DJ), (V) 298 & 299/1988 9 November 1990 No violation
Cadoret and Bihan v. France (V) 221 & 323/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Barzhig v. France (V) 327/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Pauger v. Austria (V) 415/1990 26 March 1992 Violation
Sprenger v. The Netherlands (V) 395/1990 31 March 1992 No violation
Oulajin & Kaiss v. The Netherlands (V) 406 & 426/1990 23 October 1992 No violation
Ballantyne, Davidson and McIntyre v. Canada (V) 359 & 385/1989 31 March 1993 Violation
Orihuela v. Peru (V) 309/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Brinkhof v. The Netherlands (V) 402/1990 27 July 1993 No violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Araujo-Jongen v. The Netherlands (V) 418/1990 22 October 1993 No violation
Toonen v. Australia (V) 488/1992 30 March 1994 Violation
J. A. M. B. R. v. The Netherlands (A) 477/1991 7 April 1994 Inadmissible
Neefs v. The Netherlands (V) 425/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Pepels v. The Netherlands (V) 484/1991 15 July 1994 No violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Debreczeny v. The Netherlands (V) 500/1992 3 April 1995 No violation
de Groot v. The Netherlands (A) 578/1994 14 July 1995 Inadmissible
Simunek et al. v. Czech Republic (V) 516/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Pons v. Spain (V) 454/1991 30 October 1995 No violation
Nahlik v. Austria (A) 608/1995 22 July 1996 Inadmissible
Somers v. Hungary (V) 566/1993 23 July 1996 No violation
Adam v. Czech Republic (V) 586/1994 23 July 1996 Violation
Drake et al . v. New Zealand (A) 601/1994 3 April 1997 Inadmissible
Drobek v. Slovakia (A) 643/1995 14 July 1997 Inadmissible
Oord v. The Netherlands (A) 658/1995 23 July 1997 Inadmissible
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Snijders et al. v. The Netherlands (V) 651/1995 27 July 1998 No violation
Hoofdman v. The Netherlands (V) 602/1994 3 November 1998 No violation
Pauger v. Austria (V) 716/1996 25 March 1999 Violation
Byrne and Lazarescu v. Canada (A) 742/1997 25 March 1999 Inadmissible
Vos. v. The Netherlands (V) 786/1997 26 July 1999 Violation
Foin v. France (V) 666/1995 3 November 1999 Violation
Waldman v. Canada (V) 694/1996 3 November 1999 Violation
Lestourneaud v. France (A) 861/1999 3 November 1999 Inadmissible
Maille v. France (V) 689/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Venier and Nicolas v. France (V) 690 & 691/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Gómez v. Spain (V) 701/1996 20 July 2000 Violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Toala et al. v. New Zealand (V) 675/1995 2 November 2000 No violation
Kavanagh v. Ireland (V) 819/1998 4 April 2001 Violation
Blazek et al. v. Czech Republic (V) 857/1999 12 July 2001 Violation
Schmitz-de-Jong v. The Netherlands (V) 855/1999 16 July 2001 No violation
Torregrosa Lafuente et al. v. Spain (A) 866/1999 16 July 2001 Inadmissible
Cheban v. Russian Federation (V) 790/1997 24 July 2001 No violation
Marín Gómez v. Spain (V) 865/1999 22 October 2001 No violation
Des Fours v. Czech Republic (V) 747/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Fábryová v. Czech Republic (V) 765/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Brok v. Czech Republic (V) 774/1997 31 October 2001 Violation
Müller and Engelhard v. Namibia (V) 919/2000 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Karakurt v. Austria (V) 965/2000 4 April 2002 Violation
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Gillot v. France (V) 932/2000 15 July 2002 No violation
Wackenheim v. France (V) 854/1999 15 July 2002 No violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
Pezoldova v. Czech Republic (V) 757/1997 25 October 2002 Violation
Love et. al. v. Australia (V) 983/2001 25 March 2003 No violation
Boboli v. Spain (A) 1013/2002 3 July 2003 Inadmissible
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Kristjánsson v. Iceland (A) 951/2000 16 July 2003 Inadmissible
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Hiro Balani v. Spain (A) 1021/2001 3 August 2003 Inadmissible
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Young v. Australia (V) 941/2000 6 August 2003 Violation
Sineiro Fernández v. Spain (V) 1007/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Althammer et al. v. Austria (V) 998/2001 8 August 2003 No violation
Hoyos v. Spain (A) 1008/2001 30 March 2004 Inadmissible
Barcaiztegui v. Spain (A) 1019/2001 30 March 2004 Inadmissible
Derksen v. The Netherlands (V) 976/2001 1 April 2004 Violation
Brandsma v. The Netherlands (A) 977/2001 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Petersen v. Germany (A) 1115/2002 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
G. Pohl et al. v. Austria (V) 1160/2003 9 July 2004 No Violation
Borzov v. Estonia (V) 1136/2002 26 July 2004 No Violation
Deisl v. Austria (V) 1060/2002 27 July 2004 No Violation
Chanderbali v. Austria (A) 944/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible
Jazairi v. Canada (A) 958/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible
Riedl-Riedenstein v. Germany (A) 1188/2003 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Mariano Gallego v. Spain (A) 988/2001 3 November 2004 Inadmissible
Terrón Jesús v. Spain (V) 1073/2002 5 November 2004 Violation
Olavi v. Finland 1076/2002 15 March 2005 No Violation
Radosevic v. Germany(A) 1292/2004 22 July 2005 Inadmissible
de Vos v. The Netherlands(A) 1192/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
Marik v. Czech Republic (V) 945/2000 26 July 2005 Violation
Immaculate Joseph et al. v. Sri Lanka 1249/2004 21 October 2005 Violation
Kříž v. Czech Republic (V) 1054/2002 1 November 2005 Violation
Jongenburger-Veerman v. The Netherlands (V) 1238/2004 1 November 2005 No Violation
Castell-Ruiz v. Spain (V) 1164/2003 17 March 2006 No Violation
Blaga v. Romania (V) 1158/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
X v. Colombia (V) 1361/2005 30 March 2007 Violation
Polacek v. Czech Republic (V) 1447/2006 24 July 2007 Violation
Haraldsson and Sveinsson v. Iceland (V) 1306/2004 24 October 2007 Violation
Gratzinger v. Czech Republic (V) 1463/2006 25 October 2007 Violation
Tsarjov v. Estonia (V) 1223/2003 26 October 2007 No Violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation
Zdenek and Ondracka v. Czech Republic (V) 1533/2006 31 October 2007 Violation
Schmidl v. Germany (A) 1516/2003 31 October 2007 Inadmissible
Lnenicka v. Czech Republic (V) 1484/2006 25 March 2008 Violation
Süsser v. Czech Republic (V) 1488/2006 25 March 2008 Violation
Šipin v. Estonia (V) 1423/2005 9 July 2008 No violation
Vlček v. Czech Republic (V) 1485/2006 10 July 2008 Violation
Kohoutek v. Czech Republic (V) 1448/2006 17 July 2008 Violation
Preiss v. Czech Republic (V) 1497/2006 17 July 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Amundson v. Czech Republic (V) 1508/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Vassilari et al. v. Greece (V) 1570/2007 19 March 2009 No violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Persan v. Czech Republic (V) 1479/2006 24 March 2009 Violation
Slezák v. Czech Republic (V) 1574/2007 20 July 2009 Violation
Williams Lecraft v. Spain (V) 1493/2006 27 July 2009 Violation
Dvorak v. Czech Republic (A) 1614/2007 28 July 2009 Inadmissible
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Gonçalves et al. v. Portugal (V) 1565/2007 18 March 2010 No violation
Zavrel v. Czech Republic (V) 1615/2007 27 July 2010 Violation
Wahlstatt v. Czech Republic 1491/2006 27 July 2010 Violation
Gschwind v Czech Republic 1742/2007 27 July 2010 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Machado Bartolomeu v. Portugal (V) 1783/2008 19 October 2010 No violation
Drda v. Czech Republic (V) 1581/2007 27 October 2010 Violation
Lange v. Czech Republic (V) 1586/2007 13 July 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Klain and Klain v. Czech Republic (V) 1847/2008 1 November 2011 Violation
Jünglingová v. Czech Republic (V) 1563/2007 24 October 2011 Violation
Albareda et. al v. Uruguay (V) 1637/2007,1757&1765/2008 24 October 2011 Violation
Nenova et al v. Libya (V) 1880/2009 20 March 2012 Violation
Katsaris v. Greece (V) 1558/2007 18 July 2012 Violation
Narrain et al v. Mauritius (V) 1744/2008 27 July 2012 Violation
M.B. v. Czech Republic (A) 1849/2008 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
Bulgakov v. Ukraine (V) 1803/2008 29 October 2012 Violation
M.N. et al. v. Tajikistan (A) 1500/2006 29 October 2012 Inadmissible
Naidenova et al v. Bulgaria (V) 2073/2011 30 October 2012 Violation
S.K. v. Belarus (A) 2169/2012 31 October 2012 Inadmissible
Fedotova v. Russian Federation (V) 1932/2010 31 October 2012 Violation
Singh v. France (V) 1852/2008 1 November 2012 Violation
Bakurov v. Russian Federation (V) 1861/2009 25 March 2013 No violation
Singh v. France (V) 1928/2010 19 July 2013 Violation
V.B. v. Czech Republic (A) 1809/2008 24 July 2013 Inadmissible
Turchenyak et al v. Belarus (V) 1948/2010 24 July 2013 Violation
Alekperov v. Russian Federation (V) 1764/2008 21 October 2013 No violation
Martinez et al. v. Algeria (A) 1922/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
Al-Gertani v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1955/2010 1 November 2013 Violation
Rizvanovic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 1997/2010 21 March 2014 Violation
T.W. and G.M. v. Slovak Republic (A) 1963/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Y.B. v. Russian Federation (A) 1983/2010 25 March 2014 Inadmissible
Paadar et al. v. Finland (V) 2102/2011 26 March 2014 No violation
Ory v. France (V) 1960/2010 28 March 2014 Violation
Hickey v. Australia (A) 2390/2014 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Aarass v. Spain (V) 2008/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
S.I.D. et al v. Bulgaria (A) 1926/2010 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Yachnik v. Belarus (A) 1990/2010 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Jum'a et al v. Libya (V) 1958/2010 21 July 2014 Violation
Huseynov v. Azerbaijan (A) 2042/2011 21 July 2014 Inadmissible
Ilyasov v. Kazakhstan (V) 2009/2010 23 July 2014 Violation
Koktish v. Belarus (V) 1985/2010 24 July 2014 Violation
D’Amore v. Argentina (A) 2071/2011 24 July 2014 Inadmissible
Vojnovic v. Croatia (A) 2068/2011 10 October 2014 Inadmissible
Bolivar v. Venezuela (V) 2085/2011 16 October 2014 Violation
Monika v. Cameroon (V) 1965/2010 21 October 2014 Violation
Leven v. Kazakhstan (V) 2131/2012 21 October 2014 No violation
X. v. Denmark (V) 2186/2012 22 October 2014 Violation
Chaulagain v. Nepal (V) 2018/2010 28 October 2014 Violation
Kerouane v. Algeria (V) 2132/2012 30 October 2014 Violation
Kozlov et al v. Belarus (V) 1949/2010 25 March 2015 Violation
Leghaei v. Australia (V) 1937/2010 26 March 2015 Violation
X. v. Denmark (A) 2515/2014 1 April 2015 Inadmissible
Q v. Denmark (V) 2001/2010 1 April 2015 Violation
B. & C. v. Czech Republic (A) 1967/2010 2 April 2015 Inadmissible
X. v. Czech Republic (A) 1961/2010 2 April 2015 Inadmissible
Fa'afete v. New Zealand (A) 1909/2009 13 July 2015 Inadmissible
V.M. v. Russian Federation (V) 2043/2011 15 July 2015 No violation
Surgan v. Belarus (V) 1969/2010 15 July 2015 Violation
X v. Denmark (V) 2389/2014 22 July 2015 Violation
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
J.N.G.P v. Uruguay (V) 2395/2014 23 July 2015 No violation
M.T. v. Uzbekistan (V) 2234/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
G.C.A.A. v. Uruguay (A) 2358/2014 2 November 2015 Inadmissible
Kadiric v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (V) 2048/2011 5 November 2015 Violation
X v. Canada (V) 2366/2014 5 November 2015 No violation
Z v. Australia (V) 2279/2013 5 November 2015 Violation
Z v. Denmark (V) 2422/2014 11 March 2016 No violation
Mellet v. Ireland (V) 2324/2013 31 March 2016 Violation
Mohamed Rabbae v. Netherlands (V) 2124/2011 14 July 2016 No violation
Bazarov v. Kyrgyzstan(V) 2187/2012 21 October 2016 Violation
X. and Y. v. Canada (A) 2771/2016 3 November 2016 Inadmissible
A.P.J. v. Denmark (V) 2253/2013 16 March 2017 No violation
F. A. H. v. Colombia (A) 2121/2011 28 March 2017 Inadmissible
S.Sh. v. Kazakhstan (A) 2324/2013 28 March 2017 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 27

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)
30 July 1981 Violation
Kitok v. Sweden (V) 197/1985 27 July 1988 No violation
T.K. v. France (A) 220/1987 8 November 1989 Inadmissible
M.K. v. France (A) 222/1987 8 November 1989 Inadmissible
Lubicon Lake Band v.Canada (V) 167/1984 26 March 1990 Violation
Ballantyne, Davidson and McIntyre v. Canada (V) 359 &385/1989 31 March 1993 Violation
Sara et al. v. Finland (A) 431/1990 23 March 1994 Inadmissible
Länsman et al. v. Finland (V) 511/1992 26 October 1994 No violation
Länsman et al. v. Finland (V) 671/1995 30 October 1996 No violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Mahuika et al. v. New Zealand (V) 547/1993 27 October 2000 No violation
Äärelä and Näkkäläjärvi v. Finland (V) 779/1997 24 October 2001 Violation
Länsman III v. Finland (V) 1023/2001 17 March 2005 No violation
Howard v. Canada (V) 879/1999 26 July 2005 No violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation
Mavlonov and Sa’di v. Uzbekistan (V) 1334/2004 19 March 2009 Violation
Poma v. Peru (V) 1457/2006 27 March 2009 Violation
Georgopoulos et al. v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation
Bulgakov v. Ukraine (V) 1803/2008 29 October 2012 Violation
Martinez et al. v. Algeria (A) 1922/2009 28 October 2013 Inadmissible
A.W.P v. Denmark (A) 1879/2009 1 November 2013 Inadmissible
Paadar et al. v. Finland (V) 2102/2011 26 March 2014 No violation
Omo-Amenaghawon v. Denmark/Nigeria (V) 2288/2013 23 July 2015 Violation
Mohamed Rabbae v. Netherlands (V) 2124/2011 14 July 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 50

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977(R.7/27) 29 October 1981 Violation
Jazairi v. Canada (A) 958/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible
Minogue v. Australia (A) 954/2000 2 November 2004 Inadmissible