The United Nations Human Rights Treaties


Home

Introduction

Text of the Treaties

Amendments to the Treaties

Documents

 BY STATE

 BY CATEGORY

 BY THEME OR SUBJECT MATTER

How to Complain About
 Human Rights Treaty Violations

Working Methods of the Treaty Bodies

Reform of the UN Human Rights
 Treaty System

About Bayefsky.com

PORTAL to UN human rights treaty information

Feedback? Suggestions? Contact us


Can't find what you're looking for?
See "By Theme or Subject Matter".

To link to this site, please contact us


How To Complain About Human Rights Treaty Violations

Index of Cases of CCPR by Article

Printer-friendly version

for cases by state party see Jurisprudence
to update generally see jurisprudence at: http://www.unhchr.ch/tbs/doc.nsf
A= admissibility decision
DC= discontinued cases
DJ= decision to deal with cases jointly
I= interim measures
V= views


ARTICLE 1


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lubicon Lake Band v.Canada (V) 167/1984 26 March 1990 Violation
E.P. et al. v. Colombia (A) 318/1988 25 July 1990 Inadmissible
A.B. et al. v. Italy (A) 413/1990 2 November 1990 Inadmissible
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus (V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Wilson v. Australia (A) 1239/2004 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation


ARTICLE 1(2)



Šroub v. Czech Republic (A) 1573/2007 27 October 2009 Inadmissible




ARTICLE 2



Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)		 30 July 1981 Violation
Stalla Costa v. Uruguay (V) 198/1985 9 July 1987 No violation
Nahlik v. Austria (A) 608/1995 22 July 1996 Inadmissible
Drobek v. Slovakia (A) 643/1995 14 July 1997 Inadmissible
Lestourneaud v. France (A) 861/1999 3 November 1999 Inadmissible
Ignatane v. Latvia (V) 884/1999 25 July 2001 Violation
Mazou v. Cameroon (V) 630/1995 26 July 2001 Violation
Äärelä and Näkkäläjärvi v. Finland (V) 779/1997 24 October 2001 Violation
Des Fours v. Czech Republic (V) 747/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Brok v. Czech Republic (V) 774/1997 31 October 2001 Violation
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo(V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Patera v. Czech Republic (V) 946/2000 25 July 2002 Violation
Pezoldova v. Czech Republic (V) 757/1997 25 October 2002 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus (V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Veriter v. France (A) 1088/2002 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Zheikov v. Russian Federation(V) 889/1999 17 March 2006 Violation
Sinitsin v. Belarus (V) 1047/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Alzery v. Sweden (V) 1416/2005 25 October 2006 Violation
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
Mavlonov and Sa’di v. Uzbekistan (V) 1334/2004 19 March 2009 Violation
Vassilari et al. v. Greece (V) 1570/2007 19 March 2009 No violation
Munaf v. Romania (V) 1539/2006 30 July 2009 No violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Eshonov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1225/2003 22 July 2010 Violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 2(1)



Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Toonen v. Australia (V) 488/1992 30 March 1994 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation
Arenz v. Germany (A) 1138/2002 24 March 2004 Inadmissible
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Solís v. Peru (V) 1016/2001 27 March 2006 No Violation
Tsarjov v. Estonia (V) 1223/2003 26 October 2007 No Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Munaf v. Romania (V) 1539/2006 30 July 2009 No violation
Hamida v. Canada (V) 1544/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation


ARTICLE 2(2)



Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation


ARTICLE 2(3)



Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Fanali v. Italy (V) 75/1980 31 March 1983 No violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Rodrínez Veiga v.Uruguay (A) 487/1992 18 July 1994 Inadmissible
Rodríguez v. Uruguay (V) 322/1988 19 July 1994 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Weiss v. Austria (V) 1086/2002 3 April 2003 Violation
Chambala v. Zambia (V) 856/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Kankanamge v. Sri Lanka (V) 909/2000 27 July 2004 Violation
Czernin v. Czech Republic (V) 823/1998 29 March 2005 Violation
Faure v.Australia (V) 1036/2001 31 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Blaga v. Romania (V) 1158/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Boucherf v. Algeria (V) 1196/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
Pimentel v. Philippines (V) 1320/2004 19 March 2007 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Shams et al. v. Australia (V) 1255,1256,
1259,1260,
1266,1268,
1270,1288/2004		 20 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Banda v. Sri Lanka (V) 1426/2005 26 October 2007 Violation
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Kalamiotis v. Greece (V) 1486/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Umetaliev and Tashtanbekova v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1275/2004 30 October 2008 Violation
Marcellana and Gumanoy v. The Philippines (V) 1560/2007 30 October 2008 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Poma v. Peru (V) 1457/2006 27 March 2009 Violation
Amirov and Amirova v. Russian Federation (V) 1447/2006 2 April 2009 Violation
Williams Lecraft v. Spain (V) 1493/2006 27 July 2009 Violation
Dumont v. Canada (V) 1467/2006 16 March 2010 Violation
Pestaño v. Philippines (V) 1619/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Gonzalez v. Republic of Guyana (V) 1246/2004 25 March 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Hernandez v. Philippines 1559/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Georgopoulos et al. v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Novaković v. Republic of Serbia (V) 1556/2007 21 October 2010 Violation
Avadanov v. Azerbaijan (V) 1633/2007 25 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
McCallum v. South Africa (V) 1818/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Sechremelis et al. v. Greece 1507/2006 25 October 2010 No violation
González v. Argentina (V)

 1458/2006 17 March 2011 Violation
Yevdokimov and Rezanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1410/2005 21 March 2011 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Zyuskin v. Russian Federation (V) 1605/2007 19 July 2011 Violation
Zhumbaeva and Moidunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1756/2008 19 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation

 
 
 
ARTICLE 2(3)(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Agabekova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1071/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Vlček v. Czech Republic (V) 1485/2006 10 July 2008 Violation
Kohoutek v. Czech Republic (V) 1448/2006 17 Juy 2008 Violation
Preiss v. Czech Republic (V) 1497/2006 17 Juy 2008 Violation
Aboushanif v. Norway (V) 1542/2007 17 Juy 2008 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 Juy 2008 Violation
Bandaranayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1376/2005 24 July 2008 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Amundson v. Czech Republic (V) 1508/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Isaev and Karimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1163/2003 20 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Tornel et al. v. Spain (V) 1473/2006 20 March 2009 Violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Reshetnikov v. Russian Federation (V) 1278/2004 23 March 2009 Violation
Persan v. Czech Republic (V) 1479/2006 24 March 2009 Violation
Asensi v. Paraguay 1407/2005 27 March 2009 Violation
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Sattorov v. Tajikistan (V) 1200/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Uclés v. Spain (V) 1364/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Kibaya v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1483/2006 30 July 2009 Violation
Batyrov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1585/2007 30 July 2009 Violation
Slezák v. Czech Republic (V) 1574/2007 20 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Martínez v. Spain (V) 1363/2005 19 October 2009 Violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Lukyanchik v. Belarus (V) 1392/2005 21 October 2009 Violation
Khostikoev v. Tajikistan (V) 1519/2006 22 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Latifulin v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1312/2004 10 March 2010 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Kaldarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1338/2005 18 March 2010 Violation
Hamida v. Canada (V) 1544/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Gapirjanov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1589/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Guerra de la Espriella v. Colombia (V) 1623/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Tillman v. Australia (V) 1635/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Jung et al. v. Republic of Korea (V) 1593-1603/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pestaño v. Philippines (V) 1619/2007 23 March 2010 Violation


ARTICLE 2(3)(b)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Goyet v. France (A) 1746/2008 30 October 2008 Inadmissible

 
ARTICLE 2(3)(c)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kibaya v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1483/2006 30 July 2009 Violation

 
ARTICLE 3


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)		 30 July 1981 Violation
Avellanal v. Peru (V) 202/1986 28 October 1988 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
A.A.C. v. Sweden (V) 277/2003 16 November 2006 No Violation
Tebourski v. France (V) 300/2006 1 May 2007 Violation
C.A.R.M. et al. v. Canada (V) 298/2006 18 May 2007 No violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 4


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation

ARTICLE 5


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
M.A. v. Italy (A) 117/1981 10 April 1984 Inadmissible


ARTICLE 6


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Miango v. Zaire (V) 194/1985 27 October 1987 Violation
Herrera v. Colombia (V) 161/1983 2 November 1987 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Arévalo v. Colombia (V) 181/1984 3 November 1989 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Little v. Jamaica (V) 283/1988 1 November 1991 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Simmonds v. Jamaica (V) 338/1988 23 October 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 307/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Kindler v. Canada (V) 470/1991 30 July 1993 No violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 333/1988 23 March 1994 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Champagnie et. al v. Jamaica (V) 445/1991 18 July 1994 Violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 &482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Piandiong et al. v. Philippines (V) 869/1999 19 October 2000 No violation
Mansaraj et al. v. Sierra Leone (V) 839, 840 &841/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Sahadath v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 684/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Sarma v. Sri Lanka (V) 950/2000 16 July 2003 Violation
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Aliev v. Ukraine (V) 781/1997 07 August 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 november 2003 Violation
Arutyunyan v. Uzbekistan (V) 917/2000 29 March 2004 Violation
Smartt v. Republic of Guyana (V) 867/1999 6 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Mulai v. Republic of Guyana (V) 811/1998 20 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation
Celal v. Greece (A) 1235/2003 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Siragev v. Uzbekistan (V) 907/2000 1 November 2005 Violation
Hussain and Hussain v. Guyana (V) 862/1999 25 October 2005 Violation
Chan v. Guyana (V) 913/2000 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
Khan v. Canada (A) 1302/2004 25 July 2006 Inadmissible
Brun v. France (A) 1453/2006 18 October 2006 Inadmissible
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Yakupova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1205/2003 3 April 2008 No violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Kaur v. Canada (A) 1455/2006 30 October 2008 Inadmissible
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Amirov and Amirova v. Russian Federation (V) 1447/2006 2 April 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Kwok v. Australia (V) 1442/2005 23 October 2009 Violation
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Pestaño v. Philippines (V) 1619/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Novaković v. Republic of Serbia (V) 1556/2007 21 October 2010 Violation
Hernandez v. Philippines 1559/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 6(1)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
de Guerrero v. Colombia (V) 45/1979
(R.11/45)		 31 March 1982 Violation
Baboeram et al. v. Suriname (V) 146 & 148-154/1983 4 April 1985 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
Mojica v. Dominican Republic (V) 449/1991 15 July 1994 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Thompson v. Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (V) 806/1998 18 October 2000 Violation
Chongwe v. Zambia (V) 821/1998 25 October 2000 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation
Lantsova v. Russian Federation (V) 763/1997 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
Carpo et al. v. Philippines (V) 1077/2002 28 March 2003 Violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Telitsin v. Russian Federation (V) 888/1999 29 March 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Hussain and Hussain v. Guyana (V) 862/1999 25 October 2005 Violation
Persaud v. Guyana (V) 812/1998 21 March 2006 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Umetaliev and Tashtanbekova v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1275/2004 30 October 2008 Violation
Marcellana and Gumanoy v. The Philippines (V) 1560/2007 30 October 2008 Violation
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Tornel et al. v. Spain (V) 1473/2006 20 March 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Eshonov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1225/2003 22 July 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Hernandez v. Philippines 1559/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
González v. Argentina (V)

 1458/2006 17 March 2011 Violation
Zhumbaeva and Moidunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1756/2008 19 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 6(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v.Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Judge v. Canada (V) 829/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V) 985/2001 18 October 2005 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Strakhov and Fayzullaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1017/2001 and 1066/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Tulyaganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1041/2001 20 July 2007 Violation
Khudayberganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1140/2002 24 July 2007 Violation
Uteeva v. Uzbekistan (V) 1150/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation

ARTICLE 6(4)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation

ARTICLE 6(5)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
C. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 592/1994 20 October 1998 Violation

ARTICLE 7


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)		 23 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)		 28 October 1981 Violation
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)		 26 July 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Larrosa v. Uruguay (V) 88/1981 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Quinteros v. Uruguay (V) 107/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
M. F. v. The Netherlands (A) 173/1984 2 November 1984 Inadmissible
Wight v. Madagascar (V) 115/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Arzuada v. Uruguay (V) 147/1983 1 November 1985 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Miango v. Zaire (V) 194/1985 27 October 1987 Violation
Herrera v. Colombia (V) 161/1983 2 November 1987 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Acosta v. Uruguay (V) 162/1983 25 October 1988 Violation
J.H. v. Finland (A) 300/1988 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
R.M. v. Finland (A) 301/1988 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Torres v. Finland (V) 291/1988 2 April 1990 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
García v. Ecuador (V) 319/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Prince v. Jamaica (V) 269/1987 30 March 1992 No violation
Barrett and Sutcliffe v. Jamaica (V) 270 & 271/1988 30 March 1992 Violation
Ellis v. Jamaica (V) 276/1988 28 July 1992 No violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Griffiths v. Jamaica (V) 274/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Martin v. Jamaica (V) 317/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 334/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Soogrim v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 362/1989 8 April 1993 Violation
Kindler v. Canada (V) 470/1991 30 July 1993 No violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 321/1988 19 October 1993 Violation
Kanana v. Zaire (V) 366/1989 2 November 1993 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
El-Megreisi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 440/1990 23 March 1994 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 407/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mojica v. Dominican Republic (V) 449/1991 15 July 1994 Violation
Rodríguez v. Uruguay (V) 322/1988 19 July 1994 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Simms v. Jamaica (A) 541/1993 3 April 1995 Inadmissible
Rogers v. Jamaica (A) 494/1992 4 April 1995 Inadmissible
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
Chaplin v. Jamaica (V) 596/1994 2 November 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Tshishimbi v. Zaire (V) 542/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 512/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 600/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Spence v. Jamaica (V) 599/1994 18 July 1996 Violation
Sterling v. Jamaica (V) 598/1994 22 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Canepa v. Canada (V) 558/1993 3 April 1997 No violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 587/1994 3 April 1997 Violation
Ortega v. Ecuador (V) 481/1991 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Edwards v. Jamaica (V) 529/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Singh v. Canada (A) 761/1997 29 July 1997 Inadmissible
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Bickaroo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 555/1993 29 October 1997 No violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 609/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Young v. Jamaica (V) 615/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggart v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Daley v.Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
C. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 592/1994 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Colin Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 653/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Henry v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 752/1997 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Osbourne v. Jamaica (V) 759/1997 15 March 2000 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Thompson v. Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (V) 806/1998 18 October 2000 Violation
Jensen v. Australia (A) 762/1997 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Rojas García v. Colombia (V) 687/1996 3 April 2001 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Higginson v. Jamaica (V) 792/1998 28 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Sahadath v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 684/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
C. v. Australia (V) 900/1999 28 October 2002 Violation
Van Grinsven. v. The Netherlands(A) 1142/2002 27 March 2003 Inadmissible
Banderenko v. Belarus (V) 886/1999 3 April 2003 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Belarus (V) 887/1999 3 April 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Sarma v. Sri Lanka (V) 950/2000 16 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Cabal and Pasini v. Australia (V) 1020/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Pryce v. Jamaica (V) 793/1998 15 March 2004 Violation
Telitsin v. Russian Federation (V) 888/1999 29 March 2004 Violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Byahuranga v. Denmark (V) 1222/2003 1 November 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines (V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V) 985/2001 18 October 2005 Violation
Chisanga v. Zambia (V) 1132/2002 18 October 2005 Violation
Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V) 1042/2001 20 October 2005 Violation
Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V) 1058/2002 26 October 2005 Violation
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Siragev v. Uzbekistan (V) 907/2000 1 November 2005 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Zheikov v. Russian Federation(V) 889/1999 17 March 2006 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Persaud v. Guyana (V) 812/1998 21 March 2006 Violation
Kouidis v. Greece (V) 1070/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Sankara v. Burkina Faso (V) 1159/2003 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Boucherf v. Algeria (V) 1196/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Khan v. Canada (A) 1302/2004 25 July 2006 Inadmissible
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Alzery v. Sweden (V) 1416/2005 25 October 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Agabekova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1071/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Obodzinsky v. Canada (V) 1124/2002 19 March 2007 No violationn
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violationn
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violationn
P.K. v. Canada (A) 1234/2003 1234/2003 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violationn
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Strakhov and Fayzullaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1017/2001 and 1066/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Tulyaganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1041/2001 20 July 2007 Violation
Khudayberganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1140/2002 24 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Banda v. Sri Lanka (V) 1426/2005 26 October 2007 Violation
Uteeva v. Uzbekistan (V) 1150/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
A., B., C., D. and E. v. Australia (A) 1429/2005 1 April 2008 Inadmissible
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Chadzjian and Barsgian v. The Netherlands (A) 1494/2006 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 Juy 2008 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Kalamiotis v. Greece (V) 1486/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Kaur v. Canada (A) 1455/2006 30 October 2008 Inadmissible
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Isaev and Karimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1163/2003 20 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Tarlue v. Canada (A) 1551/2007 27 March 2009 Inadmissible
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Sattorov v. Tajikistan (V) 1200/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Amirov and Amirova v. Russian Federation (V) 1447/2006 2 April 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Kibaya v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1483/2006 30 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Kwok v. Australia (V) 1442/2005 23 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Hamida v. Canada (V) 1544/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Gapirjanov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1589/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kaba v. Canada (V) 1465/2006 25 March 2010 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
Eshonov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1225/2003 22 July 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Avadanov v. Azerbaijan (V) 1633/2007 25 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
McCallum v. South Africa (V) 1818/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
Pillai et al. v. Canada 1763/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Zyuskin v. Russian Federation (V) 1605/2007 19 July 2011 Violation
Zhumbaeva and Moidunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1756/2008 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation
X. H. L. v. Netherlands 1564/2007 22 July 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 8


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Järvinen v. Finland (V) 295/1988 25 July 1990 No violation
Maille v. France (V) 689/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Venier and Nicolas v. France (V) 690 & 691/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Van Grinsven. v. The Netherlands(A) 1142/2002 27 March 2003 Inadmissible
Radosevic v. Germany (A) 1292/2004 22 July 2005 Inadmissible
Faure v.Australia (V) 1036/2001 31 October 2005 Violation


ARTICLE 9


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Quinteros v. Uruguay (V) 107/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
J.R.C. v. Costa Rica (A) 296/1988 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Arévalo v. Colombia (V) 181/1984 3 November 1989 Violation
van Alphen v. The Netherlands (V) 305/1988 23 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
García v. Ecuador (V) 319/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
El-Megreisi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 440/1990 23 March 1994 Violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
G.T. v. Australia (V) 706/1996 4 November 1997 No violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Jalloh v. The Netherlands (V) 794/1998 26 March 2002 No violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
Sarma v. Sri Lanka (V) 950/2000 16 July 2003 Violation

Rameka v. New Zealand(V)

1090/2002

6 November 2003

Violation

Madafferi v. Australia (V)

1011/2001

26 July 2004

Violation

Fijalkowska v. Poland (V)

1061/2002

26 July 2004

Violation
Jorge Luis Quispe Roque v. Peru (V) 1125/2002 21 October 2005 Violation
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Boucherf v. Algeria (V) 1196/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
Shafiq v. Australia (V) 1324/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
El Alwani v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1295/2004 11 July 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
A., B., C., D. and E. v. Australia (A) 1429/2005 1 April 2008 Inadmissible
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Mamour v. Central African Republic (V) 1587/2007 20 July 2009 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Rastorguev v. Poland (V)

 1517/2006 28 March 2011 Violation



ARTICLE 9(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)		 23 July 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)		 26 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Jaona v. Madagascar (V) 132/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Kanana v. Zaire (V) 366/1989 2 November 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mojica v. Dominican Republic (V) 449/1991 15 July 1994 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Colamarco v. Panama (A) 437/1990 21 October 1994 Inadmissible
Thompson v. Panama (A) 438/1990 21 October 1994 Inadmissible
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Baustista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Tshishimbi v. Zaire (V) 542/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423, & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
A v. New Zealand (V) 754/1997 15 July 1999 No violation
Spakmo v. Norway (V) 631/1995 5 November 1999 Violation
Dias v. Angola (V) 711/1996 20 March 2000 Violation
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Chongwe v. Zambia (V) 821/1998 25 October 2000 Violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation
Jayawardena v. Sri Lanka (V) 916/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
C. v. Australia (V) 900/1999 28 October 2002 Violation
Chambala v. Zambia (V) 856/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Baban et al. v. Australia (V) 1014/2001 6 August 2003 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Everett v. Spain (A) 961/2000 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Fernando v. Sri Lanka (V) 1189/2003 31 March 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines (V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Fijalkowska v. Poland (V) 1061/2002 26 July 2005 Violation
Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V) 1058/2002 26 October 2005 Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Sankara v. Burkina Faso (V) 1159/2003 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
D. and E. v. Australia (V) 1050/2002 11 July 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
Shafiq v. Australia (V) 1324/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Zundel v. Canada (A) 1341/2005 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Shams et al. v. Australia (V) 1255,1256,
1259,1260,
1266,1268,
1270,1288/2004		 20 July 2007 Violation
Manuel v. New Zealand (V) 1385/2005 18 October 2007 No Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Maksudov et al. v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1461/2006, 1462/2006, 1476/2006 and 1477/2006 16 July 2008 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Marcellana and Gumanoy v. The Philippines (V) 1560/2007 30 October 2008 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Castro v. Spain (V) 1388/2005 19 March 2009 No violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Kwok v. Australia (V) 1442/2005 23 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Latifulin v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1312/2004 10 March 2010 Violation
Tillman v. Australia (V) 1635/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Fardon v. Australia (V) 1629/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 9(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Borda et al. v. Colombia (V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)		 27 July 1982 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Jaona v. Madagascar (V) 132/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1997 30 March 1992 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Thompson v. Panama (A) 438/1990 21 October 1994 Inadmissible
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 597/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1988 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1988 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
Zheludkov v. Ukraine (V) 726/1996 29 October 2002 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Latifulin v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1312/2004 10 March 2010 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V)

 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 9(3)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977 (R.1/5) 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)		 28 October 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Borda et al. v. Colombia(V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)		 27 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 &242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
W. B. E. v. The Netherlands (A) 432/1990 23 October 1992 Inadmissible
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Koné v. Senegal (V) 386/1989 21 October 1994 Violation
Shalto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 447/1991 4 April 1995 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Kulomin v. Hungary (V) 521/1992 22 March 1996 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 597/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Elahie v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 533/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Smart v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 672/1995 29 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1988 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 616/1995 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Zheludkov v. Ukraine (V) 726/1996 29 October 2002 Violation
Evans v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 908/2000 21 March 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Lobban v. Jamaica (V) 797/1998 16 March 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Nazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 911/2000 6 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation

Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1042/2001

20 October 2005

Violation

Platonov v. Russian Federation (V)

1218/2003

1 November 2005

Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan (V) 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Rajapakse v. Sri Lanka (V) 1250/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Smantser v. Belarus (V) 1178/2003 23 October 2008 Violation
Reshetnikov v. Russian Federation (V) 1278/2004 23 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Kaldarov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1338/2005 18 March 2010 Violation
Gapirjanov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1589/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Peirano Basso v. Uruguay (V) 1887/2009 19 October 2010 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V)

 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 9(4)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Valcada v. Uruguay (V) 9/1977 26 October 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)		 23 July 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)		 26 July 1982 Violation
Borda et al. v. Colombia (V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)		 27 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Hammel v. Madagascar (V) 155/1983 3 April 1987 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Torres v. Finland (V) 291/1988 2 April 1990 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 597/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
A v. New Zealand (V) 754/1997 15 July 1999 No violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
C. v. Australia (V) 900/1999 28 October 2002 Violation
Baban et al. v. Australia (V) 1014/2001 6 August 2003 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation

Rameka v. New Zealand(V)

1090/2002

6 November 2003

Violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Fijalkowska v. Poland (V) 1061/2002 26 July 2005 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Wenga and Shandwe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 1177/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Bouroual v. Algeria (V) 992/2001 30 March 2006 Violation
Shafiq v. Australia (V) 1324/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Shams et al. v. Australia (V) 1255,1256,
1259,1260,
1266,1268,
1270,1288/2004		 20 July 2007 Violation
Titiahonjo v. Cameroon (V) 1186/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 9(5)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423 & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
Uebergang v. Australia (A) 963/2001 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Chambala v. Zambia (V) 856/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Fijalkowska v. Poland (V) 1061/2002 26 July 2005 Violation

ARTICLE 10


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Párkányi v. Hungary (V) 410/1990 27 July 1992 Violation
Ng v. Canada (V) 469/1991 5 November 1993 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Rogers v. Jamaica (A) 494/1992 4 April 1995 Inadmissible
Kulomin v. Hungary (V) 521/1992 22 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Chanderbali v. Austria (A) 944/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible

Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V)

1126/2002

28 October 2005

Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2006 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Sharma v. Nepal (V) 1469/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 10(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)		 23 July 1980 Violation
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
de Bouton v. Uruguay (V) 37/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)		 28 October 1981 Violation
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)		 29 October 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Bleier v. Uruguay (V) 30/1978
(R.7/30)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Masslotti and Baritussio v. Uruguay (V) 25/1978
(R.6/25)		 26 July 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Larrosa v. Uruguay (V) 88/1981 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Luyeye v. Zaire (V) 90/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Estradet v. Uruguay (V) 105/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Quinteros v. Uruguay (V) 107/1981 21 July 1983 Violation
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Machado v. Uruguay (V) 83/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Romero v. Uruguay (V) 85/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Manera v. Uruguay (V) 123/1982 6 April 1984 Violation
de Voituret v. Uruguay (V) 109/1981 10 April 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Wight v. Madagascar (V) 115/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Arzuada v. Uruguay (V) 147/1983 1 November 1985 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Herrera v. Colombia (V) 161/1983 2 November 1987 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Portorreal v. Dominican Republic (V) 188/1984 5 November 1987 Violation
Acosta v. Uruguay (V) 162/1983 25 October 1988 Violation
Vuolanne v. Finland (V) 265/1987 7 April 1989 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1998 26 March 1992 Violation
Barrett and Sutcliffe v. Jamaica (V) 270 & 271/1988 30 March 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 334/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Soogrim v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 362/1989 8 April 1993 Violation
Orihuela v. Peru (V) 309/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 321/1988 19 October 1993 Violation
Kanana v. Zaire (V) 366/1989 2 November 1993 Violation
El-Megreisi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 440/1990 23 March 1994 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 407/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Mika Miha v Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Chaplin v. Jamaica (V) 596/1994 2 November 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 512/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Hylton v. Jamaica (V) 600/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Spence v. Jamaica (V) 599/1994 18 July 1996 Violation
Sterling v. Jamaica (V) 598/1994 22 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 587/1994 3 April 1997 Violation
Ortega v. Ecuador (V) 481/1991 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Edwards v. Jamaica (V) 529/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Elahie v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 533/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Bickaroo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 555/1993 29 October 1997 No violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 609/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Matthews v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 569/1993 31 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Colin Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 653/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Henry v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 752/1997 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 616/1995 23 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Freemantle v. Jamaica (V) 625/1995 24 March 2000 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Thompson v. Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (V) 806/1998 18 October 2000 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Simpson v. Jamaica (V) 695/1996 31 October 2001 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Lantsova v. Russian Federation (V) 763/1997 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Sahadath v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 684/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Zheludkov v. Ukraine (V) 726/1996 29 October 2002 Violation
Evans v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 908/2000 21 March 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Cabal and Pasini v. Australia (V) 1020/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation

Rameka v. New Zealand(V)

1090/2002

6 November 2003

Violation

Telitsin v. Russian Federation (V)

888/1999

29 March 2004

Violation

Lobban v. Jamaica (V)

797/1998

16 March 2004

Violation

Arutyunyan v. Uzbekistan (V)

917/2000

29 March 2004

Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V) 973/2001 30 March 2005 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation

Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V)

1058/2002

26 October 2005

Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Aber v. Algeria (V) 1439/2005 13 July 2007 Violation
El Hassy v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1422/2005 24 October 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Weerawansa v. Sri Lanka (V) 1406/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1776/2008 20 October 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
McCallum v. South Africa (V) 1818/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Bozbey v. Turkmenistan (V) 1530/2006 27 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation
Giri v. Nepal (V) 1761/2008 24 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 10(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)		 29 October 1981 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1998 26 March 1992 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
D. Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 800/1998 8 April 1999 Violation
Wilson v. The Philippines (V) 868/1999 30 October 2003 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 10(2)(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Cabal and Pasini v. Australia (V) 1020/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Minogue v. Australia (A) 954/2000 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation

ARTICLE 10(2)(b)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 10(3)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
D. Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 800/1998 8 April 1999 Violation
Jensen v. Australia (A) 762/1997 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation

ARTICLE 11

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Seto Martinez v. Spain (A) 1624/2007 19 March 2010 Inadmissible


ARTICLE 11(2)(b)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Nguyen v. the Netherlands 3/2004 14 August 2006 No violation

ARTICLE 12


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)		 30 July 1981 Violation
Nunez v. Uruguay (V) 108/1981 22 July 1983 Violation
Gillot v. France (V) 932/2000 15 July 2002 No violation

Randolph v. Togo (V)

910/2000

27 October 2003

No violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation

ARTICLE 12(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Celepli v. Sweden (V) 456/1991 18 July 1994 No violation
Ackla v. Togo (V) 505/1992 25 March 1996 Violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation
El Ghar v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1107/2002 2 November 2004 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation

ARTICLE 12(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Martins v. Uruguay (V) 57/1979
(R.13/57)		 23 March 1982 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Lichtensztejn v. Uruguay (V) 77/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Montero v. Uruguay (V) 106/1981 31 March 1983 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Peltonen v. Finland (V) 492/1992 21 July 1994 No violation
El Ghar v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1107/2002 2 November 2004 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Batyrov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1585/2007 30 July 2009 Violation

ARTICLE 12(3)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Celepli v. Sweden (V) 456/1991 18 July 1994 No violation
Peltonen v. Finland (V) 492/1992 21 July 1994 No violation
Ackla v. Togo (V) 505/1992 25 March 1996 Violation
Karker v. France (V) 833/1998 26 October 2000 No violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Batyrov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1585/2007 30 July 2009 Violation

ARTICLE 12(4)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Stewart v. Canada (V) 538/1993 1 November 1996 12(4), 17, 23 No violation
Canepa v. Canada (V) 558/1993 3 April 1997 7, 12(4), 17, 23 No violation
Toala et al. v. New Zealand (V) 675/1995 2 November 2000 12(4), 26 No violation
Jiménez Vaca v. Colombia (V) 859/1999 25 March 2002 Violation  
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation  
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 13


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Maroufidou v. Sweden (V) 58/1979
(R.13/58)		 9 April 1981 No violation
Hammel v. Madagascar (V) 155/1983 3 April 1987 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Giry v. Dominican Republic (V) 193/1985 20 July 1990 Violation
García v. Ecuador (V) 319/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Sohn v. Republic of Korea (V) 518/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Karker v. France (V) 833/1998 26 October 2000 No violation
Ahani v. Canada (V) 1051/2002 29 March 2004 Violation
Elahi v. Switzerland (V) 222/2002 3 May 2005 No Violation
Alzery v. Sweden (V) 1416/2005 25 October 2006 Violation

ARTICLE 14


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Borda et al. v. Colombia (V) 46/1979
(R.11/46)		 27 July 1982 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
J.H. v. Finland (A) 300/1998 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
R.M. v. Finland (A) 301/1998 23 March 1989 Inadmissible
B.d.B. et al. v. The Netherlands (A) 273/1989 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
J.R.C. v. Costa Rica (A) 296/1988 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Little v. Jamaica (V) 283/1988 1 November 1991 Violation
Barrett and Sutcliffe v. Jamaica (V) 270 & 271/1988 30 March 1992 Violation
Ellis v. Jamaica (V) 276/1988 28 July 1992 No violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Perera v. Australia (A) 536/1993 28 March 1995 Inadmissible
Simms v. Jamaica (A) 541/1993 3 April 1995 Inadmissible
de Groot v. The Netherlands (A) 578/1994 14 July 1995 Inadmissible
Bullock v. Trinidad and Tobago (A) 553/1993 19 July 1995 Inadmissible
Marriot v. Jamaica (V) 519/1992 27 October 1995 Violation
Kulomin v. Hungary (V) 521/1992 22 March 1996 Violation
Arhuaco v. Colombia (V) 612/1995 29 July 1997 Violation
Singh v. Canada (A) 761/1997 29 July 1997 Inadmissible
Perel v. Latvia (V) 650/1995 30 March 1998 No violation
Ajaz and Jamil v. Republic of Korea (V) 644/1995 13 July 1999 No violation
Hankle v. Jamaica (V) 710/1996 28 July 1999 No violation
G. v. Canada (A) 934/2000 17 July 2000 Inadmissible
Piandiong et al. v. Philippines (V) 869/1999 19 October 2000 No violation
Rogl v. Germany (A) 808/1998 25 October 2000 Inadmissible
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo(V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Veriter v. France (A) 1088/2002 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Bochaton v. France (A) (A) 1084/2002 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Nazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 911/2000 6 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation
Kolyada v. Russian Federation (A) 1357/2005 29 March 2005 Inadmissible
Van Den Hemel v. The Netherlands(A) 1185/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
Teun Sanders v. The Netherlands (A) 1193/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible

Jorge Luis Quispe Roque v. Peru (V)

 1125/2002

21 October 2005

 Violation

Antonino Vargas Mas v. Peru (V)

 1058/2002

26 October 2005

 Violation
Marlem Carranza Alegre v. Peru (V) 1126/2002 28 October 2005 Violation
Becerra v. Colombia (V) 1298/2004 11 July 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Zundel v. Canada(A) 1341/2005 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
Chadzjian and Barsgian v. The Netherlands (A) 1494/2006 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Guerra de la Espriella v. Colombia (V) 1623/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sechremelis et al. v. Greece 1507/2006 25 October 2010 No violation
Akwanga v. Cameroon (V)

 1813/2008 22 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(1)


f
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v.Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay(V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
C.A. v. Italy (A) 127/1982 31 March 1983 Inadmissible
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Y.L. v. Canada (A) 112/1981 8 April 1986 Inadmissible
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Avellanal v. Peru (V) 202/1986 28 October 1988 Violation
Muñoz v. Peru (V) 203/1986 4 November 1988 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 223/1987 30 March 1989 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
van Meurs v. The Netherlands (V) 215/1986 13 July 1990 Violation
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Sawyers and McLean v. Jamaica (V) 226 & 256/1987 11 April 1991 No violation
Barzhig v. France (V) 327/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Z.P. v. Canada (A) 341/1988 11 April 1991 Inadmissible
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 272/1988 31 March 1992 Violation
Hibbert v. Jamaica (V) 293/1988 27 July 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Párkányi v. Hungary (V) 410/1990 27 July 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Karttunen v. Finland (V) 387/1989 23 October 1992 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Gordon v. Jamaica (V) 237/1987 5 November 1992 No violation
Griffiths v. Jamaica (V) 274/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 307/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 441/1990 19 July 1994 No violation
Poongavanam v. Mauritius (A) 567/1993 26 July 1994 Inadmissible
Fei v. Colombia (V) 514/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Pons v. Spain (V) 454/1991 30 October 1995 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
A. v. Australia (V) 560/1993 3 April 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Adu v. Canada (A) 654/1995 18 July 1997 Inadmissible
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Young v. Jamaica (V) 615/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Henry v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 752/1997 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Fraser and Fisher v. Jamaica (V) 722/1996 31 March 1999 No violation
Maleki v. Italy (V) 699/1996 15 July 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Mukunto v. Zambia (V) 768/1997 23 July 1999 Violation
Tamihere v. New Zealand (A) 891/1999 15 March 2000 Inadmissible
Ben Said v. Norway (V) 767/1997 29 March 2000 No violation
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Mahuika et al. v. New Zealand (V) 547/1993 27 October 2000 No violation
Jansen-Gielen v. The Netherlands (V) 846/1999 3 April 2001 Violation
Kavanagh v. Ireland (V) 819/1998 4 April 2001 Violation
Torregrosa Lafuente et al. v. Spain (A) 866/1999 16 July 2001 Inadmissible
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Äärelä and Näkkäläjärvi v. Finland (V) 779/1997 24 October 2001 Violation
Des Fours v. Czech Republic (V) 747/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Gutiérrez Vicanco v. Peru (V) 678/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Rodríguez Orejuela v. Colombia (V) 848/1999 23 July 2002 Violation
Ruiz Agudo v. Spain (V) 864/1999 31 October 2002 Violation
Evans v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 908/2000 21 March 2003 Violation
Weiss v. Austria (V) 1086/2002 3 April 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus (V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Kolanowski v. Poland (A) 837/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Aliev v. Ukraine (V) 781/1997 7 August 2003 Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain (A) 956/2000 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Semey v. Spain (V) 986/2001 30 July 2003 Violation
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation
Perera v. Sri Lanka (A) 1091/2002 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Martínez Muñoz v.Spain (V) 1006/2001 30 October 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Sanlés Sanlés v. Spain (A) 1024/2001 30 March 2004 Inadmissible
Wilson v. Australia (A) 1239/2004 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Van Marcke v. Belgium (V) 904/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Perterer v. Austria (V) 1015/2001 20 July 2004 Violation
Mulai v. Republic of Guyana (V) 811/1998 20 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation
Riedl-Riedenstein v. Germany (A) 1188/2003 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Olavi v. Finland (V) 1076/2002 15 March 2005 No violation
Czernin v. Czech Republic (V) 823/1998 29 March 2005 Violation
Ostroukhov v. Russian Federation (A) 967/2001 31 March 2005 Inadmissible
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines (V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Karatsis v. Cyprus (A) 1182/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
López v. Spain (A) 1105/2002 26 July 2005 Inadmissible
Dimitrov v. Bulgaria (A) 1030/2001 28 October 2005 Inadmissible

Khachatrian v. Armenia (A)

1056/2002

28 October 2005

 Inadmissible
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Lassâad Aouf (V) 1010/2001 17 March 2006 No Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Puertas v. Spain (A) 1183/2003 27 March 2006 Inadmissible
Sankara v. Burkina Faso (V) 1159/2003 28 March 2006 Violation
Kouidis v. Greece (V) 1070/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Bazarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 959/2000 14 July 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Dranichnikov v. Australia (V) 1291/2004 20 October 2006 No violation
Verlinden v. The Netherlands (A) 1187/2003 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
González Cruz v. Spain (A) 1151/2003 01 November 2006 Inadmissible
E.B. v. New Zealand (V) 1368/2005 16 March 2007 Violation
Pimentel v. Philippines (V) 1320/2004 19 March 2007 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
P.K. v. Canada (A) 1234/2003 20 March 2007 Inadmissible
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Rodríguez and Sánchez v. Spain (A) 1213/2003 28 March 2007 Inadmissible
Lederbauer v. Austria (V) 1454/2006 13 July 2007 Violation
Dudko v. Australia (V) 1347/2005 23 July 2007 Violation
Asensi v. Spain (V) 1413/2005 1 April 2008 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Babkin v. Russian Federation (V) 1310/2004 3 April 2008 Violation
Jenny v. Austria (V) 1437/2005 9 July 2008 No violation
Donskov v. Russian Republic (V) 1149/2002 17 July 2008 No Violation
Kibale v. Canada (A) 1562/2007 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 Juy 2008 Violation
Y. v. Spain (V) 1456/2006 24 July 2008 No Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Gunaratna v. Sri Lanka (V) 1432/2005 17 March 2009 Violation
Reshetnikov v. Russian Federation (V) 1278/2004 23 March 2009 Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Khostikoev v. Tajikistan (V) 1519/2006 22 October 2009 Violation
Castedo v. Spain (V) 1122/2002 20 October 2008 Violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Kaur v. Canada (A) 1455/2006 30 October 2008 Inadmissible
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Tiyagarajah v. Sri Lanka (A) 1523/2007 19 March 2010 Inadmissible
Manzano et al. v. Colombia (A) 1616/2007 19 March 2010 Inadmissible
Gonzalez Muñoz v. Guyana (V) 1246/2004 25 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Crochet v. France (V) 1777/2008 25 October 2010 No violation
Bozbey v. Turkmenistan (V) 1530/2006 27 October 2010 Violation
I. S. v. Belarus (A) 1994/2010 25 March 2011 Inadmissible
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
Sedljar and Lavrov v. Estonia (V)

 1532/2006 29 March 2011 No violation
Jessop v. New Zealand (V)

 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Bonilla Lerma v. Colombia (V) 1611/2007 26 July 2011 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 1812/2008 26 July 2011 No Violation
Cunillera Arias v. Spain (V) 1531/2006 27 July 2011 No Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v. Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Muñoz v. Peru (V) 203/1986 4 November 1988 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Chung v. Jamaica (V) 591/1994 9 April 1998 Violation
Deidrick v. Jamaica (V) 619/1995 9 April 1998 Violation
Sánchez López v. Spain (A) 777/1997 18 October 1999 Inadmissible
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Cagas v. Philippines (V) 788/1997 23 October 2001 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Sineiro Fernández v. Spain (V) 1007/2001 7 August 2003 Violation

Rameka v. New Zealand(V)

1090/2002

6 November 2003

Violation

Saidov v. Tajikistan (V)

964/2001

8 July 2004

Violation

Everett v. Spain (A)

961/2000

9 July 2004

Inadmissible

Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V)

1033/2001

21 July 2004

Violation

Arutyuniantz v. Uzbekistan (V)

971/2001

30 March 2005

Violation

Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V)

973/2001

30 March 2005

Violation
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Yakupova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1205/2003 3 April 2008 No violation
Casanovas v. France (V) 1514/2006 28 October 2008 No Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Marinich v. Belarus 1502/2006 16 July 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(3)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Weismann and Perdomo v.Uruguay (V) 8/1977 3 April 1980 Violation
Ramirez v. Uruguay (V) 4/1977
(R.1/4)		 23 July 1980 Violation
Sequeira v. Uruguay (V) 6/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Carballal v. Uruguay (V) 33/1978 27 March 1981 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Touron v. Uruguay (V) 32/1978 31 March 1981 Violation
Sendic v. Uruguay (V) 63/1979
(R.14/63)		 28 October 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Z.P. v. Canada (A) 341/1988 11 April 1991 Inadmissible
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
A.R.J. v. Australia (V) 692/1996 28 July 1997 No violation
Morgan and Williams v. Jamaica (V) 720/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Leehong v. Jamaica (V) 613/1995 13 July 1999 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v.Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Everett v. Spain (A) 961/2000 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
R. M. and S. I. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1206/2003 10 March 2010 No violation
Guerra de la Espriella v. Colombia (V) 1623/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(3)(a)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
O.F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Willianms v Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1994 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggart v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation

Khachatrian v. Armenia (A)

1056/2002

28 October 2005

Inadmissible
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(3)(b)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Machado v. Uruguay (V) 83/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Oxandabarat v. Uruguay (V) 103/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Manera v. Uruguay (V) 123/1982 6 April 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
O. F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Wight v. Madagascar (V) 115/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Penarrieta et al. v. Bolivia (V) 176/1984 2 November 1987 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Sawyers and McLean v. Jamaica (V) 226 & 256/1987 11 April 1991 No violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 272/1988 31 March 1992 Violation
Hibbert v. Jamaica (V) 293/1988 27 July 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Simmonds v. Jamaica (V) 338/1988 23 October 1992 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Gentles et. al. v. Jamaica (V) 352/ 1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 335/1989 8 July 1994 Violation
Harward v. Norway (V) 451/1991 15 July 1994 No violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Smart v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 672/1995 29 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Pennant v. Jamaica (V) 647/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Gridin v. Russian Federation (V) 770/1997 20 July 2000 Violation
Hussain v. Mauritius (A) 980/2001 18 March 2002 Inadmissible
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Ramil Rayos v. The Philippines (V) 1167/2003 27 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
van Hulst v. The Netherlands (V) 903/1999 1 November 2004 No Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation

Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V)

1042/2001

20 October 2005

Violation

Siragev v. Uzbekistan (V)

907/2000

1 November 2005

Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Chan v. Guyana (V) 913/2000 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Babkin v. Russian Federation (V) 1310/2004 3 April 2008 Violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Onoufriou v. Cyprus (A) 1636/2007 25 October 2010 Inadmissible
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V)

 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Rastorguev v. Poland (V)

 1517/2006 28 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Levinov v. Belarus (V) 1812/2008 26 July 2011 No Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(3)(c)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Casariego v. Uruguay (V) 56/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)		 29 October 1981 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
Barbato v. Uruguay (V) 84/1981 21 October 1982 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
Caldas v. Uruguay (V) 43/1979 21 July 1983 Violation
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Machado v. Uruguay (V) 83/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Oxandabarat v. Uruguay (V) 103/1981 4 November 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Manera v. Uruguay (V) 123/1982 6 April 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Solorzano v. Venezuela (V) 156/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Bolaños v. Ecuador (V) 238/1987 26 July 1989 Violation
van Alphen v. The Netherlands (V) 305/1988 23 July 1990 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Martin v. Jamaica (V) 317/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 333/1988 23 March 1994 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Bozize v. Central African Republic (V) 428/1990 7 April 1994 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 335/1989 8 July 1994 Violation
Champagnie et. al v. Jamaica (V) 445/1991 18 July 1994 Violation
Shalto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 447/1991 4 April 1995 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Seerattan v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 434/1990 26 October 1995 Violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
Bautista v. Colombia (V) 563/1993 27 October 1995 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Elahie v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 533/1993 28 July 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 635/1995 27 July 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Smart v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 672/1995 29 July 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Finn v. Jamaica (V) 617/1995 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 616/1995 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Arredondo v. Peru (V) 688/1996 27 July 2000 Violation
Paraga v. Croatia (V) 727/1996 4 April 2001 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Gutiérrez Vicanco v. Peru (V) 678/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Ruiz Agudo v. Spain (V) 864/1999 31 October 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Filpovich v. Lithuania (V) 875/1999 4 August 2003 Violation
Martínez Muñoz v.Spain (V) 1006/2001 30 October 2003 Violation
Smirnova v. Russian Federation (V) 712/1996 5 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Kankanamge v. Sri Lanka (V) 909/2000 27 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation

Rouse v. The Philippines (V)

1089/2002

25 July 2005

Violation
Taright et al. v. Algeria (V) 1085/2002 15 March 2006 Violation
Medjnoune v. Algeria (V) 1297/2004 14 July 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Lumango and Santos v. Philippines (V) 1466/2006 20 March 2008 Violation
Smantser v. Belarus (V) 1178/2003 23 October 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Peirano Basso v. Uruguay (V) 1887/2009 19 October 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Krasnov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1402/2005 29 March 2011 Violation
Jessop v. New Zealand (V)

 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation

ARTICLE 14(3)(d)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Simones v. Uruguay (V) 70/1981
(R.17/70)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Marais v. Madagascar (V) 49/1979 24 March 1983 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Vasilskis v. Uruguay (V) 80/1980 31 March 1983 Violation
J.S. v. Canada (A) 130/1982 6 April 1983 Inadmissible
Nieto v. Uruguay (V) 92/1981 25 July 1983 Violation
Viana v. Uruguay (V) 110/1981 29 March 1984 Violation
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
O. F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 223/1987 30 March 1989 Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 232/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 250/1987 20 July 1990 Violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 229/1987 8 April 1991 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Fillastre and Bizouarn v. Bolivia (V) 336/1988 5 November 1991 Violation
Wolf v. Panama (V) 289/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Linton v. Jamaica (V) 255/1987 22 October 1992 Violation
Quelch v. Jamaica (V) 292/1988 23 October 1992 No violation
Simmonds v. Jamaica (V) 338/1988 23 October 1992 Violation
Gordon v. Jamaica (V) 237/1987 5 November 1992 No violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 307/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Gentles et. al. v. Jamaica (V) 352/ 1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Wright and Harvey v. Jamaica (V) 459/1991 27 October 1995 Violation
Chaplin v. Jamaica (V) 596/1994 2 November 1995 Violation
Graham and Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 461/1991 25 March 1996 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 537/1993 17 July 1996 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Steadman v.Jamaica (V) 528/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 708/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
McLawrence v. Jamaica (V) 702/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 707/1996 18 July 1997 Violation
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Polay Campos v. Peru (V) 577/1994 6 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v.Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McTaggert v. Jamaica (V) 749/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Shaw v. Jamaica (V) 704/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Taylor v. Jamaica (V) 705/1996 2 April 1998 Violation
Jones v. Jamaica (V) 585/1994 6 April 1998 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v.Georgia (V) 623, 624,626 &627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Perkins v. Jamaica (V) 733/1997 30 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
C. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 592/1994 20 October 1998 Violation
Phillip v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 594/1992 20 October 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Forbes v. Jamaica (V) 649/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Levy v. Jamaica (V) 719/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Brown v. Jamaica (V) 775/1997 23 March 1999 Violation
Lumley v. Jamaica (V) 662/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Maleki v. Italy (V) 699/1996 15 July 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Boodlal Sooklal v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 928/2000 25 October 2001 Violation
Simpson v. Jamaica (V) 695/1996 31 October 2001 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Ricketts v. Jamaica (V) 667/1995 4 April 2002 No violation
Rodríguez Orejuela v. Colombia (V) 848/1999 23 July 2002 Violation
Borisenko v. Hungary (V) 852/1999 14 October 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Aliev v. Ukraine (V) 781/1997 7 August 2003 Violation
Arutyunyan v. Uzbekistan (V) 917/2000 29 March 2004 Violation
Smartt v. Republic of Guyana (V) 867/1999 6 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Rolando v. Philippines (V) 1110/2002 3 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation

Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V)

985/2001

18 October 2005

Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Chan v. Guyana (V) 913/2000 31 October 2005 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Corriea de Matos v. Portugal (V) 1123/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Donskov v. Russian Federation (V) 1149/2002 17 July 2008 No Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V)

 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(3)(e)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
O. F. v. Norway (A) 158/1983 26 October 1984 Inadmissible
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 223/1987 30 March 1989 Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Reynolds v. Jamaica (V) 229/1987 8 April 1991 No violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Cadoret and Bihan v. France (V) 221 & 323/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Sawyers and McLean v. Jamaica (V) 226 & 256/1987 11 April 1991 No violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 240/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Prince v. Jamaica (V) 269/1987 30 March 1992 No violation
Hibbert v. Jamaica (V) 293/1988 27 July 1992 Violation
Wright v. Jamaica (V) 349/1989 27 July 1992 Violation
Párkányi v. Hungary (V) 410/1990 27 July 1992 Violation
Gordon v. Jamaica (V) 237/1987 5 November 1992 No violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Compass v. Jamaica (V) 375/1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Allen v. Jamaica (V) 332/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Grant v. Jamaica (V) 353/1988 31 March 1994 No violation
Peart and Peart v. Jamaica (DJ), (V) 464 & 482/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Adams v. Jamaica (V) 607/1994 30 October 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Williams v. Jamaica (V) 561/1993 8 April 1997 Violation
Blaine v. Jamaica (V) 696/1996 17 July 1997 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 532/1993 3 November 1997 Violation
Young v. Jamaica (V) 615/1995 4 November 1997 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
McLeod v. Jamaica (V) 734/1997 31 March 1998 Violation
Whyte v. Jamaica (V) 732/1997 27 July 1998 Violation
Leslie v. Jamaica (V) 564/1993 31 July 1998 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 610/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 618/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Lumley v. Jamaica (V) 662/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Rodríguez Orejuela v. Colombia (V) 848/1999 23 July 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation

Rouse v. The Philippines (V)

1089/2002

25 July 2005

Violation

Khachatrian v. Armenia (A)

1056/2002

28 October 2005

Inadmissible
Lassâad Aouf (V) 1010/2001 17 March 2006 No Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Salikh v. Uzbekistan (V) 1382/2005 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Osiyuk v. Belarus (V) 1311/2004 30 July 2009 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V)

 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Sedljar and Lavrov v. Estonia (V)

 1532/2006 29 March 2011 No violation
Jessop v. New Zealand (V)

 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(3)(f)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Cadoret and Bihan v. France (V) 221 & 323/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Barzhig v. France (V) 327/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Griffin v. Spain (V) 493/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Shukuru Juma v. Australia (A) 984/2001 28 July 2003 Inadmissible
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Bozbey v. Turkmenistan (V) 1530/2006 27 October 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 14(3)(g)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
Conteris v. Uruguay (V) 139/1983 17 July 1985 Violation
Cariboni v. Uruguay (V) 159/1983 27 October 1987 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Campbell v. Jamaica (V) 248/1987 30 March 1992 Violation
Blanco v. Nicaragua (V) 328/1988 20 July 1994 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Lewis v. Jamaica (V) 527/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Yasseen and Thomas v. Republic of Guyana (V) 676/1996 30 March 1998 Violation
Sánchez López v. Spain (A) 777/1997 18 October 1999 Inadmissible
Sahadeo v. Guyana (V) 728/1996 1 November 2001 Violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Hendricks v. Guyana (V) 838/1998 28 October 2002 Violation
Kurbanova v. Tajikistan (V) 1096/2002 6 November 2003 Violation
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Khomidov v. Tajikistan (V) 1117/2002 29 July 2004 Violation
Ganga v. Republic of Guyana (V) 912/2000 1 November 2004 Violation

Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V)

973/2001

30 March 2005

Violation
Gomaríz v. Spain (V) 1095/2002 22 July 2005 Violation

Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V)

985/2001

18 October 2005

Violation

Boimurodov v. Tajikistan (V)

1042/2001

20 October 2005

Violation
Ndong et al. and Mic Abogo v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 1152 and 1190/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Kurbonov v. Tajikistan (V) 1208/2003 16 March 2006 Violation
Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V) 1044/2002 17 March 2006 Violation
Kouidis v. Greece (V) 1070/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Tarasova v. Uzbekistan 1057/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Chikunova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1043/2002 16 March 2007 Violation
Ashurov v. Tajikistan (V) 1348/2005 20 March 2007 Violation
Karimov and Nursatov v. Tajikistan (V) 1108/2002 and 1121/2002 27 March 2007 Violation
Strakhov and Fayzullaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1017/2001 and 1066/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Tulyaganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1041/2001 20 July 2007 Violation
Khudayberganov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1140/2002 24 July 2007 Violation
Uteeva v. Uzbekistan (V) 1150/2003 26 October 2007 Violation
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Yakupova v. Uzbekistan (V) 1205/2003 3 April 2008 No violation
Khuseynov and Butaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1263/2004 and 1264/2004 20 October 2008 Violation
Isaev and Karimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1163/2003 20 March 2009 Violation
Dunaev v. Tajikistan (V) 1195/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Sattorov v. Tajikistan (V) 1200/2003 30 March 2009 Violation
Idiev v. Tajikistan (V) 1276/2004 31 March 2009 Violation
Tolipkhuzhaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1280/2004 22 July 2009 Violation
Kasimov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1378/2005 30 July 2009 Violation
Kodirov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1284/1004 20 October 2009 Violation
Kirpo v. Tajikistan (V) 1401/2005 27 October 2009 Violation
Lyashkevich v. Uzbekistan (V) 1552/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Pustovalov v. Russian Federation (V) 1232/2003 23 March 2010 Violation
Usaev v. Russian Federation 1577/2007 16 July 2010 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Akhadov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1503/2006 25 March 2011 Violation
Ismailov v. Uzbekistan (V)

 1769/2008 25 March 2011 Violation
Khoroshenko v. Russian Federation (V)

 1304/2004 29 March 2011 Violation
Iskandarov v. Tajikistan (V)

 1499/2006 30 March 2011 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation
Shchetka v. Ukraine 1535/2006 19 July 2011 Violation
Gunan v. Kyrgyzstan 1545/2007 25 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 14(4)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Rakhmatov et al. v. Tajikistan (V) 1209, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004 1 April 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Koreba v. Belarus 1390/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
ARTICLE 14(5)
Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
(R.7/27)		 29 October 1981 Violation
de Montejo v. Colombia (V) 64/1979
(R.15/64)		 24 March 1982 Violation
Fanali v. Italy (V) 75/1980 31 March 1983 No Violation
Pratt and Morgan v. Jamaica (V) 225/1987 6 April 1989 Violation
Kelly v. Jamaica (V) 253/1987 8 April 1991 Violation
Henry v. Jamaica (V) 230/1987 1 November 1991 Violation
Martin v. Jamaica (V) 317/1988 24 March 1993 No violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 320/1988 24 March 1993 Violation
Collins v. Jamaica (V) 356/1989 25 March 1993 Violation
Smith v. Jamaica (V) 282/1988 31 March 1993 Violation
Gentles et. al. v. Jamaica (V) 352/ 1989 19 October 1993 No violation
Hamilton v. Jamaica (V) 333/1988 23 March 1994 Violation
Currie v. Jamaica (V) 377/1989 29 March 1994 Violation
Berry v. Jamaica (V) 330/1988 7 April 1994 Violation
Reid v. Jamaica (V) 335/1989 8 July 1994 Violation
Champagnie et. al v. Jamaica (V) 445/1991 18 July 1994 Violation
Francis v. Jamaica (V) 606/1994 25 July 1995 Violation
Stephens v. Jamaica (V) 373/1989 18 October 1995 Violation
Lubuto v. Zambia (V) 390/1990 31 October 1995 Violation
E. Johnson v. Jamaica (V) 588/1994 22 March 1996 Violation
Fuenzalida v. Ecuador (V) 480/1991 12 July 1996 Violation
Neptune v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 523/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Burrell v. Jamaica (V) 546/1993 18 July 1996 Violation
Henry and Douglas v. Jamaica (V) 571/1994 25 July 1996 Violation
Price v. Jamaica (V) 572/1994 6 November 1996 Violation
Richards v. Jamaica (V) 535/1993 31 March 1997 Violation
Hill v. Spain (V) 526/1993 2 April 1997 Violation
Walker and Richards v. Jamaica (V) 639/1995 28 July 1997 Violation
LaVende v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 554/1993 29 October 1997 Violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Chadee et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 813/1998 29 July 1998 No violation
Daley v. Jamaica (V) 750/1997 31 July 1998 Violation
Morrison v. Jamaica (V) 663/1995 3 November 1998 Violation
Marshall v. Jamaica (V) 730/1996 3 November 1998 Violation
Bennett v. Jamaica (V) 590/1994 25 March 1999 Violation
Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 614/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Lumley v. Jamaica (V) 662/1995 31 March 1999 Violation
Smith and Stewart v. Jamaica (V) 668/1995 8 April 1999 Violation
Bailey v. Jamaica (V) 709/1996 21 July 1999 Violation
Gallimore v. Jamaica (V) 680/1996 23 July 1999 Violation
Brown and Parish v. Jamaica (V) 665/1995 29 July 1999 Violation
Bryhn v. Norway (V) 789/1997 29 October 1999 No violation
Robinson v. Jamaica (V) 731/1996 29 March 2000 Violation
Gómez v. Spain (V) 701/1996 20 July 2000 Violation
Sextus v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 818/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Mansaraj et al. v. Sierra Leone (V) 839, 840 & 841/1998 16 July 2001 Violation
Ashby v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 580/1994 21 March 2002 Violation
Wanza v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 683/1996 26 March 2002 Violation
Kennedy v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 845/1998 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Francis et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 899/1999 25 July 2002 Violation
Ruiz Agudo v. Spain (V) 864/1999 31 October 2002 Violation
Gelazauskas v. Lithuania (V) 836/1998 17 March 2003 Violation
Reece v. Jamaica (V) 796/1998 14 July 2003 Violation
Shukuru Juma v. Australia (A) 984/2001 28 July 2003 Inadmissible
Semey v. Spain (V) 986/2001 30 July 2003 Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain (A) 956/2000 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Sineiro Fernández v. Spain (V) 1007/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Romanov v. Ukraine (A) 842/1998 30 October 2003 Inadmissible
Lovell v. Australia (V) 920/2000 24 March 2004 No violation
Dugin v. Russian Federation (V) 815/1998 5 July 2004 Violation
Saidov v. Tajikistan (V) 964/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Nallaratnam v. Sri Lanka (V) 1033/2001 21 July 2004 Violation
Girjadat Siewpersaud et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 938/2000 29 July 2004 Violation
van Hulst v. The Netherlands (V) 903/1999 1 November 2004 No Violation
Alba Cabriada v. Spain (V) 1101/2002 1 November 2004 Violation
Terrón Jesús v. Spain (V) 1073/2002 5 November 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Gayoso Martínez v. Spain (V) 1104/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Parra Corral v. Spain (V) 1356/2005 29 March 2005 Inadmissible

Khalilov v. Tajikistan (V)

973/2001

30 March 2005

Violation
Ratiani v. Georgia (V) 975/2001 21 July 2005 Violation
Gomaríz v. Spain (V) 1095/2002 22 July 2005 Violation
Rouse v. The Philippines(V) 1089/2002 25 July 2005 Violation
Cuartero Casado v. Spain (A) 1399/2005 25 July 2005 Inadmissible

Aliboev v. Tajikistan (V)

985/2001

18 October 2005

Violation

Chisanga v. Zambia (V)

1132/2002

18 October 2005

Violation
Lozano v. Spain 1323/2004 28 October 2005 Inadmissible

Nazriev v. Tajikistan (V)

1044/2002

17 March 2006

Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Escolar v. Spain (V) 1156/2003 28 March 2006 No Violation
Olivero v. Spain (V) 1211/2003 11 July 2006 Violation
Larrañaga v. Philippines (V) 1421/2005 24 July 2006 Violation
Villamón v. Spain (A) 1305/2004 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Conde v. Spain (V) 1325/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Sánchez and Clares v. Spain (V) 1332/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Gayoso Martínez v. Spain (A) 1098/2002 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Amador v. Spain (V) 1181/2003 31 October 2006 No violation
Moreno v. Spain (V) 1381/2005 25 July 2007 Violation
Kharkhal v. Belarus (A) 1161/2003 31 October 2007 Inadmissible
Serena and Rodríguez v. Spain (V) 1351/2005 and 1352/2005 25 March 2008 Violation
Aboushanif v. Norway (V) 1542/2007 17 Juy 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Iskiyaev v. Uzbekistan (V) 1418/2005 20 March 2009 Violation
Engo v. Cameroon (V) 1397/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Uclés v. Spain (V) 1364/2005 22 July 2009 Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain (V) 1366/2005 22 July 2009 No violation
Martínez v. Spain (V) 1363/2005 19 October 2009 Violation
Possemiers v. Spain (V) 1398/2005 20 October 2009 No violation
Mwamba v. Zambia (V) 1520/2006 10 March 2010 Violation
Kulov v. Kyrgyzstan (V) 1369/2005 26 July 2010 Violation
Mennen v. The Netherlands (V) 1797/2008 27 July 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
J. O. v. France 1620/2007 23 March 2011 Violation
 Jessop v. New Zealand (V) 1758/2008 29 March 2011 No violation

 


ARTICLE 14(6)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Muhonen v. Finland (V) 89/1981 8 April 1985 No violation
W. J. H. v. The Netherlands (A) 408/1990 22 July 1992 Inadmissible
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Simunek et al. v. Czech Republic (V) 516/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Uebergang v. Australia (A) 963/2001 22 March 2001 Inadmissible
Strik v. The Netherlands(A) 1001/2001 1 November 2002 Inadmissible
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Anderson v. Australia (A) 1367/2005 31 October 2006 Inadmissible
Dumont v. Canada (V) 1467/2006 16 March 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 14(7)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Schweizer v. Uruguay (V) 66/1980 12 October 1982 Violation
A.P. v. Italy (A) 204/1986 2 November 1987 Inadmissible
Jijón v. Ecuador (V) 277/1988 26 March 1992 Violation
del Cid v. Panama (V) 473/1991 19 July 1995 Violation
Strik v. The Netherlands (A) 1001/2001 1 November 2002 Inadmissible
Babkin v. Russian Federation (V) 1310/2004 3 April 2008 Violation
Tillman v. Australia (V) 1635/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 15


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kivenmaa v. Finland (V) 412/1990 31 March 1994 Violation
de Groot v. The Netherlands (A) 578/1994 14 July 1995 Inadmissible
Westerman v. The Netherlands (V) 682/1996 3 November 1999 No violation
Strik v. The Netherlands (A) 1001/2001 1 November 2002 Inadmissible
Van Grinsven. v. The Netherlands(A) 1142/2002 27 March 2003 Inadmissible
Gomez Casafranca v. Peru (V) 981/2001 22 July 2003 Violation
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation

ARTICLE 15(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Van Duzen v. Canada (V) 50/1979
(R.12/50)		 7 April 1982 No violation
MacIsaac v. Canada (V) 55/1979 14 October 1982 No violation
Rogerson v. Australia (V) 802/1998 3 April 2002 Violation
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Filpovich v. Lithuania (V) 875/1999 4 August 2003 Violation
Nicholas v. Australia (V) 1080/2002 19 March 2004 No violation

Ostroukhov v. Russian Federation (A)

967/2001

31 March 2005

Inadmissible
Gavrilin v. Belarus (V) 1342/2005 28 March 2007 No violation
van der Plaat v. New Zealand (A) 1492/2006 22 July 2008 Inadmissible
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Fardon v. Australia (V) 1629/2007 18 March 2010 Violation
Sobhraj v. Nepal (V) 1870/2009 27 July 2010 Violation
Tofanyuk v. Ukraine (V) 1346/2005 20 October 2010 No violation
Cochet v. France (V) 1760/2008 21 October 2010 Violation
Butovenko v. Ukraine (V) 1412/2005 19 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 16


Name of case Comm No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
A.A.C. v. Sweden (V) 277/2003 16 November 2006 No Violation
Grioua v. Algeria (V) 1327/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Kimouche v. Algeria (V) 1328/2004 10 July 2007 Violation
Madoui v. Algeria (V) 1495/2006 28 October 2008 Violation
Benaziza v. Algeria (V) 1588/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
El Abani v. Libyan Arab Jamahirya (V) 1640/2007 26 July 2010 Violation
Aboussedra v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1751/2008 25 October 2010 Violation
Aouabdia v. Algeria (V)

 1780/2008 22 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 17


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Estrella v. Uruguay (V) 74/1980 29 March 1983 Violation
van Alphen v. The Netherlands (V) 305/1988 23 July 1990 Violation
González del Rio v. Peru (V) 263/1987 28 October 1992 Violation
Orihuela v. Peru (V) 309/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Coeriel and Aurik v. The Netherlands (V) 453/1991 31 October 1994 Violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Fei v. Colombia (V) 514/1992 4 April 1995 Violation
Stewart v. Canada (V) 538/1993 1 November 1996 No violation
Canepa v. Canada (V) 558/1993 3 April 1997 No violation
Rogl v. Germany (A) 808/1998 25 October 2000 Inadmissible
Buckle v. New Zealand (V) 858/1999 25 October 2000 No violation
Rojas García v. Colombia (V) 687/1996 3 April 2001 Violation
Winata v. Australia (V) 930/2000 26 July 2001 Violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Patera v. Czech Republic (V) 946/2000 25 July 2002 Violation
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Ngambi v. France (A) 1179/2003 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Byahuranga v. Denmark (V) 1222/2003 1 November 2004 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Ruzmetov v. Uzbekistan 915/2000 30 March 2006 Violation
Brun v. France (A) 1453/2006 18 October 2006 Inadmissible
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
M.G. v. Germany (V) 1482/2006 23 Juy 2008 Violation
Sayadi and Vinck v. Belgium (V) 1472/2006 22 October 2008 Violation
Vojnović v. Croatia (V) 1510/2006 30 March 2009 Violation
Yklymova v. Turkmenistan (V) 1460/2006 20 July 2009 Violation
Dauphin v. Canada (V) 1792/2008 28 July 2009 Violation
Georgpoulos v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation
Raihman v. Latvia 1621/2007 28 October 2010 Violation
L.M.R. v. Argentina (V) 1608/2007 29 March 2011 Violation
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 17(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977
R.7/27)		 29 October 1981 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
Birindwa and Tshisekedi v. Zaire (V) 241 & 242/1987 2 November 1989 Violation
Toonen v. Australia (V) 488/1992 30 March 1994 Violation
Pinto v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 512/1992 16 July 1996 Violation
Tomlin v. Jamaica (V) 589/1994 16 July 1996 No violation
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Coronel et al. v. Colombia (V) 778/1997 24 October 2002 Violation
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
van Hulst v. The Netherlands (V) 903/1999 1 November 2004 No Violation
E.B. v. New Zealand (V) 1368/2005 16 March 2007 Violation
Komarovski v. Turkmenistan (V) 1450/2006 24 July 2008 Violation
Tornel et al. v. Spain (V) 1473/2006 20 March 2009 Violation
Gonzalez v. Republic of Guyana (V) 1246/2004 25 March 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 18


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
L.T.K. v. Finland (A) 185/1984 9 July 1985 Inadmissible
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Bhinder v. Canada (V) 208/1986 9 November 1989 no violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Westerman v. The Netherlands (V) 682/1996 3 November 1999 No violation
Ross v. Canada (V) 736/1997 18 October 2000 No violation
Boodoo v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 721/1996 2 April 2002 Violation
Leirvåg v. Norway (V) 1155/2003 3 November 2004 violation
Hudoyberganova v. Uzbekistan (V) 931/2000 5 November 2004 violation

ARTICLE 18(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Malakhovsky v. Belarus (V) 1207/2003 26 July 2005 Violation
Immaculate Joseph et al. v. Sri Lanka (V)

1249/2004

 21 October 2005

Violation
Yoon and Choi v. Republic of Korea (V) 1321 & 1322/2004 03 November 2006 Violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation
Jung et al. v. Republic of Korea (V) 1593-1603/2007 23 March 2010 Violation
Min-Kyu Jeong et al. v. Republic of Korea (V)

 1642-1741/2007 24 March 2011 Violation
Singh v. France 1876/2009 22 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 18(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Hudoyberganova v. Uzbekistan (V) 931/2000 5 November 2004 violation

ARTICLE 18(3)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Hudoyberganova v. Uzbekistan (V) 931/2000 5 November 2004 violation
Malakhovsky v. Belarus (V) 1207/2003 26 July 2005 Violation
Immaculate Joseph et al. v. Sri Lanka 1249/2004 21 October 2005 Violation
Yoon and Choi v. Republic of Korea (V) 1321 & 1322/2004 03 November 2006 Violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation
Singh v. France 1876/2009 22 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 18(4)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Hartikainen v. Finland (V) 40/1978 9 April 1981 No violation
Leirvåg v. Norway (V) 1155/2003 3 November 2004 violation

ARTICLE 19


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
J.R.T. and the W .G. Party v. Canada (A) 104/1981 6 April 1983 Inadmissible
Muteba v. Zaire (V) 124/1982 24 July 1984 Violation
L.T.K. v. Finland (A) 185/1984 9 July 1985 Inadmissible
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
V.M.R.B. v. Canada (A) 236/1987 18 July 1988 Inadmissible
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Ballantyne, Davidson and MacIntyre v. Canada (V) 359 & 385/1989 31 March 1993 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Kalenga v. Zambia (V) 326/1988 27 July 1993 Violation
Koné v. Senegal (V) 386/1989 21 October 1994 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423, & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
Park v. Republic of Korea (V) 628/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Ross v. Canada (V) 736/1997 18 October 2000 No violation
Paraga v. Croatia (V) 727/1996 4 April 2001 Violation
Dergachev v. Belarus (V) 921/2000 2 April 2002 Violation
Nam v. Republic of Korea (A) 693/1996 28 July 2003 Inadmissible
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Kankanamge v. Sri Lanka (V) 909/2000 27 July 2004 Violation
Bandajevsky v. Belarus (V) 1100/2002 28 March 2006 Violation
Abbassi Madani v. Algeria (V) 1172/2003 28 March 2007 Violation
Benhadj v. Algeria (V) 1173/2003 20 July 2007 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
Mavlonov and Sa’di v. Uzbekistan (V) 1334/2004 19 March 2009 Violation

ARTICLE 19(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation

ARTICLE 19(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
Hertzberg et al. v. Finland (V) 61/1979
(R.14/61)		 2 April 1982 No violation
Mbenge v. Zaire (V) 16/1977 25 March 1983 Violation
Jaona v. Madagascar (V) 132/1982 1 April 1985 Violation
R.T. v. France (A) 262/1987 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Kivenmaa v. Finland (V) 412/1990 31 March 1994 Violation
Mika Miha v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 414/1990 8 July 1994 Violation
Singer v. Canada (V) 455/1991 26 July 1994 Violation
Sohn v. Republic of Korea (V) 518/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Gauthier v. Canada (V) 633/1995 7 April 1999 Violation
Laptsevich v. Belarus (V) 780/1997 20 March 2000 Violation
Zündel v. Canada (A) 953/2000 27 July 2003 Inadmissible
Howell v. Jamaica (V) 798/1998 21 October 2003 Violation
Shin v. Republic of Korea (V) 926/2000 16 March 2004 Violation
Lovell v. Australia (V) 920/2000 24 March 2004 No violation
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Jong-Cheol v. Republic of Korea (V) 968/2001 27 July 2005 No violation
Velichkin v. Belarus (V) 1022/2001 20 October 2005 Violation
Bodrozic v. Serbia and Montenegro (V) 1180/2003 31 October 2005 Violation
Shchetko v. Belarus (V) 1009/2001 11 July 2006 Violation
Coleman v. Australia (V) 1157/2003 17 July 2006 Violation
Njaru v. Cameroon (V) 1353/2005 19 March 2007 Violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Katsora v. Belarus (V) 1377/2005 19 July 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Toktakunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1470/2006 28 March 2011 Violation
Zalesskaya v. Belarus (V)

 1604/2007 28 March 2011 Violation
Kungurov v. Uzbekistan 1478/2006 20 July 2011 Violoation
P. L. v. Belarus (A) 1814/2008 26 July 2011 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 19(3)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Motta et al. v. Uruguay (V) 11/1977 29 July 1980 Violation
Izquierdo v. Uruguay (V) 73/1981
(R.18/73)		 1 April 1982 Violation
Hertzberg et al. v. Finland (V) 61/1979
(R.14/61)		 2 April 1982 No violation
Mukong v. Cameroon (V) 458/1991 21 July 1994 Violation
Sohn v. Republic of Korea (V) 518/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Faurisson v. France (V) 550/1993 8 November 1996 No violation
Kim v. Republic of Korea (V) 574/1994 2 November 1998 Violation
Gauthier v. Canada (V) 633/1995 7 April 1999 Violation
Laptsevich v. Belarus (V) 780/1997 20 March 2000 Violation
Baban et al. v. Australia (V) 1014/2001 6 August 2003 Violation
Shin v. Republic of Korea (V) 926/2000 16 March 2004 Violation
Lovell v. Australia (V) 920/2000 24 March 2004 No violation
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Marques v. Angola (V) 1128/2002 29 March 2005 Violation
Jong-Cheol v. Republic of Korea (V) 968/2001 27 July 2005 No violation
Shchetko v. Belarus (V) 1009/2001 11 July 2006 Violation
Coleman v. Australia (V) 1157/2003 17 July 2006 Violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
A.K. and A.R. v. Uzbekistan (V) 1233/2003 31 March 2009 No violation
Katsora v. Belarus (V) 1377/2005 19 July 2010 Violation
Toktakunov v. Kyrgyzstan (V)

 1470/2006 28 March 2011 Violation
Zalesskaya v. Belarus (V)

 1604/2007 28 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 20(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
J.R.T. and the W.G. Party v. Canada (A) 104/1981 6 April 1983 Inadmissible
Vassilari et al. v. Greece (V) 1570/2007 19 March 2009 No violation

ARTICLE 21


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kivenmaa v. Finland (V) 412/1990 31 March 1994 Violation
Zalesskaya v. Belarus (V)

 1604/2007 28 March 2011 Violation


ARTICLE 22


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Burgos v. Uruguay (V) 52/1979 29 July 1981 Violation
J.B. et al. v. Canada (A) 118/1982 18 July 1986 Inadmissible
Park v. Republic of Korea (V) 628/1995 20 October 1998 Violation
Wallman v. Austria (V) 1002/2001 1 April 2004 No Violation
Korneenko et al. v. Belarus 1274/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Tebourski v. France (V) 300/2006 1 May 2007 Violation
C.A.R.M. et al. v. Canada (V) 298/2006 18 May 2007 No violation

ARTICLE 22(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Wallman v. Austria (V) 1002/2001 1 April 2004 No violation
Lee v. Republic of Korea (V) 1119/2002 20 July 2005 Violation
Zvozskov et al. v. Belarus 1039/2001 17 October 2006 Violation
Korneenko et al. v. Belarus 1274/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Belyatsky et al. v. Belarus (V) 1296/2004 24 July 2007 Violation
Katsora et. al v. Belarus (V) 1383/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Kungurov v. Uzbekistan 1478/2006 20 July 2011 Violoation

ARTICLE 22(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lee v. Republic of Korea (V) 1119/2002 20 July 2005 Violation
Zvozskov et al. v. Belarus 1039/2001 17 October 2006 Violation
Korneenko et al. v. Belarus 1274/2004 31 October 2006 Violation
Belyatsky et al. v. Belarus (V) 1296/2004 24 July 2007 Violation
Katsora et. al v. Belarus (V) 1383/2005 25 October 2010 Violation
Kungurov v. Uzbekistan 1478/2006 20 July 2011 Violoation

ARTICLE 23


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)		 30 July 1981 Violation
Hendricks v. The Netherlands (V) 201/1985 27 July 1988 No violation
Stewart v. Canada (V) 538/1993 1 November 1996 No violation
Buckle v. New Zealand (V) 858/1999 25 October 2000 No violation
Ngambi v. France (A) 1179/2003 9 July 2004 Inadmissible
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
Asensi v. Paraguay 1407/2005 27 March 2009 Violation
El-Hichou v. Denmark (V) 1554/2007 22 July 2010 Violation
Georgopoulos et al. v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 23(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Santacana v. Spain (V) 417/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Winata v. Australia (V) 930/2000 26 July 2001 Violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
Sahid v. New Zealand (V) 893/1999 28 March 2003 Violation
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Mulezi v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 962/2001 8 July 2004 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Byahuranga v. Denmark (V) 1222/2003 1 November 2004 Violation
E.B. v. New Zealand (V) 1368/2005 16 March 2007 Violation
Dauphin v. Canada (V) 1792/2008 28 July 2009 Violation
Nystrom et. al v. Australia 1557/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Warsame v. Canada 1959/2010 21 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 23(2)


Name of case Comm No. Date of Decision Outcome
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation


ARTICLE 23(4)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Santacana v. Spain (V) 417/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Fei v. Colombia (V) 514/1992 4 April 1995 Violation

ARTICLE 24


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
D. Thomas v. Jamaica (V) 800/1998 8 April 1999 Violation
K. N. L. H. v. Peru 1153/2003 24 October 2005 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
J. T. v. Canada (V) 1052/2002 20 March 2007 Violation
El Dernawi v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (V) 1143/2002 20 July 2007 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
X. H. L. v. Netherlands 1564/2007 22 July 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 24(1)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Santacana v. Spain (V) 417/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Celis Laureano v. Peru (V) 540/1993 25 March 1996 Violation
Winata v. Australia (V) 930/2000 26 July 2001 Violation
Jalloh v. The Netherlands (V) 794/1998 26 March 2002 No violation
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Bakhtiyari v. Australia (V) 1069/2002 29 October 2003 Violation
Madafferi v. Australia (V) 1011/2001 26 July 2004 Violation
Brough v. Australia (V) 1184/2003 17 March 2006 Violation
Asensi v. Paraguay 1407/2005 27 March 2009 Violation
Kaba v. Canada (V) 1465/2006 25 March 2010 Violation
El-Hichou v. Denmark (V) 1554/2007 22 July 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 24(2)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation

ARTICLE 24(3)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation

ARTICLE 25


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Massera et al. v. Uruguay (V) 5/1977
(R.1/5)		 15 August 1979 Violation
Weinberger v. Uruguay (V) 28/1978 29 October 1980 Violation
Pietraroia v. Uruguay (V) 44/1979 27 March 1981 Violation
Silva et al. v. Uruguay (V) 34/1978 8 April 1981 Violation
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Altesor v. Uruguay (V) 10/1977
(R.2/10)		 29 March 1982 Violation
Mpandanjila et al. v. Zaire (V) 138/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Mpaka-Nsusu v. Zaire (V) 157/1983 26 March 1986 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Rodríguez Veiga v. Uruguay (A) 487/1992 18 July 1994 Inadmissible
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Debreczeny v. The Netherlands (V) 500/1992 3 April 1995 No violation
Domukovsky et al. v. Georgia (V) 623, 624, 626 & 627/1995 6 April 1998 Violation
Ignatane v. Latvia (V) 884/1999 25 July 2001 Violation
Mazou v. Cameroon (V) 630/1995 26 July 2001 Violation
Karakurt v. Austria (V) 965/2000 4 April 2002 Violation
Gillot v. France (V) 932/2000 15 July 2002 No violation
Arenz v. Germany (A) 1138/2002 24 March 2004 Inadmissible
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Lukyanchik v. Belarus (V) 1392/2005 21 October 2009 Violation
Yevdokimov and Rezanov v. Russian Federation (V) 1410/2005 21 March 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 25(A)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Marshall et al. v. Canada (V) 205/1986 4 November 1991 No violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Mátyus v. Slovakia (V) 923/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Beydon v. France (A) 1400/2005 2 November 2005 Inadmissible
Brun v. France (V) 1473/2006 7 November 2006 No violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation


ARTICLE 25(b)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Svetik v. Belarus (V) 927/2000 8 July 2004 Violation
Gorji-Dinka v. Cameroon (V) 1134/2002 17 March 2005 Violation
Shchetko v. Belarus (V) 1009/2001 11 July 2006 Violation
Sinitsin v. Belarus (V) 1047/2002 20 October 2006 Violation
Dissanayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1373/2005 22 July 2008 Violation
Lukyanchik v. Belarus (V) 1392/2005 21 October 2009 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation


ARTICLE 25(c)


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Stalla Costa v. Uruguay (V) 198/1985 9 July 1987 No violation
Muñoz v. Peru (V) 203/1986 4 November 1988 Violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Aduayom et al. v. Togo (V) 422, 423 & 424/1990 12 July 1996 Violation
Kall v. Poland (V) 522/1993 14 July 1997 No violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Marín Gómez v. Spain (V) 865/1999 22 October 2001 No violation
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Mátyus v. Slovakia (V) 923/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Chira Vargas v. Peru (V) 906/2000 22 July 2002 Violation
Adrien Mundyo Busyo, Thomas Osthudi Wongodi, Ren Sibu Matubuka et al. v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 933/2000 31 July 2003 Violation
Pastukhov v. Belarus(V) 814/1998 5 August 2003 Violation
Kazantzis v. Cyprus (A) 972/2001 7 August 2003 Inadmissible
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
Karatsis v. Cyprus (A)

1182/2003

25 July 2005

 Inadmissible
Solís v. Peru (V) 1016/2001 27 March 2006 No Violation
Raosavljevic v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (A) 1219/2003 28 March 2007 Inadmissible
Bandaranayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1376/2005 24 July 2008 Violation
Bandaranayake v. Sri Lanka (V) 1376/2005 24 July 2008 Violation

ARTICLE 26


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Mauritian women v. Mauritius (V) 35/1978 9 April 1981 Violation
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)		 30 July 1981 Violation
E.H. v. Finland (A) 170/1984 25 October 1985 Inadmissible
S.W.M. Brooks v. The Netherlands (V) 172/1984 9 April 1987 Violation
Danning v. The Netherlands (V) 180/1984 9 April 1987 No violation
Zwaan-de Vries v. The Netherlands (V) 182/1984 9 April 1987 Violation
Stalla Costa v. Uruguay (V) 198/1985 9 July 1987 No violation
P. P. C. v The Netherlands (A) 212/1986 24 March 1988 Inadmissible
Blom v. Sweden (V) 191/1985 4 April 1988 No violation
Avellanal v. Peru (V) 202/1986 28 October 1988 Violation
Vos v. The Netherlands (V) 218/1986 29 March 1989 No violation
R.T. v. France (A) 262/1987 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
B. d. B. et al. v. The Netherlands (A) 273/1989 30 March 1989 Inadmissible
Gueye et al. v. France (V) 196/1983 3 April 1989 Violation
Morael v. France (V) 207/1986 28 July 1989 No violation
Bhinder v. Canada (V) 208/1986 9 November 1989 no violation
Delgado Páez v. Colombia (V) 195/1985 12 July 1990 Violation
Guesdon v. France (V) 219/1986 25 July 1990 No violation
Järvinen v. Finland (V) 295/1988 25 July 1990 No violation
Lindgren et al. and Lundquist et al. v. Sweden (DJ), (V) 298 & 299/1988 9 November 1990 No violation
Cadoret and Bihan v. France (V) 221 & 323/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Barzhig v. France (V) 327/1988 11 April 1991 No violation
Pauger v. Austria (V) 415/1990 26 March 1992 Violation
Sprenger v. The Netherlands (V) 395/1990 31 March 1992 No violation
Oulajin & Kaiss v. The Netherlands (V) 406 & 426/1990 23 October 1992 No violation
Ballantyne, Davidson and McIntyre v. Canada (V) 359 & 385/1989 31 March 1993 Violation
Orihuela v. Peru (V) 309/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Bwalya v. Zambia (V) 314/1988 14 July 1993 Violation
Brinkhof v. The Netherlands (V) 402/1990 27 July 1993 No violation
Bahamonde v. Equatorial Guinea (V) 468/1991 20 October 1993 Violation
Araujo-Jongen v. The Netherlands (V) 418/1990 22 October 1993 No violation
Toonen v. Australia (V) 488/1992 30 March 1994 Violation
J. A. M. B. R. v. The Netherlands (A) 477/1991 7 April 1994 Inadmissible
Neefs v. The Netherlands (V) 425/1990 15 July 1994 No violation
Pepels v. The Netherlands (V) 484/1991 15 July 1994 No violation
Cox v. Canada (V) 539/1993 31 October 1994 No violation
Mónaco v. Argentina (V) 400/1990 3 April 1995 Violation
Debreczeny v. The Netherlands (V) 500/1992 3 April 1995 No violation
de Groot v. The Netherlands (A) 578/1994 14 July 1995 Inadmissible
Simunek et al. v. Czech Republic (V) 516/1992 19 July 1995 Violation
Pons v. Spain (V) 454/1991 30 October 1995 No violation
Nahlik v. Austria (A) 608/1995 22 July 1996 Inadmissible
Somers v. Hungary (V) 566/1993 23 July 1996 No violation
Adam v. Czech Republic (V) 586/1994 23 July 1996 Violation
Drake et al . v. New Zealand (A) 601/1994 3 April 1997 Inadmissible
Drobek v. Slovakia (A) 643/1995 14 July 1997 Inadmissible
Oord v. The Netherlands (A) 658/1995 23 July 1997 Inadmissible
Hopu and Bessert v. France (V) 549/1993 29 July 1997 Violation
Snijders et al. v. The Netherlands (V) 651/1995 27 July 1998 No violation
Hoofdman v. The Netherlands (V) 602/1994 3 November 1998 No violation
Pauger v. Austria (V) 716/1996 25 March 1999 Violation
Byrne and Lazarescu v. Canada (A) 742/1997 25 March 1999 Inadmissible
Vos. v. The Netherlands (V) 786/1997 26 July 1999 Violation
Foin v. France (V) 666/1995 3 November 1999 Violation
Waldman v. Canada (V) 694/1996 3 November 1999 Violation
Lestourneaud v. France (A) 861/1999 3 November 1999 Inadmissible
Maille v. France (V) 689/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Venier and Nicolas v. France (V) 690 & 691/1996 10 July 2000 Violation
Gómez v. Spain (V) 701/1996 20 July 2000 Violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Toala et al. v. New Zealand (V) 675/1995 2 November 2000 No violation
Kavanagh v. Ireland (V) 819/1998 4 April 2001 Violation
Blazek et al. v. Czech Republic (V) 857/1999 12 July 2001 Violation
Schmitz-de-Jong v. The Netherlands (V) 855/1999 16 July 2001 No violation
Torregrosa Lafuente et al. v. Spain (A) 866/1999 16 July 2001 Inadmissible
Cheban v. Russian Federation (V) 790/1997 24 July 2001 No violation
Marín Gómez v. Spain (V) 865/1999 22 October 2001 No violation
Des Fours v. Czech Republic (V) 747/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Fábryová v. Czech Republic (V) 765/1997 30 October 2001 Violation
Brok v. Czech Republic (V) 774/1997 31 October 2001 Violation
Müller and Engelhard v. Namibia (V) 919/2000 26 March 2002 Violation
Teesdale v. Trinidad and Tobago (V) 677/1996 1 April 2002 Violation
Karakurt v. Austria (V) 965/2000 4 April 2002 Violation
Gedumbe v. Democratic Republic of the Congo (V) 641/1995 9 July 2002 Violation
Gillot v. France (V) 932/2000 15 July 2002 No violation
Wackenheim v. France (V) 854/1999 15 July 2002 No violation
Joslin v. New Zealand (V) 902/1999 17 July 2002 No violation
Pezoldova v. Czech Republic (V) 757/1997 25 October 2002 Violation
Love et. al. v. Australia (V) 983/2001 25 March 2003 No violation
Kang v. Republic of Korea (V) 878/1999 15 July 2003 Violation
Boboli v. Spain (A) 1013/2002 3 July 2003 Inadmissible
Kristjánsson v. Iceland (A) 951/2000 16 July 2003 Inadmissible
Baumgarten v. Germany (V) 960/2000 31 July 2003 No violation
Hiro Balani v. Spain (A) 1021/2001 3 August 2003 Inadmissible
Rajan v. New Zealand (A) 820/1998 6 August 2003 Inadmissible
Young v. Australia (V) 941/2000 6 August 2003 Violation
Sineiro Fernández v. Spain (V) 1007/2001 7 August 2003 Violation
Althammer et al. v. Austria (V) 998/2001 8 August 2003 No violation
Hoyos v. Spain (A) 1008/2001 30 March 2004 Inadmissible
Barcaiztegui v. Spain (A) 1019/2001 30 March 2004 Inadmissible
Derksen v. The Netherlands (V) 976/2001 1 April 2004 Violation
Brandsma v. The Netherlands (A) 977/2001 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Petersen v. Germany (A) 1115/2002 1 April 2004 Inadmissible
Guido Jacobs v. Belgium (V) 943/2000 7 July 2004 No Violation
G. Pohl et al. v. Austria (V) 1160/2003 9 July 2004 No Violation
Borzov v. Estonia (V) 1136/2002 26 July 2004 No Violation
Deisl v. Austria (V) 1060/2002 27 July 2004 No Violation
Chanderbali v. Austria (A) 944/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible
Riedl-Riedenstein v. Germany (A) 1188/2003 2 November 2004 Inadmissible
Jazairi v. Canada (A) 958/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible
Mariano Gallego v. Spain (A) 988/2001 3 November 2004 Inadmissible
Terrón Jesús v. Spain (V) 1073/2002 5 November 2004 Violation
Olavi v. Finland 1076/2002 15 March 2005 No Violation
Radosevic v. Germany(A) 1292/2004 22 July 2005 Inadmissible
de Vos v. The Netherlands(A) 1192/2003 25 July 2005 Inadmissible
Marik v. Czech Republic (V) 945/2000 26 July 2005 Violation
Immaculate Joseph et al. v. Sri Lanka 1249/2004 21 October 2005 Violation
Kříž v. Czech Republic (V) 1054/2002 1 November 2005 Violation
Jongenburger-Veerman v. The Netherlands (V) 1238/2004 1 November 2005 No Violation
Castell-Ruiz v. Spain (V) 1164/2003 17 March 2006 No Violation
Blaga v. Romania (V) 1158/2003 30 March 2006 Violation
O'Neill and Quinn v. Ireland (V) 1314/2004 24 July 2006 No Violation
X v. Colombia (V) 1361/2005 30 March 2007 Violation
Polacek v. Czech Republic (V) 1447/2006 24 July 2007 Violation

Haraldsson and Sveinsson v. Iceland (V)

1306/2004

24 October 2007

Violation
Gratzinger v. Czech Republic (V) 1463/2006 25 October 2007 Violation
Tsarjov v. Estonia (V) 1223/2003 26 October 2007 No Violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation

Zdenek and Ondracka v. Czech Republic (V)

1533/2006

31 October 2007

Violation
Schmidl v. Germany (A) 1516/2003 31 October 2007 Inadmissible
Lnenicka v. Czech Republic (V) 1484/2006 25 March 2008 Violation
Süsser v. Czech Republic (V) 1488/2006 25 March 2008 Violation
Šipin v. Estonia (V) 1423/2005 9 July 2008 No violation
Vlček v. Czech Republic (V) 1485/2006 10 July 2008 Violation
Kohoutek v. Czech Republic (V) 1448/2006 17 Juy 2008 Violation
Preiss v. Czech Republic (V) 1497/2006 17 Juy 2008 Violation
Dean v. New Zealand (V) 1512/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Amundson v. Czech Republic (V) 1508/2006 17 March 2009 Violation
Vassilari et al. v. Greece (V) 1570/2007 19 March 2009 No violation
Korneenko and Milinkevich v. Belarus (V) 1553/2007 20 March 2009 Violation
Persan v. Czech Republic (V) 1479/2006 24 March 2009 Violation
Slezák v. Czech Republic (V) 1574/2007 20 July 2009 Violation
Williams Lecraft v. Spain (V) 1493/2006 27 July 2009 Violation
Dvorak v. Czech Republic (A) 1614/2007 28 July 2009 Inadmissible
Marz v. Russian Federation (V) 1425/2005 21 October 2009 No violation
Gonçalves et al. v. Portugal (V) 1565/2007 18 March 2010 No violation
Zavrel v. Czech Republic (V) 1615/2007 27 July 2010 Violation
Wahlstatt v. Czech Republic 1491/2006 27 July 2010 Violation
Gschwind v Czech Republic 1742/2007 27 July 2010 Violation
Sudalenko v. Belarus (V) 1354/2005 19 October 2010 Violation
Umarov v. Uzbekistan (V) 1449/2006 19 October 2010 Violation
Machado Bartolomeu v. Portugal (V) 1783/2008 19 October 2010 No violation
Drda v. Czech Republic (V) 1581/2007 27 October 2010 Violation
Lange v. Czech Republic (V) 1586/2007 13 July 2011 Violation
L. N. P. v. Argentina (V) 1610/2007 18 July 2011 Violation
Klain and Klain v. Czech Republic (V) 1847/2008 1 November 2011 Violation

ARTICLE 27


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lovelace v. Canada (V) 24/1977
(R.6/24)		 30 July 1981 Violation
Kitok v. Sweden (V) 197/1985 27 July 1988 No violation
T.K. v. France (A) 220/1987 8 November 1989 Inadmissible
M.K. v. France (A) 222/1987 8 November 1989 Inadmissible
Lubicon Lake Band v.Canada (V) 167/1984 26 March 1990 Violation
Ballantyne, Davidson and McIntyre v. Canada (V) 359 &385/1989 31 March 1993 Violation
Sara et al. v. Finland (A) 431/1990 23 March 1994 Inadmissible
Länsman et al. v. Finland (V) 511/1992 26 October 1994 No violation
Länsman et al. v. Finland (V) 671/1995 30 October 1996 No violation
Diergaardt et al. v. Namibia (V) 760/1997 25 July 2000 Violation
Mahuika et al. v. New Zealand (V) 547/1993 27 October 2000 No violation
Äärelä and Näkkäläjärvi v. Finland (V) 779/1997 24 October 2001 Violation
Länsman III v. Finland (V) 1023/2001 17 March 2005 No violation
Howard v. Canada (V) 879/1999 26 July 2005 No violation
Prince v. South Africa (V) 1474/2006 31 October 2007 No Violation
Mavlonov and Sa’di v. Uzbekistan (V) 1334/2004 19 March 2009 Violation
Poma v. Peru (V) 1457/2006 27 March 2009 Violation
Georgopoulos et al. v. Greece (V) 1799/2008 29 July 2010 Violation

ARTICLE 50


Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Pinkney v. Canada (V) 27/1977(R.7/27) 29 October 1981 Violation
Jazairi v. Canada (A) 958/2000 26 October 2004 Inadmissible
Minogue v. Australia (A) 954/2000 2 November 2004 Inadmissible