Bayefsky.com

The United Nations Human Rights Treaties

How To Complain About Human Rights Treaty Violations

Index of Cases of CERD by Article

Printer-friendly version

for cases by state party see Jurisprudence
to update generally see jurisprudence at: http://www.unhchr.ch/tbs/doc.nsf

A = admissibility decision

V = views


ARTICLE 1

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
L. R. et al. v. Slovakia (V) 31/2003 7 March 2005 Violation
Goekce v. Austria (V) 5/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Yildirim v. Austria (V) 6/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
P.S.N. v. Denmark (A) 36/2006 8 August 2007 Inadmissible
A.W.R.A.P. v. Denmark (A) 37/2006 8 August 2007 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 1(1)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Diop v. France (V) 2/1989 18 March 1991 No violation
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 1(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Diop v. France (A) 2/1989 22 August 1990 Admissible
Diop v. France (V) 2/1989 18 March 1991 No violation
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 1(3)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 1(4)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 2

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
E. I. F. v The Netherlands (V) 15/1999 21 March 2001 No violation
Lacko v. Slovakia (V) 11/1998 9 August 2001 No violation

ARTICLE 2(1)(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
L. R. et al. v. Slovakia (V) 31/2003 7 March 2005 Violation
Goekce v. Austria (V) 5/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Yildirim v. Austria (V) 6/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
D.F. v. Australia (V) 39/2006 22 February 2008 No violation
D.R. v. Australia (V) 42/2008 14 August 2009 No violation
M. v. Russian Federation (A) 55/2014 7 August 2015 Inadmissible
V.S. v. Slovakia (V) 56/2014 4 December 2015 Violation
Benon Pjetri v. Switzerland (V) 53/2013 5 December 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 2(1)(c)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Hagan v. Australia (V) 26/2002 20 March 2003 Violation
Goekce v. Austria (V) 5/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Yildirim v. Austria (V) 6/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
V.S. v. Slovakia (V) 56/2014 4 December 2015 Violation
Benon Pjetri v. Switzerland (V) 53/2013 5 December 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 2(1(d)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Habassi v. Denmark (V) 10/1997 17 March 1999 Violation
Ahmad v. Denmark (V) 16/1999 13 March 2000 Violation
M.B. v. Denmark (V) 20/2000 13 March 2002 No violation
Quereshi v. Denmark (V) 33/2003 9 March 2005 No violation
Sefic v. Denmark (V) 32/2003 7 March 2005 No violation
Gelle v. Denmark (V) 34/2004 6 March 2006 Violation
Goekce v. Austria (V) 5/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Yildirim v. Austria (V) 6/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Er v. Denmark (V) 40/2007 8 August 2007 Violation
Jama v. Denmark 41/2008 21 August 2009 No violation
Adan v. Denmark (V) 43/2008 13 August 2010 Violation
Hermansen et al. (A) 44/2009 13 August 2010 Inadmissible
Dawas and Shava v. Denmark (V) 46/2009 6 March 2012 Violation
V.S. v. Slovakia (V) 56/2014 4 December 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 2(1)(e)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Goekce v. Austria (V) 5/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Yildirim v. Austria (V) 6/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
V.S. v. Slovakia (V) 56/2014 4 December 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 2(1)(f)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Goekce v. Austria (V) 5/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Yildirim v. Austria (V) 6/2005 6 August 2007 Violation

ARTICLE 2(2)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation
V.S. v. Slovakia (V) 56/2014 4 December 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 2(6)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Laurent Gabre Gabaroum v. France (A) 52/2012 10 May 2016 Violation

ARTICLE 3

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Lacko v. Slovakia (V) 11/1998 9 August 2001 No violation
Goekce v. Austria (V) 5/2005 6 August 2007 Violation
Yildirim v. Austria (V) 6/2005 6 August 2007 Violation

ARTICLE 4

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Yilmaz-Dogan v. The Netherlands (V) 1/1984 10 August 1988 Violation
Lacko v. Slovakia (V) 11/1998 9 August 2001 No violation
Quereshi v. Denmark (V) 33/2003 9 March 2005 No violation
The Jewish community of Oslo et al. v. Norway 30/2003 15 August 2005 Violation
Gelle v. Denmark (V) 34/2004 6 March 2006 Violation
P.S.N. v. Denmark (A) 36/2006 8 August 2007 Inadmissible
A.W.R.A.P. v. Denmark (A) 37/2006 8 August 2007 Inadmissible
Er v. Denmark (V) 40/2007 8 August 2007 Violation
Jama v. Denmark 41/2008 21 August 2009 No violation
Adan v. Denmark (V) 43/2008 13 August 2010 Violation
Adan v. Denmark (V) 43/2008 13 August 2010 Violation
A.S. v. Russian Federation (A) 45/2009 26 August 2011 Inadmissible
TBB v. Germany (V) 48/2010 26 February 2013 Violation

ARTICLE 4(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
L. K. v. The Netherlands (V) 4/1991 16 March 1993 Violation
Zentralrat Deutscher Sinti und Roma et al. v. Germany (V) 38/2006 22 February 2008 No violation

ARTICLE 4(b)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Kamal Quereshi v. Denmark (V) 27/2002 19 August 2003 No violation

ARTICLE 4(c)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 5

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
E. I. F. v The Netherlands (V) 15/1999 21 March 2001 No violation
Lacko v. Slovakia (V) 11/1998 9 August 2001 No violation
Hagan v. Australia (V) 26/2002 20 March 2003 Violation
Sefic v. Denmark (V) 32/2003 7 March 2005 No violation
The Jewish community of Oslo et al. v. Norway 30/2003 15 August 2005 Violation
A.S. v. Russian Federation (A) 45/2009 26 August 2011 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 5(a)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Narrainen v. Norway (V) 3/1991 15 March 1994 No violation
Z. U. B. S. v Australia (V) 6/1995 26 August 1999 No violation
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation
M. v. Russian Federation (A) 55/2014 7 August 2015 Inadmissible
Benon Pjetri v. Switzerland (V) 53/2013 5 December 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 5(b)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 5(c)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Z. U. B. S. v. Australia (A) 6/1995 19 August 1997 Admissible

ARTICLE 5(d(i))

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Koptova v. Slovakia (V) 13/1998 8 August 2000 Violation
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation

ARTICLE 5(d(iii))

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
L. R. et al. v. Slovakia (V) 31/2003 7 March 2005 Violation
D.R. v. Australia (V) 42/2008 14 August 2009 No violation
Benon Pjetri v. Switzerland (V) 53/2013 5 December 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 5(e)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Diop v. France (V) 2/1989 18 March 1991 No violation

ARTICLE 5(e(i))

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Yilmaz-Dogan v. The Netherlands (V) 1/1984 10 August 1988 Violation
B. M. S. v. Australia (A) 8/1996 19 August 1997 Admissible
Z. U. B. S. v Australia (V) 6/1995 26 August 1999 No violation
V.S. v. Slovakia (V) 56/2014 4 December 2015 Violation

ARTICLE 5(e(iv))

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
D.F. v. Australia (V) 39/2006 22 February 2008 No violation
D.R. v. Australia (V) 42/2008 14 August 2009 No violation

ARTICLE 5(e)(v)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Er v. Denmark (V) 40/2007 8 August 2007 Violation
D.R. v. Australia (V) 42/2008 14 August 2009 No violation

ARTICLE 5(f)

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Durmic v. Serbia and Montenegro (V) 29/2003 6 March 2006 Violation
Hermansen et al. (A) 44/2009 13 August 2010 Inadmissible

ARTICLE 6

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
Yilmaz-Dogan v. The Netherlands (V) 1/1984 10 August 1988 Violation
L. K. v. The Netherlands (V) 4/1991 16 March 1993 Violation
C. P. and M. P. v. Denmark (A) 5/1994 15 March 1995 Inadmissible
Habassi v. Denmark (V) 10/1997 17 March 1999 Violation
Ahmad v. Denmark (V) 16/1999 13 March 2000 Violation
B. J. v. Denmark (V) 17/1999 17 March 2000 No violation
E. I. F. v The Netherlands (V) 15/1999 21 March 2001 No violation
Lacko v. Slovakia (V) 11/1998 9 August 2001 No violation
Hagan v. Australia (V) 26/2002 20 March 2003 Violation
Kamal Quereshi v. Denmark (V) 27/2002 19 August 2003 No violation
L. R. et al. v. Slovakia (V) 31/2003 7 March 2005 Violation
Sefic v. Denmark (V) 32/2003 7 March 2005 No violation
Quereshi v. Denmark (V) 33/2003 9 March 2005 No violation
The Jewish community of Oslo et al. v. Norway 30/2003 15 August 2005 Violation
Durmic v. Serbia and Montenegro (V) 29/2003 6 March 2006 Violation
Gelle v. Denmark (V) 34/2004 6 March 2006 Violation
Er v. Denmark (V) 40/2007 8 August 2007 Violation
Zentralrat Deutscher Sinti und Roma et al. v. Germany (V) 38/2006 22 February 2008 No violation
Jama v. Denmark 41/2008 21 August 2009 No violation
Adan v. Denmark (V) 43/2008 13 August 2010 Violation
Hermansen et al. (A) 44/2009 13 August 2010 Inadmissible
A.S. v. Russian Federation (A) 45/2009 26 August 2011 Inadmissible
Dawas and Shava v. Denmark (V) 46/2009 6 March 2012 Violation
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation
M. v. Russian Federation (A) 55/2014 7 August 2015 Inadmissible
V.S. v. Slovakia (V) 56/2014 4 December 2015 Violation
Benon Pjetri v. Switzerland (V) 53/2013 5 December 2016 No violation

ARTICLE 7

Name of case Comm. No. Date of Decision Outcome
E. I. F. v The Netherlands (V) 15/1999 21 March 2001 No violation
Hagan v. Australia (V) 26/2002 20 March 2003 Violation
A.M.M. v. Switzerland (A) 50/2012 18 February 2014 No violation