Bayefsky.com

The United Nations Human Rights Treaties

Jurisprudence

CCPR - Spain

Complete list of decisions

Case Name Comm Number Date Articles Outcome
M. I. T. v. Spain 310/1988 11 April 1991   Inadmissible
V. E. M. v. Spain 467/1991 16 July 1993   Inadmissible
Griffin v. Spain 493/1992 11 October 1993   Admissible
A. P. A. v. Spain 433/1990 25 March 1994   Inadmissible
Pons v. Spain 454/1991 30 June 1994   Admissible
Santacana v. Spain 417/1990 15 July 1994 23(1, 4), 24(1) No Violation
Griffin v. Spain 493/1992 04 April 1995 9(2), 10(1,2),14 (3,f) Violation
Pons v. Spain 454/1991 30 October 1995 14(1), 26 No Violation
V. E. M. v. Spain 656/1995 30 October 1995   Inadmissible
Hill v. Spain 526/1993 02 April 1997 9(2, 3), 10, 14(1, 2, 3b,c,d,5) Violation
Bonelo v. Spain 698/1996 29 July 1997   Inadmissible
Navarro v. Spain 758/1997 29 July 1997   Inadmissible
Sánchez López v. Spain 777/1997 18 October 1999 14 (2, 3g) Inadmissible
Gómez v. Spain 701/1996 20 July 2000 14(5), 26 Violation
Torregrosa Lafuente et al. v. Spain 866/1999 16 July 2001 14(1), 26 Inadmissible
Asensio López v. Spain 905/2000 23 July 2001   Inadmissible
Marín Gómez v. Spain 865/1999 22 October 2001 25(c), 26 No Violation
Sánchez González v. Spain 1005/2001 21 March 2002   Inadmissible
Ruiz Agudo v. Spain 864/1999 31 October 2002 14(1, 3c, 5) Violation
Estevill v. Spain 1004/2001 25 March 2003   Inadmissible
Hiro Balani v. Spain 1021/2001 28 March 2003 26 Inadmissible
Boboli v. Spain 1013/2002 30 July 2003 26 Inadmissible
Semey v. Spain 986/2001 30 July 2003 14 (1, 5) Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain 956/2000 07 August 2003 14(1, 5) Inadmissible
Sineiro Fernández v. Spain 1007/2001 07 August 2003 14(2, 5), 26 Violation
Martínez Muñoz v.Spain 1006/2001 30 October 2003 14(1, 3c) Violation
Hoyos v. Spain 1008/2001 30 March 2004 26 Inadmissible
Barcaiztegui v. Spain 1019/2001 30 March 2004 26 Inadmissible
Sanlés Sanlés v. Spain 1024/2001 30 March 2004 14(1) Inadmissible
Navarra Ferragut v. Spain 1074/2002 31 March 2004   Inadmissible
Everett v. Spain 961/2000 09 July 2004 9(1), 14(2, 3), 23(1) Inadmissible
Alba Cabriada v. Spain 1101/2002 01 November 2004 14(5) Violation
Mariano Gallego v. Spain 988/2001 03 November 2004 26 Inadmissible
Terrón Jesús v. Spain 1073/2002 05 November 2004 14(5), 26 Violation
Marín v. Spain 1099/2002 17 March 2005   Inadmissible
Guillén v. Spain 1092/2002 29 March 2005   Inadmissible
Martínez v. Spain 1104/2002 29 March 2005 14(5) Violation
Parra Corral v. Spain 1356/2005 29 March 2005 14(5) Inadmissible
Álvarez Fernández v. Spain 860/1999 31 March 2005   Inadmissible
Martínez II v. Spain 1097/2002 21 July 2005   Inadmissible
Gomaríz v. Spain 1095/2002 22 July 2005 14(3g,5) Violation
Pérez Munuera & Hernández
Mateo v. Spain		 1329-1330/2004 25 July 2005   Inadmissible
Calvet v. Spain 1333/2004 25 July 2005   Inadmissible
Bertelli v. Spain 1389/2005 25 July 2005   Inadmissible
Cuartero Casado v. Spain 1399/2005 25 July 2005 14(5) Inadmissible
López v. Spain 1105/2002 26 July 2005 14(1) Inadmissible
Morote Vidal and Mazón Costa v.
Spain		 1326/2004 26 July 2005   Inadmissible
Carvallo Villar v. Spain 1059/2002 28 October 2005   Inadmissible
Lozano v. Spain 1323/2004 28 October 2005 14(5) Inadmissible
Fernández v. Spain 1396/2005 28 October 2005   Inadmissible
Castell-Ruiz et al. v. Spain 1164/2003 17 March 2006 26 No Violation
Herrara v. Spain 1094/2002 27 March 2006   Inadmissible
Semey Joe Johnson v. Spain 1102/2002 27 March 2006   Inadmissible
Puertas v. Spain 1183/2003 27 March 2006 14(1) Inadmissible
Escolar v. Spain 1156/2003 28 March 2006 14(5) No Violation
Olivero v. Spain 1211/2003 11 July 2006 14(5) Violation
Kurbogaj v. Spain 1374/2005 14 July 2006   Inadmissible
De Dios v. Spain 1293/2004 25 July 2006   Inadmissible
Garcia v. Spain 1441/2005 25 July 2006   Inadmissible
Oubiña v. Spain 1387/2005 25 July 2006   Inadmissible
Rovira v. Spain 1444/2006 25 July 2006   Inadmissible
Lanzarote v. Spain 1212/2003 25 July 2006   Inadmissible
Castano v. Spain 1313/2004 25 July 2006   Inadmissible
Rodríquez José v. Spain 1093/2002 25 July 2006   Inadmissible
Martínez v. Spain 1098/2002 31 October 2006   Inadmissible
Villamón v. Spain 1305/2004 31 October 2006 14(5) Inadmissible
Conde v. Spain 1325/2004 31 October 2006 14(5) Violation
Sánchez and Clares v. Spain 1332/2004 31 October 2006 14(5) Violation
Amador v. Spain 1181/2003 31 October 2006 14(5) No Violation
González Cruz v. Spain 1151/2003 01 November 2006 14(1) Inadmissible
Esposito v. Spain 1359/2005 20 March 2007   Inadmissible
Rodríguez and Sánchez v. Spain 1213/2003 28 March 2007 14(1) Inadmissible
González and Muñoz v. Spain 1370/2005 24 July 2007   Inadmissible
Roussev v. Spain 1386/2005 24 July 2007   Inadmissible
Roche and Hernandez v. Spain 1370/2005 24 July 2007   Inadmissible
Rodrigo v. Spain 1391/2005 24 July 2007   Inadmissible
Moreno v. Spain 1381/2005 25 July 2007 14(5) Violation
Serena and Rodríguez v. Spain 1351/2005 and 1352/2005 25 March 2008 14(5) Violation
Asensi v. Spain 1413/2005 25 March 2008 14(1) No Violation
Beisti v. Spain 1375/2005 01 April 2008   Inadmissible
Conde v. Spain 1527/2006 01 April 2008   Inadmissible
Murcia v. Spain 1528/2006 01 April 2008   Inadmissible
Costa v. Spain 1745/2007 01 April 2008   Inadmissible
Piñeiro v. Spain 1360/2005 03 April 2008 14(5) Violation
Y. v. Spain 1456/2006 24 July 2008 14(1) No Violation
Castedo v. Spain 1122/2002 20 October 2008 14(1) Violation
Rodríguez v. Spain 1489/2006 30 October 2008   Inadmissible
Martínez v. Spain 1490/2006 30 October 2008   Inadmissible
Castro v. Spain 1388/2005 19 March 2009 9(1) No Violation
Tornel et al. v. Spain 1473/2006 20 March 2009 2(3a), 6(1), 17(1) Violation
Perea v. Spain 1511/2006 27 March 2009   Inadmissible
Uclés v. Spain 1364/2005 22 July 2009 2(3a), 14(5) Violation
Piscioneri v. Spain 1366/2005 22 July 2009 14(5) No Violation
Williams Lecraft v. Spain 1493/2006 27 July 2009 2(3), 26 Violation
Hill v. Spain 1550/2007 28 July 2009   Inadmissible
Gayoso Martínez v. Spain 1363/2005 19 October 2009 2(3)(a), 14(5) Violation
Possemiers v. Spain 1398/2005 20 October 2009 14(5) No Violation
Rodríguez Domínguez et al. v. Spain 1471/2006 27 October 2009   Inadmissible
Suils Ramonet v. Spain 1555/2007 27 October 2009   Inadmissible
Seto Martinez v. Spain 1624/2007 19 March 2010 11 Inadmissible
Barrionuevo Álvarez and Bernabé Pérez v. Spain 1794/2008 19 March 2010   Inadmissible
Sanjuán v. Spain 1869/2009 26 July 2010   Inadmissible
L. G. M. v. Spain 1617/2007 26 July 2011   Inadmissible
L. D. L. P. v. Spain 1622/2007 26 July 2011   Inadmissible
Cunillera Arias v. Spain 1531/2006 27 July 2011 14(1) No Violation
L. O. P. v. Spain 1802/2008 31 October 2011   Inadmissible
J.A.B.G. v. Spain 1891/2009 29 October 2012 14 Inadmissible
J.J.U.B v. Spain 1892/2009 29 October 2012 14(5) Inadmissible
H.P.N. v. Spain 1943/2010 25 March 2013 7, 10, 14 (5,7) Inadmissible
Puertas v. Spain 1945/2010 27 March 2013 7 (2, 3) Violation
M.R.R. v. Spain 2037/2011 21 July 2014 14(5) Inadmissible
Aarass v. Spain 2008/2010 21 July 2014 2, 7, 9, 23, 26 Violation
Mora v. Spain 2070/2011 28 October 2014 14 Inadmissible
S.S.F., S.S.E. and E.J.S.E. v. Spain 2105/2011 28 October 2014 14(1)(5)(7) Inadmissible
A.G.S. v. Spain 2626/2015 02 November 2015 14(7) Inadmissible

Information in this section of Bayefsky.com is as of May 2018. To update use the UN website search engine here.

CERD, CCPR, CESCR, CEDAW, CAT, CRC, CMW, CRPD and CED all have optional complaint mechanisms, whereby an individual may complain to the respective treaty body that his or her rights under the treaty have been violated. The CMW complaint mechanism is not yet in force.

Included in this section are:

  1. requests made by the treaty body for interim measures
  2. decisions to deal jointly with cases
  3. admissibility decisions (normally decisions determining a complaint is admissible are not issued separately and hence this category involves decisions in which complaints are found to be inadmissible)
  4. final views.

Information on follow-up of final Views where a violation has been found is included in the section entitled "Follow-up: Jurisprudence".